Game development engine Unity has U-turned on some parts of its hugely controversial plan to enforce fees on game creat…

Game development engine Unity has U-turned on some parts of its hugely controversial plan to enforce fees on game creat…

  • MudMan
    85•1 year ago

    I don’t think people realize how horrifying these addendums are.

    Not only do they not really fix the issue, but they prove that no, yeah, they hadn’t thought about the possibility of “install bombing” at all until just now and it would totally have triggered massive fees.

    I mean, the announcement was terribly worded, and some of the stuff (like wha’t a “monthly fee” or a “retroactive fee”) were very unclear, so you could hold out hope that they knew what they wanted to do and were just bad at explaining it.

    But nope, that ship has sailed. They clearly didn’t give this any amount of thought.

    So yeah, I’m more worried about it now than I was yesterday, believe it or not. Like, a LOT more.

    • @visor841English
      27•1 year ago

      Yeah this feels like Wizard of the Coast’s first response to the OGL drama. Make some changes that are technically better than the first terrible system, but is ultimately still completely unacceptable. WotC eventually had to walk back everything, we’ll see if Unity does the same.

      • MudMan
        17•1 year ago

        I mean, they have to.

        But honestly at this point that’s not even enough. You know they tried, you know whatever need for cash they were trying to fulfill remains. It’s one thing to let that go when buying a piece of software that you just… have, but building an entire business on top of this middleware and knowing you have a business relationship with them indefinitely as a result?

        At this point it’s a dealbreaker. You can’t trust them again. If I start a new dev studio tomorrow Unity would not even be in the running to start choosing an engine. They made themselves into a liability overnight. It’s stunning. I don’t know what the hell they’re putting in the filtered, flavored water they sell to executives, but this year has been an endless chain of self-immolation I had never witnessed before.

        • @AdalastEnglish
          2•1 year ago

          Not to mention the OGL stuff was only a risk to 3PP as a lawsuit of WoTC decided to act on it. This debacle is a direct attack on the bottom lines of games publishers that will kill independent development and seriously hamper even AAA companies. I know I’m not going to waste my time learning it.

    • @fluxionEnglish
      24•1 year ago

      I’m sure the CEO put plenty of thought in how much they could cash out before destroying the company and moving on to the next company to destroy

      • LemminaryEnglish
        9•1 year ago

        He comes from EA, I’m not surprised

        • stopthatgirl7OP
          5•1 year ago

          I was reading a Forbes article on this mess today, and the writer speculated they were hoping to make bank from Genshin Impact, since it uses Unity.