Things have gotten better and progress has been made from times past, it just seems worse now because we have more access to information. We’ve come far, and have further to go!

  • @Womble
    link
    English
    11 year ago

    The less/fewer distinction is arbitrary Victorian bullshit flying directly in the face of how English is used. The only point of it was to try and make English more like Latin and allow aristocrats who spoke Latin to look down on those without expensive private education.

    Please dont perpetuate it.

      • @Womble
        link
        English
        1
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        I do beg your pardon, it was Georgian not Victorian era when this nonsense was dreamed up for no reason other than preference for trying to cram Latin-esque cases into english.

        https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/no-genuine-rule-dictates-the-use-of-less-or-fewer-cs25kv8s5

        The very notion of a neat distinction between fewer and less according to whether the noun is countable or not is a myth. It was invented out of whole cloth by an ill- informed 18th-century pedant called Robert Baker in his book Reflections on the English Language (1770). He proposed this distinction not as a hard-and-fast rule of grammar, moreover, but as a tentative suggestion with caveats (“I should think . . . it appears to me . . . ”) that you won’t find in modern style guides.

        The wiki article on it notes that

        The Cambridge Guide to English Usage notes that the “pressure to substitute fewer for less seems to have developed out of all proportion to the ambiguity it may provide in noun phrases like less promising results”. It describes conformance with this pressure as a shibboleth and the choice “between the more formal fewer and the more spontaneous less” as a stylistic choice.

        i.e. it is a shibboleth for saying “I am educated unlike you uncultured lot who use natural sounding language”

        • @SpaceNoodle
          link
          01 year ago

          Yeah, people who learn and understand language are the worst

          • @Womble
            link
            English
            01 year ago

            You cant say “the worst” when talking about an uncountable group, you have to say “the least good” because I prefer that and it makes me sound smart by correcting you. Apparently that is sufficient for it to be understanding language and for you to be wrong.

            • @SpaceNoodle
              link
              01 year ago

              Most people thank me for the little correction and just go about their day without being a total asshole.

              • @Womble
                link
                English
                01 year ago

                Really most people thank you for being an annoying pedant who isnt even correct?

                • @SpaceNoodle
                  link
                  01 year ago

                  No, most people aren’t self-important assholes like you who lie for attention.