Two conservative groups are asking a federal court to block the Biden administration’s plan to cancel $39 billion in student loans for more than 800,000 borrowers.
If it’s unfair, then I can see how you’d want to change the rules for future borrowers… but what seems unfair to me is changing the rules for past borrowers, especially once they’ve received the benefit of the loan.
If the loans are so unfair, why is the solution to cancel existing loans? Why not just prevent that injustice in the future? If the interest rates are so unfair that it has to affect existing contracts, what about compensating people who have fully paid off their loans? Should they be given some money back? If not, why not? If so, how far back would that go? And how much should they be given?
If someone can prove they were eligible to go to college / university but chose not to go because they knew these interest rates were unfair, should they be compensated? After all, you’re saying that in hindsight they were right to avoid these unfair contracts. But, if the people who went get the benefit of the degree at with a loan that turns out to be fair (because the outstanding balance is canceled, say), then it’s unfair to the people who made the smart choice with the information they had available at the time.
It seems to me that the only fair thing to do is to change the rules going forward. The people who agreed to an unfair deal in the past would have to live with their bad decisions.
I’m asking for both to fix the existing loans and stop giving out predatory ones. I never said I just wanted it to benefit my self. Even if I didn’t have plans I would support that. I want the whole thing fixed for everyone obviously
Also you keep saying “deal with their bad decisions” I don’t think you understand that these loans are pushed onto kids who are 18 the very first year they are eligible to sign a contract like that and usually it’s their very first one. The government comes a long with a horrible deal and that’s the only offer. If you want to go to school you take it. That’s predatory and it’s not ok. If you don’t have all the information you need to make the right decision you aren’t going to make the right one. It needs to stop. You act like people are stupid for wanting to better themselves and for listening to the advice of their parents and teachers.
If it’s unfair, then I can see how you’d want to change the rules for future borrowers… but what seems unfair to me is changing the rules for past borrowers, especially once they’ve received the benefit of the loan.
If the loans are so unfair, why is the solution to cancel existing loans? Why not just prevent that injustice in the future? If the interest rates are so unfair that it has to affect existing contracts, what about compensating people who have fully paid off their loans? Should they be given some money back? If not, why not? If so, how far back would that go? And how much should they be given?
If someone can prove they were eligible to go to college / university but chose not to go because they knew these interest rates were unfair, should they be compensated? After all, you’re saying that in hindsight they were right to avoid these unfair contracts. But, if the people who went get the benefit of the degree at with a loan that turns out to be fair (because the outstanding balance is canceled, say), then it’s unfair to the people who made the smart choice with the information they had available at the time.
It seems to me that the only fair thing to do is to change the rules going forward. The people who agreed to an unfair deal in the past would have to live with their bad decisions.
I’m asking for both to fix the existing loans and stop giving out predatory ones. I never said I just wanted it to benefit my self. Even if I didn’t have plans I would support that. I want the whole thing fixed for everyone obviously
Also you keep saying “deal with their bad decisions” I don’t think you understand that these loans are pushed onto kids who are 18 the very first year they are eligible to sign a contract like that and usually it’s their very first one. The government comes a long with a horrible deal and that’s the only offer. If you want to go to school you take it. That’s predatory and it’s not ok. If you don’t have all the information you need to make the right decision you aren’t going to make the right one. It needs to stop. You act like people are stupid for wanting to better themselves and for listening to the advice of their parents and teachers.