I doubt it? I think at this point, most of them would agree with the prevailing analysis that the most mechanical cause for its failure was the leadership of Kruschev and his collaborators implementing reforms to create a wealth accumulation mechanism for the political elite. But how that came to pass I think is still not fully understood. If we understand Kruschev to be the beginning of the end, that means that Stalin failed to protect the revolution from internal revisionists. So essentially Stalin was paranoid that “the wrong people” were vying for power and he was right, and he purged so many people from politics, and still immediately after he died those exact people rose to the top. So Stalin failed in this responsibility, but if Stalin’s extreme behavior was actually founded in some form of real perception he had, then that means the whole system was shot through with people looking to undermine the revolution for self-enrichment for many years…
Mao and the CPC attempted to explain this as a problem with the culture of the people and thus attempted the cultural revolution as a solution. However, the CPC’s own analysis years later is that the cultural revolution was a mistake.
The Chinese did identify one mission critical component of revolution: self-critique. The Soviet project was not successful in cutlivating and incorporating criticism of the revolution. The Chinese identified that as a critical component of a revolutionary project and self-critique has become a structured, inculturated, and disciplined part of the CPC.
Is that enough? We’ll see. Remember that tankies see communist revolutions as experiments in governance, and that each project uncovers new learnings, new complexities, new mistakes, and new solutions and at least half the job is trying to determine which of those things are specific to that time and place and people and which can be abstracted into lessons for improving future revolutionary projects
Thanks for the answer. I think Stalin’s purges were at a minimum partially self serving, for example what threat to the revolution did Trotsky pose halfway around the world, but I will concede that at least some of it likely well intentioned.
I do think it’s notable that you mention party elites accumulating wealth in the USSR, are we not seeing the same kinds of wealth discrepancies growing in China? I do agree that self criticism and introspection is essential to any form of governance
are we not seeing the same kinds of wealth discrepancies growing in China?
Yes and no. Most of the wealth accumulation is from private citizens who are not party members and most of that wealth accumulation is through capitalist flows of profit not state appropriation through positional authority.
But also, as much as the Western media has been crowing about Xi purging the military and claiming that it’s about personal fealty, the entire party appartus is communicating in terms of removing the influence of money and special interest groups from political and military positions of power and influence.
Which goes back to that idea of having institutionalized self-criticism.
So again, it remains to be seen if China has figured out a way to use capitalism’s resource allocation power without allowing the profit motive to fundamentally steer the direction of the state. It also remains to be seen if any other communist revolution can do the same thing, achieve the same goal with different means, or go a totally different direction.
Stalin was a murderous asshole and Marx would have hated him. I find you ponderings pretty distasteful in the context of actual socialist principles.
Experiments in killing massive amounts of people and still waiting on the first true socialist country let alone a stateless communist one. I wonder how many more mass executions/genocides…err expirements it is going take to get it “right”.
Hopefully you don’t buy into this kind of garbage and are just critiquing it for everyone’s benefit.
Marxism has nothing to do with who Marx would have loved or hated. It’s not a personality contest.
Stalin was a murderous asshole, as was Mao, Jefferson, Washington, Hegseth, Ho Chi Minh, Castro, Che, Obama, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Reagan, Biden, Harris, Trump, and many many other world leaders across the entire spectrum of political philosophy and ideology. It’s not useful to characterize people this way when analyzing politics.
Actual socialist principles are consequentialist, not virtue ethics. And until you can come to terms with that you’re going to arrive at contradictions in your analysis.
The imperial world worder kills 800k people a year with just US sanctions. That’s an incredible amount of mass murder without any bombs or guns. Imperialism has and is killing far far more people than movements for communism have ever killed. And yes, unfortunately, politics involves killing people, which means, yes, unfortunately communist experiments will include within them killing people. If they fail to kill the right people, those people will them. If they mistakenly kill the wrong people, those deaths will cause the masses to revolt. It is very difficult to secure a revolution, just ask every liberal revolution how they handled the people revolting (hint, it was with the military and paramilitary forces).
No one is “waiting on the first true socialist country”. We are all trying to figure out how to build one. Some nations have organized revolutions and advanced their “figuring out” beyond rhetoric. No Western nation has done so yet.
I wonder how many more mass executions
Mass executions will happen. There’s no way around that. That’s how war goes. It’s not desirable, but if you think anyone is going to do revolutionary politics without violence in the world today, when the US and its allies and vassals are literally bombing countries to oblivion, kidnapping heads of state, blowing up schools and hospitals, targeting weddings and funerals, and sinking civilian ships for the lulz, then you’re kidding yourself.
The US literally trained, armed, and air lifted terrorists into Tibet. The British literally defined entire states in the Persian Gulf based on promoting a brutal minority into power to oppress the majority. Revolutions will be violent because they are fighting against violence, and when the Israelis will literally go into Iran and recruit malcontents and cultivate armed resistance domestically, it’s going to result in mass executions. It sucks that the Europeans are so violent and depraved that they would literally recruit brother to fight brother. We saw that in Afghanistan too. That Afghani veteran who shot up DC was literally recruited by the US to be a child soldier and was trained to torture, murder, and rape his own countrymen. Because the European imperial system is just that depraved. If you want revolution without violence, you’re the one who’s waiting for perfection.
It is very useful. Placing people up on pedestals is incompatible with socialism. Every one of these grandstanding tyrants has done their part to destroy the fabric of humanity in the name of their twisted virtue signaling. This is just one of the glaring flaws of humanity.
Putting Clinton or Obama in the same category as total monsters is bizarre. I greatly dislike Neofascism, but objectively there is no comparison between their direct actions and loss of life. Indirect actions on the other hand, are problematic as you pointed out. US sanctions have cost a staggering amount of life far higher than your estimates.
No one is trying to figure out how to actually build socialism. That is a fucking lie you tell yourself to make you worldview make sense. I totally get being in denial, as I was about democracy for the several years of my life until I saw through the rhetoric of power and control.
Everything you accuse the supposed West of the East has done as well. Playing Imperialist is extremely common in communist countries, which shows how much garbage using socialism as a cover for ogliarchy really is.
You seem to act just like another murderous leftist. Ready to handwave massive death as long as your team is in charge and they say the rhetoric that gets you to drop trow for.
You’re basically articulating the exact thing Western Marxism is criticized for:
No one is trying to figure out how to actually build socialism [it’s just about] power and control
Essentially you’re saying the only true form of socialism is the form that is powerless and not in control. Socialism is fine for you if the socialists are oppressed, but as soon as the socialists seize power, they cease to be socialists in your view. This is such a common position that we had to come up with a term for it, and that term is “Western Marxism”. It is a position that will never liberate anyone and only serves to justify imperialist intervention and undermine revolutionary movements.
What were your impressions of Engels’ On Authority?
Placing people up on pedestals is incompatible with socialism.
That’s a strong claim using undefined terms. One might say undefinable. What could you possibly mean by “placing people up on pedestals”? Certainly not celebrating people’s accomplishments, right? Because socialism has nothing to say about celebrating people’s accomplishments. Marxism certainly argues against Great Man Theory, but that’s the belief that history is advanced by individuals taking actions to advance history instead of individuals emerging from the conditions of history is it marches through us.
Stalin is celebrated for his role in defeating the Nazis and his role in rapidly industrialization to support that war effort. That’s basically it. If you think celebrating Stalin for his role in defeating the Nazis is incompatible with socialism, then I think perhaps you have a very idiosyncratic definition of socialism.
Putting Clinton or Obama in the same category as total monsters is bizarre
There’s that Western Marxism again. Both Clinton and Obama presided over the greatest enemy of humanity for 8 years. In each of those 8-year terms, unilateral US sanctions killed approximately 6.4M people, mostly children and elderly, through starvation and denial of medications.
Clinton was the first person in modern history to launch do a war for “humanitarian” reasons. Curious concept in general, but we can excuse the fabricated claims of ethnic cleansing as normal American behavior. But it’s quite strange that during that war the military shot 10 metric tons of depleted uranium from the air, bombed major urban areas, and cut the entire economic output of the country in half. For humanity!
Clinton also grew domestic prison populations by 50% to surpass the brief surge of post-collapse Russia and claim the top spot in prison rate that it would hold for two decades and years. Clinton’s prison rates were basically second only to the 3-year peak of Stalin’s incarceration rate and the short stint of mass crime following the dissolution of the USSR (an expected abberation).
And of course Obama expanded the drone war, setting precedents for killing American citizens abroad without due process, double tapping weddings and funerals. He and H Clinton led the destruction of Libya, the African country with the highest standard of living and prosperity with the strongest social safety net on the continent. H Clinton had no qualms about saying she laughed while she watched the video of a 70-year-old man being sodomized with a blade by the people her State Department funded and trafficked arms to for the purposes of creating an incredibly bloody civil war.
He also deported over 3M people, significantly more than Trump, and did so by expanding DHS and ICE, which Trump then used to effect his work. Obama also appointed Tom Homan to lead deportations, the same guy who architects Trump’s deportations.
but objectively there is no comparison between their direct actions and loss of life
That’s because objectively they aren’t symmetrical situations. Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were funding the Third Reich as they developed the world’s most advanced war machine to invade and subjugate all of Russia and the Caucuses. Clinton and Obama presided over the dominant global hegemon, largest military in the history of the world, and greatest continuous engine of war crimes and atrocities without accountability the world has ever seen while also presiding over essentially the most authoritarian carceral system on the planet, imprisoning more of their own people than anyone else and managing (via parole and probation) almost 300% more of its citizens than the next closest state, while having some of the worst prison outcomes in the world. Stalin could never kill 800M each year simply through sanctions. He had nowhere near that kind of power. But Clinton and Obama? Absolutely. Claiming that this was “indirect action” and therefore somehow morally superior is literally saying that you would rather the imperialist super power starve people than for the world’s first ever socialist revolution to kill people with bullets during a war campaign where 25M of their citizens died.
This is why virtue ethics is morally bankrupt. It’s primarily a way for people to feel morally superior about themselves regardless of context or outcome. Stalin did a lot of horrible things, he was obviously paranoid and violent and there were many instances of him using his power that produced suffering and death without benefit to the socialist movement. But he also was in a situation you personally will never be in, as the leader selected by the party to defend the country against the Nazis. He used his power to achieve the goal and he also used his power to harm many people unnecessarily. What’s that thing you people like to say? “two things can be true at the same time”
Everything you accuse the supposed West of the East has done as well.
Only if you abstract it into virtues and ignore history. It’s literally impossible for your statement to be actually true because the East didn’t develop a blue ocean navy until after the West had dominated 80% of the world’s population and committed multiple mass genocides on multiple continents. Did Russia or China of Persia or the Ottomans or the Japanese do things that are abstractly congruous? Yes. Did they have a blue ocean navy and sail the world and land on every continent and subjugate people and divide them against each other on every continent? No, because none of them had advanced their technology enough to do so yet.
You seem to act just like another murderous leftist.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous. But if you put me in a war to defend a revolution, I would probably have killed people.
Ready to handwave massive death as long as your team is in charge
Says the person who thinks collective punishment by the global hegemon is “indirect action” and therefore morally superior literally anything a communist party has done.
they say the rhetoric that gets you to drop trow for.
Ah yes, the last refuge of the Western liberal. Accusing me of being willing to be a sexual bottom, as though it’s an insult. I’m sure your sex partners would love to know that you find it demeaning and insulting to be a bottom.
Anyway, carry on with your morally superior position. Keep supporting socialism exclusively without power. You’re doing the meme. But at least you give me the opportunity to explain to others why your position is weak. Hopefully someone learns something. Hopefully these words will slowly work through your defense mechanisms over the coming years. We’re going to be better off with you, and everyone else, on the side of liberation.
Essentially you’re saying the only true form of socialism is the form that is powerless and not in control.
Never said that, but you did which only adds to what I am saying. The jig is up, it is just just more murderers with a slightly better sounding rhetoric.
term for it, and that term is “Western Marxism”. It
Weak scapegoating pretending to be informed. This kind of nonsense is why it is hard for you to be taken seriously.
". It is a position that will never liberate anyone an
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender. Such a common trope here.
That’s a strong claim using undefined terms.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals, give me a break.
Stalin is celebrated
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Both Clinton and Obama presided over the greatest enemy of humanity for 8 years.
Oh please, they did not order massive campaigns of death and destruction. Obama’s drone campaign killed a fraction of the people Stalin did on a bad day. I absolutely hated Obama carrying on the drone campaign, but that is entirely different than ordering the secret police to kill upwards of a thousand citizens a day. Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
Clinton was the first person in modern history to launch do a war for “humanitarian” reasons.
Fashioning Clinton as a war monger has to be one of the silliest examples of bad propaganda I have ever seen. He was a neofascist womanizer. If you are going to hate the guy, at least have real non shitty Russian propaganda reasons.
He also deported over 3M people, significantly more than Trump,
I know, it makes Trump supporters cry because Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem leaving poor Trump with only legal immigrants to deport.
Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
Says the person who thinks collective punishment by the global hegemon is “indirect action” and therefore morally superior literally anything a communist party has done.
I never said that. What a weak attempt to paint me into a corner. Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists. No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
You are on the verge of literally speaking without meaning.
“Scapegoating” is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them. That’s not what’s happening here. I’m critiquing your position and assigning the label of Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse. From the summary of critique:
J. G. Merquior argues that the movement’s defining flaw was its embrace of Kulturkritik, which led it to reject historical analysis in favor of sweeping, often romantic, indictments of modern civilization. In his view, this resulted in a “theoreticism” that produced little of value for sociological or historical understanding.
That’s the criticism I am levying at you. There’s no scapegoating here. That’s not what that word means.
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender
Again, another misunderstanding so complete it feels like you’re arguing with a ghost in your head. It’s so bad, I have to take it in 3 parts:
my “ideology will rise from the ashes”
My criticism of Western Marxism as impotent is not in any way, shape, or form me saying “my ideology will rise from the ashes” because I don’t think my ideology is in ashes. I think Marxism-Leninism as an ideology is still alive and well in Cuba, China, Vietnam, and Laos at the very least. It’s far from dead.
authoritarian
I would challenge you to define this word in any way that doesn’t implicate basically every state that has ever existed. It’s a meaningless term, and if you were actually engaged in socialist discourse (and I don’t mean with MLs, I just mean generally) you would know that “authoritarian” is often critiqued as a word without any actual meaning or utility. Again, the US is the most egregious abuser of authority in the world per capita by a large margin. Wars are exercises in authority. Revolutions are exercises in authority. This critique is meaningless.
disguised as a human rights defender
The concept of human rights is a liberal construct. Marxism views rights as legal fictions that emerge as part of the superstructure. I’m not pretending to be a defender of human rights. I am stating plainly that liberalism is a political philosophy of subjugation and that communism is a political philosophy of liberation. As a political philosophy of liberation it seeks to understand the root cause of subjugation and it has arrived at the conclusion that class society is the root cause of subjugation, and therefore abolition of classes is the path to liberation. It has also concluded that the only way to abolish classes is to abolish the owning class, and the only way to do that is through repression of the owning class and the reactionaries who would re-establish it. That necessarily involves violating human rights. We’re clear eyed about that. The path to universal liberation is on the other side of repressing the owning class. That’s the political theory, that’s the analysis, that’s the prescription. You can disagree with that. That’s OK. But that’s not a form of Marxism and you’re lying to yourself if you think it is.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals
You never defined the term. So as it stands you have uttered words without meaning and declined the opportunity to clarify yourself.
Stalin is celebrated
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage. You think it’s disgusting to celebrate the leader of the military that defeated the Third Reich, took Berlin, and did so at great national cost. As the saying goes “We liberated Europe from fascism, but they will never forgive us for it”.
Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling. As I have already stated, Stalin did a lot of terrible things. But as I also stated, comparing the leader of a country that was the target of the combined industrial power of Western Europe, that was invaded multiple times, including by the US, and ultimately had to fight the vast majority of Nazi forces to a president of a country that has literally never had anyone attack at their borders is not a valid basis for comparison. Every bomb dropped by an American president was a bomb of choice, while Stalin was specifically operating with the existential threat of the Germans on meth enslaving the Slavs for centuries. They’re not comparable. And again, even while they’re not comparable, Stalin still did horrible things. And even still, while Stalin did horrible things, he did not just go on war adventures bombing people on the other side of the planet to dominate them and he did not starve children, pregnant women, and the elderly in over a dozen countries for the crime of national self-determination.
Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem
Oh, wow. So you actually think that the combined 8M people deported by Obama and Biden were all just violent criminals. 8M violent criminals? Really? OK then. And you call me an authoritarian bootlicker? This is what Blue MAGA looks like.
That’s because objectively they aren’t symmetrical situations. Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were funding the Third Reich as they developed the world’s most advanced war machine to invade and subjugate all of Russia and the Caucuses.
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
I mean, that just says it all, doesn’t it? I’m literally talking about how the Nazis, led by Hitler, were funded and what their goals were and how the target of their invasion sought to defend themselves and their neighbors from Hitler and the Nazis, and you can’t tell the difference between that and a Nazi defending Hitler. I mean, fair enough! If that’s how you process information, well, I guess that’s all there is to it. You can’t tell the difference between the violence of the master against the slave or the violence of the slave against the master. Both are wrong to you. And that’s why virtue ethics is, ironically, morally bankrupt.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
On which statement? I bet I can guess which one!
Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists
Because you literally said:
I greatly dislike Neofascism, but objectively there is no comparison between their direct actions and loss of life.
You are making a claim that there is an objective moral superiority of Neofascism over all historical movements for communism. But then again, I’m coming to realize that you think it’s bullshit that words have meaning, so I guess I can’t expect you to understand even your words and their implications because you’re just spitting vibes and don’t have any idea that there’s actually any analysis or critique to be done by anyone, least of all you. All that’s important is that you vehemently distance yourself from anything that might morally taint you.
No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
Very funny on both counts. It’s not about nations anymore, that’s why the world imperial hegemon hates it when nations nationalize their national resources and will do everything in their power to stop nations from nationalizing their national resources via nationalist movements. Because it’s not about nations anymore.
As for the claim of campism, I think that’s funny as well. It’s a thought terminating cliche. Try to define the camps that you think I see and how I’m choosing a specific camp and arguing against other camps. I’m sorry. That’s unfair of me to ask. You couldn’t do that. You don’t have any idea what you’re saying. You don’t know what campism means, the history of the term, what the historical camps were, how they related to each other. To you, words are dirt to throw at your opponent, not things with meaning and history.
I have an analysis. I have argued for that analysis. I have attempted to answer your criticism. And what you have given me back is moralizing. You have axiomatically defined what is “good” and what is “bad” and you have stripped all other context to ensure that you can apply your labels in a way that makes you the good guy. Don’t believe me? Here’s what someone like you would say:
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Scapegoating" is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them.
You are indeed labeling me and blaming me for an ideology I do not have. Perhaps this is an ESL thing for you. I am not sure.
Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse
Well there is your problem, this is not my criticism at all.
I would challenge you to define this word
Neoauthoritarianism is the evolution of authoritarianism. It is seen throughout Asia and I would argue in the US now as well. I am well aware of ML propaganda in regards to this and I soundly reject it.
My criticism of Western Marxism
Hey I get it, you are willing to let people to die for your revolution. You don’t have to pretend about your warped views in regards to a powerful socialist/communist nation. I already know where you are coming from.
You never defined the term
Says the guy lamenting how good murderous dictators were. Just experiments after all.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage
You have to be extra psychotic to deny what he did.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling.
You have never stated your position, only your criticism of a position I don’t have.
Both are wrong to you. And
Please, people who minimize what either of the monsters did are certainly wrong. They disgust me and people who defend them do as well. I hope that you are just offering an impartial historical perspective rather than a ham fisted attempt at defense.
But do they all agree on the cause?
I doubt it? I think at this point, most of them would agree with the prevailing analysis that the most mechanical cause for its failure was the leadership of Kruschev and his collaborators implementing reforms to create a wealth accumulation mechanism for the political elite. But how that came to pass I think is still not fully understood. If we understand Kruschev to be the beginning of the end, that means that Stalin failed to protect the revolution from internal revisionists. So essentially Stalin was paranoid that “the wrong people” were vying for power and he was right, and he purged so many people from politics, and still immediately after he died those exact people rose to the top. So Stalin failed in this responsibility, but if Stalin’s extreme behavior was actually founded in some form of real perception he had, then that means the whole system was shot through with people looking to undermine the revolution for self-enrichment for many years…
Mao and the CPC attempted to explain this as a problem with the culture of the people and thus attempted the cultural revolution as a solution. However, the CPC’s own analysis years later is that the cultural revolution was a mistake.
The Chinese did identify one mission critical component of revolution: self-critique. The Soviet project was not successful in cutlivating and incorporating criticism of the revolution. The Chinese identified that as a critical component of a revolutionary project and self-critique has become a structured, inculturated, and disciplined part of the CPC.
Is that enough? We’ll see. Remember that tankies see communist revolutions as experiments in governance, and that each project uncovers new learnings, new complexities, new mistakes, and new solutions and at least half the job is trying to determine which of those things are specific to that time and place and people and which can be abstracted into lessons for improving future revolutionary projects
Thanks for the answer. I think Stalin’s purges were at a minimum partially self serving, for example what threat to the revolution did Trotsky pose halfway around the world, but I will concede that at least some of it likely well intentioned.
I do think it’s notable that you mention party elites accumulating wealth in the USSR, are we not seeing the same kinds of wealth discrepancies growing in China? I do agree that self criticism and introspection is essential to any form of governance
Yes and no. Most of the wealth accumulation is from private citizens who are not party members and most of that wealth accumulation is through capitalist flows of profit not state appropriation through positional authority.
But also, as much as the Western media has been crowing about Xi purging the military and claiming that it’s about personal fealty, the entire party appartus is communicating in terms of removing the influence of money and special interest groups from political and military positions of power and influence.
Which goes back to that idea of having institutionalized self-criticism.
So again, it remains to be seen if China has figured out a way to use capitalism’s resource allocation power without allowing the profit motive to fundamentally steer the direction of the state. It also remains to be seen if any other communist revolution can do the same thing, achieve the same goal with different means, or go a totally different direction.
Stalin was a murderous asshole and Marx would have hated him. I find you ponderings pretty distasteful in the context of actual socialist principles.
Experiments in killing massive amounts of people and still waiting on the first true socialist country let alone a stateless communist one. I wonder how many more mass executions/genocides…err expirements it is going take to get it “right”.
Hopefully you don’t buy into this kind of garbage and are just critiquing it for everyone’s benefit.
Marxism has nothing to do with who Marx would have loved or hated. It’s not a personality contest.
Stalin was a murderous asshole, as was Mao, Jefferson, Washington, Hegseth, Ho Chi Minh, Castro, Che, Obama, Bill and Hillary Clinton, Reagan, Biden, Harris, Trump, and many many other world leaders across the entire spectrum of political philosophy and ideology. It’s not useful to characterize people this way when analyzing politics.
Actual socialist principles are consequentialist, not virtue ethics. And until you can come to terms with that you’re going to arrive at contradictions in your analysis.
The imperial world worder kills 800k people a year with just US sanctions. That’s an incredible amount of mass murder without any bombs or guns. Imperialism has and is killing far far more people than movements for communism have ever killed. And yes, unfortunately, politics involves killing people, which means, yes, unfortunately communist experiments will include within them killing people. If they fail to kill the right people, those people will them. If they mistakenly kill the wrong people, those deaths will cause the masses to revolt. It is very difficult to secure a revolution, just ask every liberal revolution how they handled the people revolting (hint, it was with the military and paramilitary forces).
No one is “waiting on the first true socialist country”. We are all trying to figure out how to build one. Some nations have organized revolutions and advanced their “figuring out” beyond rhetoric. No Western nation has done so yet.
Mass executions will happen. There’s no way around that. That’s how war goes. It’s not desirable, but if you think anyone is going to do revolutionary politics without violence in the world today, when the US and its allies and vassals are literally bombing countries to oblivion, kidnapping heads of state, blowing up schools and hospitals, targeting weddings and funerals, and sinking civilian ships for the lulz, then you’re kidding yourself.
The US literally trained, armed, and air lifted terrorists into Tibet. The British literally defined entire states in the Persian Gulf based on promoting a brutal minority into power to oppress the majority. Revolutions will be violent because they are fighting against violence, and when the Israelis will literally go into Iran and recruit malcontents and cultivate armed resistance domestically, it’s going to result in mass executions. It sucks that the Europeans are so violent and depraved that they would literally recruit brother to fight brother. We saw that in Afghanistan too. That Afghani veteran who shot up DC was literally recruited by the US to be a child soldier and was trained to torture, murder, and rape his own countrymen. Because the European imperial system is just that depraved. If you want revolution without violence, you’re the one who’s waiting for perfection.
It is very useful. Placing people up on pedestals is incompatible with socialism. Every one of these grandstanding tyrants has done their part to destroy the fabric of humanity in the name of their twisted virtue signaling. This is just one of the glaring flaws of humanity.
Putting Clinton or Obama in the same category as total monsters is bizarre. I greatly dislike Neofascism, but objectively there is no comparison between their direct actions and loss of life. Indirect actions on the other hand, are problematic as you pointed out. US sanctions have cost a staggering amount of life far higher than your estimates.
No one is trying to figure out how to actually build socialism. That is a fucking lie you tell yourself to make you worldview make sense. I totally get being in denial, as I was about democracy for the several years of my life until I saw through the rhetoric of power and control.
Everything you accuse the supposed West of the East has done as well. Playing Imperialist is extremely common in communist countries, which shows how much garbage using socialism as a cover for ogliarchy really is.
You seem to act just like another murderous leftist. Ready to handwave massive death as long as your team is in charge and they say the rhetoric that gets you to drop trow for.
You’re basically articulating the exact thing Western Marxism is criticized for:
Essentially you’re saying the only true form of socialism is the form that is powerless and not in control. Socialism is fine for you if the socialists are oppressed, but as soon as the socialists seize power, they cease to be socialists in your view. This is such a common position that we had to come up with a term for it, and that term is “Western Marxism”. It is a position that will never liberate anyone and only serves to justify imperialist intervention and undermine revolutionary movements.
What were your impressions of Engels’ On Authority?
That’s a strong claim using undefined terms. One might say undefinable. What could you possibly mean by “placing people up on pedestals”? Certainly not celebrating people’s accomplishments, right? Because socialism has nothing to say about celebrating people’s accomplishments. Marxism certainly argues against Great Man Theory, but that’s the belief that history is advanced by individuals taking actions to advance history instead of individuals emerging from the conditions of history is it marches through us.
Stalin is celebrated for his role in defeating the Nazis and his role in rapidly industrialization to support that war effort. That’s basically it. If you think celebrating Stalin for his role in defeating the Nazis is incompatible with socialism, then I think perhaps you have a very idiosyncratic definition of socialism.
There’s that Western Marxism again. Both Clinton and Obama presided over the greatest enemy of humanity for 8 years. In each of those 8-year terms, unilateral US sanctions killed approximately 6.4M people, mostly children and elderly, through starvation and denial of medications.
Clinton was the first person in modern history to launch do a war for “humanitarian” reasons. Curious concept in general, but we can excuse the fabricated claims of ethnic cleansing as normal American behavior. But it’s quite strange that during that war the military shot 10 metric tons of depleted uranium from the air, bombed major urban areas, and cut the entire economic output of the country in half. For humanity!
Clinton also grew domestic prison populations by 50% to surpass the brief surge of post-collapse Russia and claim the top spot in prison rate that it would hold for two decades and years. Clinton’s prison rates were basically second only to the 3-year peak of Stalin’s incarceration rate and the short stint of mass crime following the dissolution of the USSR (an expected abberation).
And of course Obama expanded the drone war, setting precedents for killing American citizens abroad without due process, double tapping weddings and funerals. He and H Clinton led the destruction of Libya, the African country with the highest standard of living and prosperity with the strongest social safety net on the continent. H Clinton had no qualms about saying she laughed while she watched the video of a 70-year-old man being sodomized with a blade by the people her State Department funded and trafficked arms to for the purposes of creating an incredibly bloody civil war.
He also deported over 3M people, significantly more than Trump, and did so by expanding DHS and ICE, which Trump then used to effect his work. Obama also appointed Tom Homan to lead deportations, the same guy who architects Trump’s deportations.
That’s because objectively they aren’t symmetrical situations. Stalin presided over a period of time when US and English businessmen were funding the Third Reich as they developed the world’s most advanced war machine to invade and subjugate all of Russia and the Caucuses. Clinton and Obama presided over the dominant global hegemon, largest military in the history of the world, and greatest continuous engine of war crimes and atrocities without accountability the world has ever seen while also presiding over essentially the most authoritarian carceral system on the planet, imprisoning more of their own people than anyone else and managing (via parole and probation) almost 300% more of its citizens than the next closest state, while having some of the worst prison outcomes in the world. Stalin could never kill 800M each year simply through sanctions. He had nowhere near that kind of power. But Clinton and Obama? Absolutely. Claiming that this was “indirect action” and therefore somehow morally superior is literally saying that you would rather the imperialist super power starve people than for the world’s first ever socialist revolution to kill people with bullets during a war campaign where 25M of their citizens died.
This is why virtue ethics is morally bankrupt. It’s primarily a way for people to feel morally superior about themselves regardless of context or outcome. Stalin did a lot of horrible things, he was obviously paranoid and violent and there were many instances of him using his power that produced suffering and death without benefit to the socialist movement. But he also was in a situation you personally will never be in, as the leader selected by the party to defend the country against the Nazis. He used his power to achieve the goal and he also used his power to harm many people unnecessarily. What’s that thing you people like to say? “two things can be true at the same time”
Only if you abstract it into virtues and ignore history. It’s literally impossible for your statement to be actually true because the East didn’t develop a blue ocean navy until after the West had dominated 80% of the world’s population and committed multiple mass genocides on multiple continents. Did Russia or China of Persia or the Ottomans or the Japanese do things that are abstractly congruous? Yes. Did they have a blue ocean navy and sail the world and land on every continent and subjugate people and divide them against each other on every continent? No, because none of them had advanced their technology enough to do so yet.
Words have meaning. I am not murderous. But if you put me in a war to defend a revolution, I would probably have killed people.
Says the person who thinks collective punishment by the global hegemon is “indirect action” and therefore morally superior literally anything a communist party has done.
Ah yes, the last refuge of the Western liberal. Accusing me of being willing to be a sexual bottom, as though it’s an insult. I’m sure your sex partners would love to know that you find it demeaning and insulting to be a bottom.
Anyway, carry on with your morally superior position. Keep supporting socialism exclusively without power. You’re doing the meme. But at least you give me the opportunity to explain to others why your position is weak. Hopefully someone learns something. Hopefully these words will slowly work through your defense mechanisms over the coming years. We’re going to be better off with you, and everyone else, on the side of liberation.
Never said that, but you did which only adds to what I am saying. The jig is up, it is just just more murderers with a slightly better sounding rhetoric.
Weak scapegoating pretending to be informed. This kind of nonsense is why it is hard for you to be taken seriously.
Ah yes another my “ideology will rise from the ashes” authoritarian bootlicker disguised as a human rights defender. Such a common trope here.
Says the guy putting people on pedestals, give me a break.
Fucking disgusting as I already mentioned.
Oh please, they did not order massive campaigns of death and destruction. Obama’s drone campaign killed a fraction of the people Stalin did on a bad day. I absolutely hated Obama carrying on the drone campaign, but that is entirely different than ordering the secret police to kill upwards of a thousand citizens a day. Inability to compare the magnitude of leaders personal decisions is very telling.
Fashioning Clinton as a war monger has to be one of the silliest examples of bad propaganda I have ever seen. He was a neofascist womanizer. If you are going to hate the guy, at least have real non shitty Russian propaganda reasons.
I know, it makes Trump supporters cry because Obama and Biden already legally deported all the problem leaving poor Trump with only legal immigrants to deport.
To me this is no different than listening to a Nazi defend Hitler.
Going to have to respectfully call bullshit here.
I never said that. What a weak attempt to paint me into a corner. Why is criticizing the dysfunctionalism that is communism a ringing endorsement of the current world paradigm of Neofascist Leverage Capitalists. No, you just act like a hopeless campist who can’t see that it is no longer even about nations anymore.
You are on the verge of literally speaking without meaning.
“Scapegoating” is singling out a person or group and assigning blame to them. That’s not what’s happening here. I’m critiquing your position and assigning the label of Western Marxism which is critiqued in the socialist discourse. From the summary of critique:
That’s the criticism I am levying at you. There’s no scapegoating here. That’s not what that word means.
Again, another misunderstanding so complete it feels like you’re arguing with a ghost in your head. It’s so bad, I have to take it in 3 parts:
My criticism of Western Marxism as impotent is not in any way, shape, or form me saying “my ideology will rise from the ashes” because I don’t think my ideology is in ashes. I think Marxism-Leninism as an ideology is still alive and well in Cuba, China, Vietnam, and Laos at the very least. It’s far from dead.
I would challenge you to define this word in any way that doesn’t implicate basically every state that has ever existed. It’s a meaningless term, and if you were actually engaged in socialist discourse (and I don’t mean with MLs, I just mean generally) you would know that “authoritarian” is often critiqued as a word without any actual meaning or utility. Again, the US is the most egregious abuser of authority in the world per capita by a large margin. Wars are exercises in authority. Revolutions are exercises in authority. This critique is meaningless.
The concept of human rights is a liberal construct. Marxism views rights as legal fictions that emerge as part of the superstructure. I’m not pretending to be a defender of human rights. I am stating plainly that liberalism is a political philosophy of subjugation and that communism is a political philosophy of liberation. As a political philosophy of liberation it seeks to understand the root cause of subjugation and it has arrived at the conclusion that class society is the root cause of subjugation, and therefore abolition of classes is the path to liberation. It has also concluded that the only way to abolish classes is to abolish the owning class, and the only way to do that is through repression of the owning class and the reactionaries who would re-establish it. That necessarily involves violating human rights. We’re clear eyed about that. The path to universal liberation is on the other side of repressing the owning class. That’s the political theory, that’s the analysis, that’s the prescription. You can disagree with that. That’s OK. But that’s not a form of Marxism and you’re lying to yourself if you think it is.
You never defined the term. So as it stands you have uttered words without meaning and declined the opportunity to clarify yourself.
Yeah, I mean at this point, it’s like I’m talking to an LLM that was trained to regurgitate randomized moral outrage. You think it’s disgusting to celebrate the leader of the military that defeated the Third Reich, took Berlin, and did so at great national cost. As the saying goes “We liberated Europe from fascism, but they will never forgive us for it”.
And inability to incorporate any of what I said into your understanding of my position is also very telling. As I have already stated, Stalin did a lot of terrible things. But as I also stated, comparing the leader of a country that was the target of the combined industrial power of Western Europe, that was invaded multiple times, including by the US, and ultimately had to fight the vast majority of Nazi forces to a president of a country that has literally never had anyone attack at their borders is not a valid basis for comparison. Every bomb dropped by an American president was a bomb of choice, while Stalin was specifically operating with the existential threat of the Germans on meth enslaving the Slavs for centuries. They’re not comparable. And again, even while they’re not comparable, Stalin still did horrible things. And even still, while Stalin did horrible things, he did not just go on war adventures bombing people on the other side of the planet to dominate them and he did not starve children, pregnant women, and the elderly in over a dozen countries for the crime of national self-determination.
Oh, wow. So you actually think that the combined 8M people deported by Obama and Biden were all just violent criminals. 8M violent criminals? Really? OK then. And you call me an authoritarian bootlicker? This is what Blue MAGA looks like.
I mean, that just says it all, doesn’t it? I’m literally talking about how the Nazis, led by Hitler, were funded and what their goals were and how the target of their invasion sought to defend themselves and their neighbors from Hitler and the Nazis, and you can’t tell the difference between that and a Nazi defending Hitler. I mean, fair enough! If that’s how you process information, well, I guess that’s all there is to it. You can’t tell the difference between the violence of the master against the slave or the violence of the slave against the master. Both are wrong to you. And that’s why virtue ethics is, ironically, morally bankrupt.
On which statement? I bet I can guess which one!
Because you literally said:
You are making a claim that there is an objective moral superiority of Neofascism over all historical movements for communism. But then again, I’m coming to realize that you think it’s bullshit that words have meaning, so I guess I can’t expect you to understand even your words and their implications because you’re just spitting vibes and don’t have any idea that there’s actually any analysis or critique to be done by anyone, least of all you. All that’s important is that you vehemently distance yourself from anything that might morally taint you.
Very funny on both counts. It’s not about nations anymore, that’s why the world imperial hegemon hates it when nations nationalize their national resources and will do everything in their power to stop nations from nationalizing their national resources via nationalist movements. Because it’s not about nations anymore.
As for the claim of campism, I think that’s funny as well. It’s a thought terminating cliche. Try to define the camps that you think I see and how I’m choosing a specific camp and arguing against other camps. I’m sorry. That’s unfair of me to ask. You couldn’t do that. You don’t have any idea what you’re saying. You don’t know what campism means, the history of the term, what the historical camps were, how they related to each other. To you, words are dirt to throw at your opponent, not things with meaning and history.
I have an analysis. I have argued for that analysis. I have attempted to answer your criticism. And what you have given me back is moralizing. You have axiomatically defined what is “good” and what is “bad” and you have stripped all other context to ensure that you can apply your labels in a way that makes you the good guy. Don’t believe me? Here’s what someone like you would say:
I mean. That really does say it all, doesn’t it.
You are indeed labeling me and blaming me for an ideology I do not have. Perhaps this is an ESL thing for you. I am not sure.
Well there is your problem, this is not my criticism at all.
Neoauthoritarianism is the evolution of authoritarianism. It is seen throughout Asia and I would argue in the US now as well. I am well aware of ML propaganda in regards to this and I soundly reject it.
Hey I get it, you are willing to let people to die for your revolution. You don’t have to pretend about your warped views in regards to a powerful socialist/communist nation. I already know where you are coming from.
Says the guy lamenting how good murderous dictators were. Just experiments after all.
You have to be extra psychotic to deny what he did.
You have never stated your position, only your criticism of a position I don’t have.
Please, people who minimize what either of the monsters did are certainly wrong. They disgust me and people who defend them do as well. I hope that you are just offering an impartial historical perspective rather than a ham fisted attempt at defense.