• @CharlesDarwin
    link
    English
    21 year ago

    Why would the people pointing out how unhealthy milk is be the ones that are the scammers? What would they have to gain from it? Why is milk promoted so very hard as a “health” drink? Not enough people seem to ask themselves this.

    • Queen HawlSera
      link
      fedilink
      English
      11 year ago

      The same reason why people try to tell you that vaccines are bullshit but if you buy their essential oils you’ll live forever. People try to discredit the mainstream and proven treatment in favor of quackery that they happen to sell at an inflated price.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        21 year ago

        Milk is “vaccines” in this situation. People are telling us milk is bullshit, but if we buy into veganism, we’ll live forever. While the Mayo Clinic reminds people that plant based milks are just generally not as healthy as dairy milk. Soymilk comes close if it is both fortified and unsweetened, but it’s still second-best. Good enough for someone who is already a vegan, but definitely not good enough for someone to stop drinking milk if they already do.

      • @CharlesDarwin
        link
        English
        11 year ago

        Yeah, but what are they going to sell? Also, I don’t think milk as a health drink is really all that mainstream any more, or becoming increasingly less so over time. I think people are still sputtering along on what they might have been told ages ago, or what they were told by the dairy council.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      0
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      Militant Veganism involves the desire to convince people to stop eating animal products at all costs. Just look at nutritionstudies.org. When you have a bunch “plant-based nutrition” sites that disagree with the Mayo Clinic and various cancer research organizations, it definitely gets problematic.

      Why is milk promoted so very hard as a “health” drink?

      Per the Mayo Clinic: “it’s tough to beat dairy milk for balanced nutrition”. That’s why. With a few caveats (which I cover below), it is one of the most perfectly balanced foods a human can consume.

      Here’s a question I don’t think enough people seem to ask. When cancer patients are encouraged to drink milk, and study after study fails to find a strong correlative or causal link between milk and cancer, why are so many vegan sites claiming it causes or worsens cancer. If I were a cancer patient, should I be trusting nutritionstudies.org and some vegan redditors/lemmings more than, say, Cancer Research UK? Or the Australia Cancer Council?

      The problem is that “why does EVERYONE say this is so healthy?!?” is similar to “there’s no evidence of this person committing a crime, so it must be a massive cover-up”… Or maybe EVERYONE says it is so healthy because it is so healthy.

      Not saying it’s a magical wonderdrink. Drinking calories is still an obesity risk. And people with lactose intolerance need to be careful or have a lactase enzyme with their milk. Of course the dairy industry wants you to drink 5000 glasses of milk per day. So don’t listen to them, and equally don’t listen to the militant vegans. Listen to medical and nutrition experts who don’t have some sort of agenda.