Again it’s not that the good resources don’t exist, it’s that AI floods the search with garbage. Also, AI isn’t just writing garbage books, they’re also making AI generated websites that are SEO optimized beyond human capability pushing the good resources out of the top search results.
Which is why they suggested finding an organization/association, not an arbitrary website.
Funnily enough, chatgpt should be able to recommend some great associations. GPT-3 doesn’t even have up-to-date databases so it doesn’t even know about any new AI things that have popped up.
Which is why they suggested finding an organization/association
How does one start searching for an organization/association? My first instinct, and pretty much everyone I know’s first instinct, would be to search online for a mycology group, which is likely surrounded by other highly SEO optimized AI generated mycology group website. And then you go to a meet that doesn’t exist, and you try the next group you found online and find that group doesn’t exist, ad infinitum.
Buy a book published more that a couple of years ago. Or ask the people living in the area (the older the better, normally ). Or ask the people living in the area where you can have the mushrooms checked, they usually know where to go.
In the absence of a local club, I’m not sure. I mean, have a look at the cover on this one—I understand that’s considered one of the more reliable and informative guides for the locations it covers, which is why it’s still in print after 30+ years, but the only reason that photo doesn’t look AI generated is that you can’t imagine how they would have come up with the prompt . . .
How does one find a mycology forum or club without falling prey to SEO optimized AI generated results? AI isn’t just generating books, they can write fake web pages for non-existent clubs and fake entire forums and optimize the hell out of the SEO to maximize positioning on Google’s search results.
Exactly, and then keep doing that over and over again until you either dig through enough garbage to find the good source or just throw your hands in the air and give up trying to find good sources and either give up the hobby all together or say fuck it and go at it alone.
Tldr: Use reliable sources when hunting mushrooms.
While agreed, how do you find the reliable surfaces amid the sea of garbage, especially when you’re first starting out?
before:2023
search for a local mycological society or association?
Again it’s not that the good resources don’t exist, it’s that AI floods the search with garbage. Also, AI isn’t just writing garbage books, they’re also making AI generated websites that are SEO optimized beyond human capability pushing the good resources out of the top search results.
Which is why they suggested finding an organization/association, not an arbitrary website.
Funnily enough, chatgpt should be able to recommend some great associations. GPT-3 doesn’t even have up-to-date databases so it doesn’t even know about any new AI things that have popped up.
So find a real group of people, ask them things.
How does one start searching for an organization/association? My first instinct, and pretty much everyone I know’s first instinct, would be to search online for a mycology group, which is likely surrounded by other highly SEO optimized AI generated mycology group website. And then you go to a meet that doesn’t exist, and you try the next group you found online and find that group doesn’t exist, ad infinitum.
Buy a book published more that a couple of years ago. Or ask the people living in the area (the older the better, normally ). Or ask the people living in the area where you can have the mushrooms checked, they usually know where to go.
In the absence of a local club, I’m not sure. I mean, have a look at the cover on this one—I understand that’s considered one of the more reliable and informative guides for the locations it covers, which is why it’s still in print after 30+ years, but the only reason that photo doesn’t look AI generated is that you can’t imagine how they would have come up with the prompt . . .
Mycology forums and clubs can be good ways to find reliable books, apps, etc for identification
How does one find a mycology forum or club without falling prey to SEO optimized AI generated results? AI isn’t just generating books, they can write fake web pages for non-existent clubs and fake entire forums and optimize the hell out of the SEO to maximize positioning on Google’s search results.
Sure, but youre talking about Dead Internet Theory at that point, which applies to all topics not just mycology
If you try to contact the club, but can’t actually meet anyone, it’s fake or might as well be.
Exactly, and then keep doing that over and over again until you either dig through enough garbage to find the good source or just throw your hands in the air and give up trying to find good sources and either give up the hobby all together or say fuck it and go at it alone.
Ask the people living in the area. They know the mushrooms and eventually they know where to go to have them checked.