• jwiggler
    link
    fedilink
    01 year ago

    I don’t think they should be condemned to genocide, but I don’t think we should be sending them weapons. I think Biden should be talking to Putin in some capacity, which he is not. Radio silence. I think that exacerbates the war.

    I don’t think this weird moral imperative is real, like we’re America so we ought to do something. I don’t think that it’s real because, just like in Russia, where you’ve got an active conflict and you’ve got some Russian propaganda calling for the denazification (what you’ve correctly referred to as genocidal) you also have, in Israel, active conflict of genocidal nature between Israel against Palestinians, but we do nothing.

    So you’re saying, we, America should condemn Palestine to genocide? Or how about the Uhygur peoples? Should we engage in a proxy war with China? Certainly, according to your claims that otherwise we are dooming them to genocide by their occupying country.

    That moral imperative you’re talking about is fabricated, because if the US government actually cared about these people – Ukrainians, Palestinians, or Uhygur – we’d be sending military aid to all of them, or else we’d be “condemning them to genocide,” as you say.

    This aid is not going to Ukraine to help them endure genocidal forces. It’s going there to perpetuate our constant war economy that is reliant on conflict. It’s going there to unite the political party against an outside evil and to further the US geopolitical and global free-market goals.

    • @pedalmore
      link
      11 year ago

      Classic, of course you follow with whattaboutism. Like I said, we’ve seen the Russian talking point already. Next.

      Also the US isn’t single handedly supporting Ukraine. You need to dramatically increase your whattaboutism to cover the other 50 or so countries.

      • jwiggler
        link
        fedilink
        11 year ago

        Its just a lack of consistency, I don’t know what to tell you. You can’t tell me the US sends military aid to Ukraine in order to “defend democracy,” when in numerous other cases of sovereign countries being occupied, we do nothing, or we even support the occupiers, in Palestine’s case.

        This lack of consistency lends itself to the idea that there are further interests besides “defending democracy” for which we send Ukraine weapons. I’m not sure how else to put it. If it were about the moral imperative of defending occupied people’s, you can pick out numerous similar examples where we have not acted, and you just have to conclude that there are other factors behind the US sending aid to Ukraine. One is the perceived threat the country feels from Russia, which I think is probably exacerbated by the press. One is the perpetuation of the constant war economy we have, and one is the increased political unity that war brings.

        But I’m curious about your position, you’re dismissing my arguments as “whataboutism,” but what exactly would you assert instead? Do you think that Ukraine deserves our aid more than Palestine does? Is it that Russia is a grave threat to the United States? I’m genuinely curious

        • @pedalmore
          link
          11 year ago

          So if the US supported Palestine, you’d agree with the US supporting Ukraine? If so, real strong set of morality there. You’re fine with more suffering because of some perceived (not even real, as these are two totally different situations) logical inconsistency? If not, your argument is disingenuous. You can pick whichever position you want - they’re both shitty. Are you equally suspect of the other 4 dozen countries supporting Ukraine, or just the US?

          My position is super simple. Russia invaded Ukraine with literally zero justification and is attempting genocide. That’s bad. Ukraine deserves support to protect their people and their home. All your other bullshit is noise, because you’re trying to use unrelated events to cast doubt. Like I said, we all know the playbook of Russian apologia by now and can see right through this.