• @NotMyOldRedditName
    link
    English
    34
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    Of all the games they try to demonize, they demonize a game type people have played at home for decades at parties, in person, with no computers.

    Brilliant.

    90s house party game here, I’m sure people played it earlier.

    • @jqubed
      link
      English
      61 month ago

      Not too much earlier; Wikipedia says the game was invented in 1986 by psychology student Dimitry Davidoff, a psychology student at Moscow State University.

      • @NotMyOldRedditName
        link
        English
        51 month ago

        Interesting, had no idea about its origin story.

        Also… of course

        In June 2006 a Rockingham school inquiry was launched after parents complained of the traumatic effects classroom Mafia was having on their fifth-grade children. Davidoff responded to the reports, saying that as a parent who had studied child psychology for 25 years, he felt that the game could “teach kids to distinguish right from wrong”, and that the positive message of being honest could overcome the negative effects of an “evil narrator” moderating the game as if it were a scary story.

        • @jqubed
          link
          English
          126 days ago

          If you enjoy the game you should check out The Traitors with its many international variants. I was surprised to read that the productions provide psychologists to help the contestants as it gets traumatic, but when I watched the first UK season there were a lot of people getting into emotional distress.

          There have been a lot of people cast who really shouldn’t be on the show; it’s just a game!

            • @jqubed
              link
              English
              121 days ago

              The biggest difference of the TV show versus the home game is the home game just ends whenever all the killers are found. The TV show has to reach a set number of episodes, so there are mechanisms built-in to make sure there’s always at least one traitor up to the final episode.

              • @NotMyOldRedditName
                link
                English
                1
                edit-2
                21 days ago

                I actually did try watching a bit of it, and while I love the idea of it, I can’t stand the length they make it due to the reality tv show.

                It just drags on and on.

                If they’d made them 30-40 minute episodes instead of an hour I might have liked it.

                • @jqubed
                  link
                  English
                  118 days ago

                  I guess it depends which version you watch; I think the U.S. and Canada versions are 44 minutes without commercials, but yeah, it does have some filler. When someone’s actually good at the strategy it can be interesting hearing them talk through their plans.