• @YoBuckStopsHere
    link
    English
    410 months ago

    The United States didn’t buy The Philippines or Puerto Rico. It did buy the Western States.

    • chaogomu
      link
      fedilink
      2210 months ago

      It bought some of the western states. It flat out stole the rest.

      • @YoBuckStopsHere
        link
        English
        -1210 months ago

        It bought them all, but Mexico was really poor so they got it cheaper. The US was willing to pay $50 million.

        • chaogomu
          link
          fedilink
          1510 months ago

          No. It did not.

          The US did offer to buy the territories, Mexico said no, then the US invaded and took them. During the peace process after the war, the US then paid less than half of the initial offer for the territories that it was never going to give back.

          Later, the US bought a sliver of land on the border for a slightly inflated price, but that was its own thing.

          But you can’t really call an armed invasion, and then a pittance paid out in damages, to be “Buying them all”.

          • @YoBuckStopsHere
            link
            English
            -1810 months ago

            The United States could have just taken all of Mexico, but it didn’t. It paid for the land. The population of the western states was made up of Americans anyhow, less than a thousand Mexican citizens lived in those areas at the time.

            • Alien Nathan Edward
              link
              fedilink
              710 months ago

              Someone: puts a gun to your head and says “I’ll give you $4 for your car”.

              You: “This is a free and fair trade.”

              • @YoBuckStopsHere
                link
                English
                -410 months ago

                That wasn’t the case, the Mexican government was run as an oligarchy. The United States threat was to threaten to turn over their lands to the public.

            • Decoy321
              link
              710 months ago

              How generous of you to call the natives American after the fact.

              • @YoBuckStopsHere
                link
                English
                -210 months ago

                That is actually addressed in the purchase agreement.

                • chaogomu
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1110 months ago

                  If a guy takes your car at gunpoint, and then hands you a fiver, he did not just “buy your car”.

                  A peace treaty at the end of a war of conquest is not a “purchase agreement”.

                  • @YoBuckStopsHere
                    link
                    English
                    -510 months ago

                    You are assuming a lot, especially that Mexico had a functional government even before their Army slaughters settlers in Texas.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              2
              edit-2
              10 months ago

              The US took most of the land from Mexico that was worth taking. There’s little viable agricultural land south of Texas. Also, it put a lot of land in between Mexico and New Orleans, which is an incredibly important international port. With that secured, no foreign army would be able to threaten that port without major logistics challenges, much less fighting through the US Army and every local citizen with a gun.

              The US grabbed what it wanted and let Mexico keep the scraps.

              • @YoBuckStopsHere
                link
                English
                -210 months ago

                That is looking at it from today, not from how it was viewed then. The main reason Mexico was fine with selling was the massive desert that separated the two areas and the extremely violent native population that inhabited the region. That reason didn’t become peaceful until the 1920s.

    • @wildcardology
      link
      6
      edit-2
      10 months ago

      The US bought the Philippines from Spain for $14 million. Then fought a war with the Filipinos.

        • @wildcardology
          link
          110 months ago

          Spain was loosing influence in the Philippines at that time so to cut their loses they offered the Philippines to the US. They even fought a mock battle where Spain “lost”.