A former Twitter employee, Gary Rooney, won about $600,000 for unfair dismissal after Twitter assumed he resigned by not responding to Elon Musk’s “hardcore” work email.

The case highlighted the importance of clear communication between employers and employees, especially regarding significant changes in employment terms.

Rooney’s private Slack messages, where he discussed leaving, were used as evidence by Twitter, underscoring that internal communication on platforms like Slack is not always private and can be used in legal disputes.

  • @Paddzr
    link
    957 days ago

    But people don’t understand it.

    Hell, no email sent or received is yours and likely can never be truly deleted off your company’s exchsnge. Same with files etc.

    It’s not common knowledge, let’s not pretend it is and educate people.

    • @QuarterSwede
      link
      186 days ago

      True that. I have to tell employees regularly to not send any chat or email they don’t want read in court. That usually gets the point across.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        46 days ago

        I hope I get to read mine someday, I really wanna say

        it’s okay to be an idiot, just don’t be so fucking loud about it…uhhh… your honor

    • bluGill
      link
      fedilink
      -137 days ago

      Most companies have a strict policy to delete everything off of exchange after a few months unless there is a reason to keep it longer. You can’t bring up in court anything that wan daleted before you looked.

      • @HeyJoe
        link
        277 days ago

        I don’t think that’s true. We archive all email within the company as soon as it arrives. This is done to prevent an employee from deleting any evidence for many reasons that they may have. We are also on litigation hold which requires all data to be saved and since we can’t trust everyone to do this we are required to back up everything until we are told not to. We have used restored data many times for legal cases in the past.

        • @linearchaos
          link
          English
          116 days ago

          No he’s actually right, it’s a SOX thing. Not all companies do it but big ones with good legal departments generally do. Especially if they’re into shady s***.

          The concept rules like this: we delete all emails over 90 days old. If someone subpoena’s emails over 90 days old we simply say they don’t exist we delete emails over 90 days old and show them the policy. From there it gets a little more dicey if people cram stuff into local stores.

          From a corporate standpoint there’s a strong advantage to deleting all of your old emails and not keeping backups over 90 days especially for anything that might be legally questionable.

          That said with the advent of SAAS, there’s a hell of a lot of data out there that doesn’t ever go away even if you do your best to make it happen.

        • @ByteJunk
          link
          127 days ago

          Where I work there is a data retention policy, and emails and other forms of communication (internal emails and slack, but even customer calls, etc) are deleted after a set amount of time, which varies depending on the rationale for storing that data.

          There’s many reasons to do this - limit disclosure issues in case of litigation, reduce storage costs, comply with PII rules around the world, etc. The guys in Legal have us file these loong ass forms about all this, including where the data is kept, security measures, etc etc etc.

          I’m shocked this isn’t common practice everywhere.

          • @Silic0n_Alph4
            link
            157 days ago

            There are two main types of data retention policy:

            • Retain everything to protect the company when the staff do something dodgy.
            • Delete everything to protect management when management do something dodgy.

            It’s a little more nuanced than that, of course, but in broad strokes that’s how I’ve seen it play out. Does the company want to pin the blame on somebody or shrug and say “we have no idea how that can have happened, guess we need to forget about it.”

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            16 days ago

            I think that’s an understandable position but IT is ruled in a cost benefit analysis for many small to medium sized businesses, so I am sure if it’s as common practice there

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        46 days ago

        I’ve contracted for companies with email policies that nuke anything older than 30 days.

        I typically learn it the hard way when I go back to look for an email I need and…it has been deleted.