• NeuromancerM
    link
    fedilink
    -53 months ago

    Lincoln was a conservative himself. He described himself as a conservative and historians Label him as one. In the speech you cited, he was speaking as a conservative to other conservatives.

    Democrats owned slaves. Democrats still want to own slaves.

    • Zeppo
      link
      fedilink
      63 months ago

      Ending slavery is not a conservative position by definition. Conservatism means continuing the system that is currently in place and accepted.

      • NeuromancerM
        link
        fedilink
        -43 months ago

        Ending slavery is a conservative value. Since we believe all men are equal, slavery by default insults that position.

        • Zeppo
          link
          fedilink
          13 months ago

          Are you sure you’re a conservative? Most conservative views are insulting. But back in real life, it was a deeply ingrained institution at the time.

          • NeuromancerM
            link
            fedilink
            -23 months ago

            I am very conservative. The Republican party was started to end slavery. Lincoln was a conservative. Before joining the Republican Party he was conservative Whig. Republicans have always stood up for freedom and individual rights. In the 80’s we picked up the religious right which skewed some stances but I’m not part of the religious right.

            • Zeppo
              link
              fedilink
              23 months ago

              I don’t think there’s much use in explaining this, but you don’t seem to have a very good grasp of history. Party names are not the key to ideology, and it’s baffling that people think they can compare politics from 180 and 120 years ago using current concepts. If you think modern Republicans are the party of Lincoln, let’s see… who would we see flying Confederate flags currently?

                • Zeppo
                  link
                  fedilink
                  13 months ago

                  Kind of a weird dodge… I’ll just answer the rhetorical question for you. So, people who currently fly confederate flags are uniformly Republican and identify as conservative.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1
                  edit-2
                  3 months ago

                  Good.point.

                  This is the same reason I don’t trust any Italians from Rome. Those Romans are always going around waging wars of conquest, demanding tributes, look what they did to Carthage! I still hold them dang Romans responsible for all those crucifixions. Horrible!

                  And don’t even get me started on those Hittites! Constantly conquering people, they had slaves too! Just as bad as the democrats if not worse. Whenever I meet an Assyrian I like to personally thank them for taking care of those Hittite bastards.

                  • NeuromancerM
                    link
                    fedilink
                    -13 months ago

                    Weird, I never knew Rome was a political party. I always thought it was a city.

        • @Zombiepirate
          link
          53 months ago

          Your profile says you’re a conservative and a fascist? @neuromancer said before they’re incompatible, and he’s a conservative.

          He also says Lincoln was a conservative.

          Why do you both say the opposite? Is conservatism so meaningless that such fundamental differences are just ignored?

          Why do you think conservatives deny that fascists are part of their movement when they clearly are?

          • link
            fedilink
            -23 months ago

            @Zombiepirate

            As to what conservatism is, I write about that a lot:

            https://www.amerika.org/

            It is a focus on order beyond the individual and the social group; we call it realism, and it tends to favor historically-proven results and a case-by-case basis instead of ideological categorical containers.

            About ten thousand people in North America can successfully parse that sentence.

          • link
            fedilink
            -23 months ago

            @Zombiepirate

            Fascists are hybrids. Fascism is corporatism, i.e. state control through corporations.

            What does my profile say?

            “Furthest Right: raging realism plus transcendental reverence. I write at https://www.amerika.org/ and https://www.deathmetal.org/ about topics such as nihilism, ecofascism, paganism, eugenics, capitalism, perennialism, conservatism, natural selection, and of course death metal.”

            Ecofascism is a separate movement. You read your Linkola and Kaczynski?

            Full readout here:
            https://annihilation.social/notice/AgRr091ay4W0HCTtcu

            Lincoln was a radical. He, too, was a hybrid, in that he came from the Anglo tradition but was outside of it as a “radical.”

            He was a progressive of his age. He was closer to Marx than Washington.

            • @Zombiepirate
              link
              23 months ago

              So you’re saying that fascists and conservatives work to similar ends?

              • link
                fedilink
                -13 months ago

                @Zombiepirate

                The most conservative society:

                * Absolute monarchy
                * Ethno-nationalist
                * Free market based
                * Caste system
                * Culture/religion united

                Like anything else, there are degrees of conservatism.

                Some conservatives, like GWB, are barely conservative.

              • link
                fedilink
                -23 months ago

                @Zombiepirate

                Fascists still believe in the State; conservatives are free market devotees but ambivalent if not hostile to the State.

                • @Zombiepirate
                  link
                  2
                  edit-2
                  3 months ago

                  Not all conservatives are free market devotees; that’s a modern twist that is not universal.

                  But you agree that they work to the same ends?

                  • link
                    fedilink
                    -13 months ago

                    @Zombiepirate

                    I disagree. Conservatives naturally favor organic methods like common law, free markets, culture, and hierarchy.

                    As far as work to the same ends, I think you have it backwards. Fascism is a hybrid. It borrows some goals and methods from both Left and Right.

      • NeuromancerM
        link
        fedilink
        -43 months ago

        I get you don’t read well but see how Lincoln uses the word we. It’s including himself. Lincoln was a conservative. He was a Republican.

        Lincoln was not a progressive.