ISPs say Sony's win over Cox would force them to do "mass Internet evictions."

Four more large Internet service providers told the US Supreme Court this week that ISPs shouldn’t be forced to aggressively police copyright infringement on broadband networks.

While the ISPs worry about financial liability from lawsuits filed by major record labels and other copyright holders, they also argue that mass terminations of Internet users accused of piracy “would harm innocent people by depriving households, schools, hospitals, and businesses of Internet access.” The legal question presented by the case “is exceptionally important to the future of the Internet,” they wrote in a brief filed with the Supreme Court on Monday.

  • @BluefruitEnglish
    109•2 months ago

    Not everyday i agree with ISPs but here we are. Guilty of and accused of are two very different things. Innocent until proven guilty.

    • @Lost_My_MindEnglish
      40•2 months ago

      Hell, I don’t even want to ban users guilty of piracy. Oh no! Sony and it’s BILLIONS of dollars will surely be affected by pirating their dvd of a movie! Heavens to betsy!

      • sunzu2
        16•2 months ago

        You joke but that’s how Sony feels when you buy a used DVD… They just can’t admit it publicly

        • @Lost_My_MindEnglish
          15•2 months ago

          They must HATE me…There’s a thrift shop just up the street from me. I bought Deadpool on DVD/Bluray combo pack. Still sealed new from factory, for $2.50.

          I buy lots of DVDs there. My sisters say my collection is rediculous. She means it in a bad way, like I need to get rid of some stuff. But hell, when it’s $2.50, why NOT buy like 20 movies in an afternoon? And why NOT do that same thing several times a year? Although I will admit I’m running out of room…help! My apartment is filled with DVDs, and I can’t see the walls anymore!

          • @acetanilideEnglish
            6•2 months ago

            I aspire to be like you! I finally am going to have a DVD player and I am absolutely THRILLED. No joke. It’s going to be fantastic.

            Not as fantastic as an old VCR since it’s like 2% harder to fast forward through the ads. But pretty close!

          • @[email protected]English
            3•2 months ago

            Next step: rip them all to a NAS and install something like Jellyfin. That way you can enjoy all of that content, but without having to swap discs.

            That’s what I did, and now everything sits in a box hidden away somewhere in case my NAS dies or something.

      • ObjectivityIncarnateEnglish
        5•2 months ago

        Hell, I don’t even want to ban users guilty of piracy.

        Yeah, if someone shoplifts from a store, the punishment/penalty should not involve confiscating the car they drove to the store, lol.

    • @j4k3English
      13•2 months ago

      Not for potato supreme. I’m sure labels and sony bought vacations for those sub human coup supporting shits

      • @[email protected]English
        18•2 months ago

        Never dehumanize fascists or fascist-sympathizers (redundant but ok), it’s always important to remember that bad faith actors or their stooges are human and cannot be entirely eliminated from society, which is why people that fight for positive change have to set the rules such that bad faith actors’ actions are either quickly recognized and mitigated, or have society structured such that even those motivated solely by unempathetic selfishness can only achieve status by masking and contributing positively anyway.

      • @BluefruitEnglish
        1•2 months ago

        I am not familiar with that, I’m guessing potato supreme is a username or something?