Renewables capacity needs to increase substantially and hydrogen and derivatives need an eight-fold increase to meet a Pathway to Net Zero (PNZ) by 2050, according to DNV’s Energy Transition Outlook 2023 report.

  • HypxOP
    link
    fedilink
    11 year ago

    It’s the same accusation made against BEVs. That it is just powering cars with coal. But it’s a dumb argument because you can power them with anything. Same is true with hydrogen.

    • snooggums
      link
      fedilink
      11 year ago

      Except we had already made massive strides with production of electricity through solar, wind, and other renewables and have continued to improve the ratios of renewable to fossil fuel generation for electricity. All of the renewable methods had enough obvious potential that the claims it was mostly fossil fuel were accurate, but there was a foreseeable path away from fossil fuels. Note that a lot of the ‘it is just fossil fuels so it isn’t better’ came from fossil fuel producers who wanted to muddy the water.

      Hydrogen is still at a place where there is no obvious potential growth in using renewables to produce hydrogen. The only thing that is currently obviously scalable is more fossil fuel based production. That doesn’t require the fossil fuel companies to end provide misinformation, that is just where we are at technologically the last I checked when electric and hydrogen cars were being compared as the new potential hotness within the last decade.

      Is there some new scalable production method for hydrogen that has come out that I missed that will impact that 95% rate? If there is I will be pleasantly surprised!

      • HypxOP
        link
        fedilink
        1
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        And what is the end result of that, other than equally massive strides in production of green hydrogen? You cannot say that renewable can take off, but then claim that its direct consequences won’t happen.

        It’s pretty obvious you didn’t read the article. Green hydrogen is absolute necessary for a green society. It’s not merely an idea anymore. People who still think otherwise are either stuck 10 years in the past, or are repeating generic anti-green energy lies, no different than what the fossil fuel industry said about renewable energy.

        • snooggums
          link
          fedilink
          11 year ago

          Look, there are multiple things going on and you are dismissing one criticism because one part of the process is lagging behind.

          Electric and hydrogen vehicles are awesome! The both reduce pollution in cities and places where people live by reducing it at the point of use. We absolutely need to continue the work on the use of hydrogen fuel cells for applications for the same reason as electric, primarily the short term benefits and the long term potential of being 100% renewable.

          I mean my first response was that we needed to focus on more renewable methods for producing hydrogen because right now the fossil fuel companies are set up to benefit immediately from any increase and that will just incentivize them to spread more misinformation as the renewables get sorted out.

          • HypxOP
            link
            fedilink
            11 year ago

            Then you can stop with the conspiracy theories and just accept hydrogen as a good idea.

            • snooggums
              link
              fedilink
              11 year ago

              I still don’t know what conspiracy theory you are going on about.

              • HypxOP
                link
                fedilink
                11 year ago

                You started saying that it is just a way for oil companies to sell more oil. That’s literally your first post in this thread. That is the conspiracy theory.

                • snooggums
                  link
                  fedilink
                  11 year ago

                  No, I said since oil companies currently account for 95% of hydrogen production and no scalable alternatives currently exist, oil companies will be excited to see increased demand for their products. They stand to benefit from any increase unless an alternate comes up and that is a fact, not a conspiracy.

                  I did not say oil companies were the ones promoting hydrogen. Wouldn’t be surprised, but made no such claim.

                  • HypxOP
                    link
                    fedilink
                    11 year ago

                    You can say the same thing about coal companies and BEVs. It’s totally missing the point. The non-conspiracy version of events will find that all fossil fuel companies are terrified of green technology. None of them are actually supporting green technology beyond pushing a few side-projects.

                    You’re implying that it is the case. That is still doing the same thing.