That’s really what I was thinking - that the graph probably wouldn’t change much if you remapped it to personal connections because the pattern of personal connections is probably what drives it in the first place. Hence my favorite musical era is when my connections peaked around age 30. Although tbh most of what I liked then and still do is what you would call “popular gunk” - never did care much for dismissing popularity as low quality. They often go together, but unpopularity and low quality also do.
There’s a reason why things are popular. People like it.
The only drawback is that to make a “Billboard #1” type hit, you need extremely broad appeal. So, often it’s stuff that nobody hates instead of something that people who know a certain niche genre absolutely adore. You’re unlikely to get a jazz song as a #1, or a twangy country song, or any song with lyrics that any group might find offensive,
That’s really what I was thinking - that the graph probably wouldn’t change much if you remapped it to personal connections because the pattern of personal connections is probably what drives it in the first place. Hence my favorite musical era is when my connections peaked around age 30. Although tbh most of what I liked then and still do is what you would call “popular gunk” - never did care much for dismissing popularity as low quality. They often go together, but unpopularity and low quality also do.
There’s a reason why things are popular. People like it.
The only drawback is that to make a “Billboard #1” type hit, you need extremely broad appeal. So, often it’s stuff that nobody hates instead of something that people who know a certain niche genre absolutely adore. You’re unlikely to get a jazz song as a #1, or a twangy country song, or any song with lyrics that any group might find offensive,