• Snowclone
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    10 hours ago

    you have to actually look things up and not just believe what people say in Sunday school. again, that’s your faith and your welcome to it. but it’s not historically factual, there are no first hand accounts or eye witness accounts of Jesus’s ministry, those are all compilations of sayings and sermons from secondary sources that are 20-50 years past the lifetime of anyone that knew Jesus. This is well known, the Catholic scholars that compiled The Bible documented this. Not knowing where the text comes from isn’t proof you know something. Feel free to look it up, there’s a lot of information on this avaliable.

    • HM King Charles III DG FD@feddit.uk
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      20 minutes ago

      20-50 years past the lifetime of anyone that knew Jesus

      This is just pure falsehood.

      Secular scholars point to Mark being written around 70AD, although this is because of them presupposing that it was written after the destruction of the temple, an event that was prophecied by Jesus.

      Bug being charitable to that, Jesus, who died and ascended into heaven in 33ad, that is well within living memory. Of course, the earliest writing of Jesus is likely 1 Thessalonians, which is around 50ad. Only twenty years after Jesus had ascended into heaven. Well within living memory.

      Even the last one, St John’s Gospel is at the latest 100ad. 70 years after the fact, but still living memory (and according to tradition, it was written by St John who would have been around 80-90 years old)

      I know of random anecdotes that are passed down orally in my family which are well over 100 years old. And we don’t have an oral storytelling tradition here in the UK in modern times like they would have had back in first century Palestine.

      The early apostolic sources you mention all say that Matthew wrote Matthew’s Gospel and John wrote his own. Sure, Mark and Luke are definitely compilations, albeit from first hand sources, but that’s still pretty reliable.