This is partially me getting stuff off my chest. This post isn’t a response to, but was partially inspired by a dumpster fire of a thread from a couple days ago that appears to be deleted now.

I was lucky enough to be raised going to a Lutheran church that was “one of the good ones.” Going through confirmation was my first formalized exposure to thinking philosophically in a way public schools don’t teach. It was through the lens of the Bible, but the discussions we had were on finding our own interpretations and meanings on what’s right. It’s where I learned the phrase “sin boldly,” something I’ve internalized to this day as accepting that I can’t be perfect but to keep moving forward. At the end I had to give a faith statement and told my pastor to his face that I wasn’t certain I believed in this God guy but I liked a lot of the lessons, and he was fine with that.

I’m pretty agnostic at this point, though I wouldn’t call myself atheist, but my religious experience has pretty much always been a good one. The last time I went to church a few years ago they outright welcomed gay, trans, and other oppressed people and offered opportunities to do good in the community.

Whenever I see online atheists hating on religion, my instinct is to get defensive because my experience with it has been good. But since I became an adult it’s also become clear to me that a lot of religious people suck and use their religion as a shield and a cudgel to act hatefully. Piping up and saying “not all religious people” rings about the same as saying “not all men” though, so I usually just don’t say anything, especially in explicitly atheist spaces. But I felt a need to express my feelings, and this seemed an appropriate way to do so.

  • UnderpantsWeevil
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    5
    arrow-down
    6
    ·
    3 days ago

    I got sucked into New Atheism in college, after being raised a Catholic as a kid. The movement was seductive on it’s face, because the personalities were big and the politics was in stark contrast to Evangelical Southerners running my country.

    But it ended up being very hollow. There was no organization, just a bunch of celebrities and influencers. There was no philosophy, just endless self-aggrandizing “debate”. There was no community, just blogs and message forums.

    Say what you will about Catholics, but there’s a big building you can go to. And there’s people in the building. And these are your neighbors, family, friends.

    Like, as I’ve gotten older and found it harder to socialize like I did in school or as a single guy at the office… I get the appeal, even if I’m still not a regular.

    • njm1314
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      16
      ·
      edit-2
      3 days ago

      What on Earth were you expecting exactly? It’s atheism. It’s not supposed to have a philosophy. It’s not supposed to have organization. Not supposed to have community. You were looking for religion. You picked something that was the absence of religion. Of course you were going to be disappointed.

      • hendrik@palaver.p3x.de
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        3 days ago

        Seems to me like the correct explanation of what happened there 😁

        Though I think it raises an interesting point. One of the things church did was, give structure to people. You had fixed milestones in life, like baptism, marry an opposite gender person et cetera… And a decent amount of people are longing for those kinds of things. They want someone to give them an idea of what to do, want some traditions and be celebrated once in a while. That’s kind of some human desire and they’ll be searching for that.

        Also church used to provide communal space. And you’d meet your neighbours there and socialise. Now doomscrolling on the sofa isn’t an adequate replacement for that. It’d be nice to have some non religious communal spaces which aren’t for-profit places. All I see our governments do is cut funding to those. Which is a shame.

        • njm1314
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          6
          ·
          3 days ago

          I’m not sure if you just didn’t read that or if you didn’t understand it. Which one is it?

    • Agnosis
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      3 days ago

      It was more or less already said, but atheism is just the belief that there are no gods. How did you think that a community was going to work just around that fact? If you believe there’s a god, of course you’re going to have your life turn around that axle, but that doesn’t work when you think “hey, I don’t think there’s a guy in the sky running the universe”. What you did wrong was not looking for a community based on something else. You could have joined a boardgames group, a sport, do charity work. You also have to understand that your statement that “there’s no philosophy” is extremely disingenuous when there’re so many books on the topic you could build a house with, plus all the existing philosophy that does not change regardless of whether there’s a god or not.

      • UnderpantsWeevil
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        2
        arrow-down
        4
        ·
        3 days ago

        It was more or less already said, but atheism is just the belief that there are no gods. How did you think that a community was going to work just around that fact?

        The same way any organization works. People gather and socialize, host events, form chapters with regular meetings and members in good standing, raise and spend money on offices and events, and pursue some collectively understood end goals.

        You could have joined a boardgames group, a sport, do charity work.

        I did. I’m still an avid board gamer, athlete, and volunteer. I’m not so much an avid atheist anymore.

        • Agnosis
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          5
          ·
          3 days ago

          I just explained why a community just based on your belief that something doesn’t exist is not very easy to build, but even then, people have done it. There are even atheist groups that hold Sundays secular assemblies. Maybe you could have had better luck looking for humanist communities, but in the end I think the other person that replied to you is right: you were just looking for religion.