It’s something that really winds me up about scifi shows, and I know there are always budget restrictions… but it just feels really lazy to me, for aliens to be simply humans with plasticine on their foreheads.
I’m reading one of Iain M. Banks’ ‘Culture’ series of hard scifi books, the depth and variety of not just alien species but ‘post-human’ modification is breathtaking. ‘The Culture’ is a far-flung hyper-technological society, no money, all wants and needs provided for, there are no drugs because everyone has their own drug gland. If you decide you want to try changing sex, off you go, the nanosuite will take care of it within a matter of days. Sick of being a humaniform? No problem, now you’re the bush-like bundle of tendrils of your dreams. Bored with being a bush? Maybe you want to download your consciousness into a drone, or the solar sail drive of a starship? Again, no problemo!
Hyperion explored that a bit. An incredibly wealthy character in the book makes himself into a Satyr. We are Legion (We are Bob) also has some really fun stuff with android host machines. The Bobs can be anything they want to be. The movie Arrival did an amazing job depicting non-humanoid aliens. But yes, most sci-fi is very lazy with the aliens.
For some reason, I only got the alert for your reply today!
I adore the Hyperion Cantos, it’s one of my favourite scifi book series ever, and I hope one day it gets the TV treatment it deserves. Always felt it would make an amazing show.
Yeah man, some of the coolest concepts I’ve ever read were in that series. The crusader’s ship that fucking demolishes their bodies from hyper acceleration and then rebuilds them during flight, all without their knowledge, was wild! My biggest fear about it being a series is that idk if there’s a way to create the Shrike in a live action recreation without making it look cheesy. The Shrike definitely benefits from the fogginess in the theater of the mind.
Yeah they’d have to do a LOT of R&D to make sure the Shrike looks suitably terrifying. The speed of it wouldn’t be a problem, they could get all the people who worked on The Flash!
I’ve been pleasantly surprised with TV versions of late. I didn’t watch Foundation until S02 dropped, I just saw no way they could do a show set over aeons. They’ve taken a lot of artistic license and I’ve heard from many who loved the books saying they’re unhappy with that, but I really enjoyed it. Three Body Problem season one was also fantastic, so fingers crossed that gets a second season (apparently it was very expensive to make so S01 may be all we get unfortunately).
I couldn’t get past the first few episodes of The Foundation. I’m one of those people who read the books who wasn’t happy with what they did for the show. It did look beautiful though, absolutely amazing.
Three Body Problem was excellent. They had a budget of 20 or 30 million dollars per episode though. I’ve been thinking about watching the Chinese version to see how it ends, since that version is finished, but I doubt they can make a show look as good as the Netflix one. The only part of that show that I didn’t like was Augie. Man, that’s the worst character I’ve ever seen. Not only is she terribly written, but she’s a terrible actor, and terribly miscast. The most unbelievable part of that show was that Augie would have any friends, and it’s a show about outer space aliens! LOL. But overall I really enjoyed the show. I watched the entire season in two days.
Tbh I did strongly expect massive changes to the Asimov books. They were written quite some time ago in a different social climate… I read the entire Asimov collection over lockdown and while he’s an excellent writer (reading other authors after a year of Asimov was like wading through treacle!), with massive inventive potential, I remember thinking to myself reading a lot of the stories “Well. That wouldn’t wash in this century”. Mostly casual sexism.
I imagine the showrunners read the source material and thought “Oh no, there’s no lead women characters. That’s not going to go down very well” and then the changes cascaded from there. Still a very enjoyable show, just have to try and disengage from the OG source material.
Fingers crossed for 3BP season 2! The bit with the ship and the military nanofibers was gruesome as fuck, I can get why the Augie character would’ve been very unhappy about that haha. But yeah I also found her character a bit annoying.
The sex of the characters honestly never even occurred to me in the foundation TV series. What I didn’t like about it is that they seemed to be making it a show about people, and the original stories are about concepts. They play out over thousands of years, and the individual characters only serve to illustrate those concepts. So a lot of the character interactions weren’t Asimov, who is an excellent writer, they were Apple TV writers, who aren’t even in the same category as one of the greats. It seemed contrived to me, and I got bored. I’m glad that people enjoyed it though. Even though it was changed, it’s cool that newer generations are still being exposed to Asimov.
Asimov is a great creative story teller, but I never got a sense while reading the books that his actual writing style was outstanding. I know the feeling you had though. When I finished reading 1984 everything else I read for at least a year seemed dull, and inferior. Orwell’s writing style amazed me. There were times when I’d read a paragraph and then think about it for several minutes and go back and read it again, just because I was so impressed with how wonderful Orwell’s phrasing was. I don’t mean to take anything away from Asimov, as he is obviously in the same league as Orwell. I think it just comes down to personal preference. They’re both outstanding writers.
I should also kind of amend my previous negativity towards Apple writers since I was incredibly impressed with Severance. They did an outstanding job with that show. They probably did a great job with Foundation too, it just wasn’t for me having read the source material first.
Every sentient species looks like a human into body modification.
And yeah, there is a storyline about all sentient species being related.
It’s something that really winds me up about scifi shows, and I know there are always budget restrictions… but it just feels really lazy to me, for aliens to be simply humans with plasticine on their foreheads.
I’m reading one of Iain M. Banks’ ‘Culture’ series of hard scifi books, the depth and variety of not just alien species but ‘post-human’ modification is breathtaking. ‘The Culture’ is a far-flung hyper-technological society, no money, all wants and needs provided for, there are no drugs because everyone has their own drug gland. If you decide you want to try changing sex, off you go, the nanosuite will take care of it within a matter of days. Sick of being a humaniform? No problem, now you’re the bush-like bundle of tendrils of your dreams. Bored with being a bush? Maybe you want to download your consciousness into a drone, or the solar sail drive of a starship? Again, no problemo!
Hyperion explored that a bit. An incredibly wealthy character in the book makes himself into a Satyr. We are Legion (We are Bob) also has some really fun stuff with android host machines. The Bobs can be anything they want to be. The movie Arrival did an amazing job depicting non-humanoid aliens. But yes, most sci-fi is very lazy with the aliens.
For some reason, I only got the alert for your reply today!
I adore the Hyperion Cantos, it’s one of my favourite scifi book series ever, and I hope one day it gets the TV treatment it deserves. Always felt it would make an amazing show.
Yeah man, some of the coolest concepts I’ve ever read were in that series. The crusader’s ship that fucking demolishes their bodies from hyper acceleration and then rebuilds them during flight, all without their knowledge, was wild! My biggest fear about it being a series is that idk if there’s a way to create the Shrike in a live action recreation without making it look cheesy. The Shrike definitely benefits from the fogginess in the theater of the mind.
Yeah they’d have to do a LOT of R&D to make sure the Shrike looks suitably terrifying. The speed of it wouldn’t be a problem, they could get all the people who worked on The Flash!
I’ve been pleasantly surprised with TV versions of late. I didn’t watch Foundation until S02 dropped, I just saw no way they could do a show set over aeons. They’ve taken a lot of artistic license and I’ve heard from many who loved the books saying they’re unhappy with that, but I really enjoyed it. Three Body Problem season one was also fantastic, so fingers crossed that gets a second season (apparently it was very expensive to make so S01 may be all we get unfortunately).
I couldn’t get past the first few episodes of The Foundation. I’m one of those people who read the books who wasn’t happy with what they did for the show. It did look beautiful though, absolutely amazing.
Three Body Problem was excellent. They had a budget of 20 or 30 million dollars per episode though. I’ve been thinking about watching the Chinese version to see how it ends, since that version is finished, but I doubt they can make a show look as good as the Netflix one. The only part of that show that I didn’t like was Augie. Man, that’s the worst character I’ve ever seen. Not only is she terribly written, but she’s a terrible actor, and terribly miscast. The most unbelievable part of that show was that Augie would have any friends, and it’s a show about outer space aliens! LOL. But overall I really enjoyed the show. I watched the entire season in two days.
Tbh I did strongly expect massive changes to the Asimov books. They were written quite some time ago in a different social climate… I read the entire Asimov collection over lockdown and while he’s an excellent writer (reading other authors after a year of Asimov was like wading through treacle!), with massive inventive potential, I remember thinking to myself reading a lot of the stories “Well. That wouldn’t wash in this century”. Mostly casual sexism.
I imagine the showrunners read the source material and thought “Oh no, there’s no lead women characters. That’s not going to go down very well” and then the changes cascaded from there. Still a very enjoyable show, just have to try and disengage from the OG source material.
Fingers crossed for 3BP season 2! The bit with the ship and the military nanofibers was gruesome as fuck, I can get why the Augie character would’ve been very unhappy about that haha. But yeah I also found her character a bit annoying.
The sex of the characters honestly never even occurred to me in the foundation TV series. What I didn’t like about it is that they seemed to be making it a show about people, and the original stories are about concepts. They play out over thousands of years, and the individual characters only serve to illustrate those concepts. So a lot of the character interactions weren’t Asimov, who is an excellent writer, they were Apple TV writers, who aren’t even in the same category as one of the greats. It seemed contrived to me, and I got bored. I’m glad that people enjoyed it though. Even though it was changed, it’s cool that newer generations are still being exposed to Asimov.
Asimov is a great creative story teller, but I never got a sense while reading the books that his actual writing style was outstanding. I know the feeling you had though. When I finished reading 1984 everything else I read for at least a year seemed dull, and inferior. Orwell’s writing style amazed me. There were times when I’d read a paragraph and then think about it for several minutes and go back and read it again, just because I was so impressed with how wonderful Orwell’s phrasing was. I don’t mean to take anything away from Asimov, as he is obviously in the same league as Orwell. I think it just comes down to personal preference. They’re both outstanding writers.
I should also kind of amend my previous negativity towards Apple writers since I was incredibly impressed with Severance. They did an outstanding job with that show. They probably did a great job with Foundation too, it just wasn’t for me having read the source material first.