Police are investigating a virtual sexual assault of a girl’s avatar, the chair of the Association of Police and Crime Commissioners has said.

Donna Jones said she had learned that a complaint was made in 2023, triggering a police inquiry.

The virtual incident did not result in physical harm but caused “psychological trauma”, the Daily Mail has reported a source as saying. Police chiefs have called on platforms to do more to protect their users.

The impact of the attack on the girl’s avatar was said to be heightened because of the immersive nature of the VR experience.

  • Kalkaline
    link
    fedilink
    13711 months ago

    I can’t make up my mind on this one. On one hand we probably should make some rules etiquette and laws regarding VR, but on the other hand I made it through the Halo series just fine and was able to separate myself from what those people did to my corpse.

    • Cyber Yuki
      link
      4011 months ago

      I would classify this as sexual harassment. It’s no different from being sent obscene videos over email. The gravity resides in that they’re sexual assault videos with the recipient being the victim.

      • kase
        link
        211 months ago

        This situation reminds me of the deepfake porn issue that’s been going around as well. Ofc there are differences, but mainly I mean the confusion around it of ‘how he hell do we categorize this’. I don’t know nearly enough to make a judgement here, but yours does sound reasonable imho.

        (People have been saying this website isn’t super trustworthy, so I’m taking it with a grain of salt. Even if the story is fake - I’m not saying it is, for all I know it may be true, though I hope not - I imagine it’s still worthy of discussion as something that could happen.)

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      2311 months ago

      Having been involved in something that was actually bad, I can say with certainty that there are enough rules already (in most places) that apply to these sorts of situations. Harassment and stalking crimes cover the sorts of things that need to be handled by police. If someone teabags you in Halo, or curses at you or says disgusting things in a voice chat, you either block them or shake your head and move on. If they follow you around through multiple lobbies, send/spam pictures or post/spray real pictures of genitalia (in places where it is not supposed to be, such as your inbox/cellphone/vr lobbies, obviously not talking about nsfw sites), those things are already crimes covered by harassment/stalking/sexting crimes.

      There may be a few edge cases where someone can skirt the laws, but again, in my experience, the statutes are broad enough to catch almost everything you could imagine and want to be a crime.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        611 months ago

        Totally agree with you! If we are talking laws, it needs to be covered by general laws. Hopefully it already is wherever ppl are. It makes no sense to create specific laws for online games and VR games. Otherwise the next new tech needs its special law again, and the making of law is always late.

        If we are talking etiquette, Netiquette exists.

      • littleblue✨
        link
        -27
        edit-2
        11 months ago

        Let me guess: cis-het white dude? Yeah. Tracks.

          • littleblue✨
            link
            -1711 months ago

            You didn’t have to underline my point, but go ahead, I guess. Bro.

            • kase
              link
              211 months ago

              I’m not sure anyone here knows what your point is, could you explain?

              • littleblue✨
                link
                011 months ago

                I give 0 fucks about imaginary internet points, and the downvoters are only showing their collective bareass lack of ability to read for comprehension, but sure, I’ll bite:

                …in my experience, the statutes are broad enough to catch almost everything you could imagine and want to be a crime.

                Just screams in blithe confidence most often reserved for the privilege of white, cis-het males. To say nothing of the presumption that simply labeling something as a crime insures enforcement (aka “justice”), which would certainly stem from a lifelong pattern of that same ignorance re: one’s own privilege.

                Carry on with your echo chamber, citizens. You’re doing great.

    • @foggy
      link
      2211 months ago

      crouch crouch crouch

    • Flying Squid
      link
      1011 months ago

      It’s a little silly at this stage, but I think there needs to be a legal framework around this thing now because eventually, our games will be realistic enough and immersive enough that this could become a serious issue.

      • Lath
        link
        fedilink
        4211 months ago

        You’re joking right? Read about Ellen Page and the Beyond:Two Souls controversy.

        Shit’s already here. It’s not just a little silly anymore. And with those AI deep fakes floating around, anyone can become a pornstar without even knowing about it.

        People already killing themselves for fake rape allegations and social media pariah-ism, what now that fake porn with you in it can be made at any time?

        This shit’s a disaster in the making, not just a little silly.

        • Cyborganism
          link
          fedilink
          2111 months ago

          This is the best comment in this thread so far. You make some excellent points.

          What that girl experienced is definitely a form of harassment. And the VR part just made it more real than simple texts or photos. Which I think should be considered as a form of psychological assault.

          And how fucked up must men and rape culture be that a girl can’t even feel safe in a fucking virtual reality setting. Seriously, that’s a big WTF. This is just sad.

          • @LowtierComputer
            link
            1011 months ago

            I’d say it’s more expected. People feel fat less social restraints when online. VR is no different.

          • @diffcalculus
            link
            English
            111 months ago

            Glad to see these opinions. A lot of this thread is full of ignorant people.

        • @Hubi
          link
          311 months ago

          I’d get life in prison for sure.

        • Flying Squid
          link
          -511 months ago

          Again, eventually it could become a serious issue.

      • Cornpop
        link
        English
        111 months ago

        Absolutely not! That’s absurd. You can’t virtually rape someone or virtually assault someone. You can always just look away, remove the headset, or turn off the pc. You can always instantly remove yourself from the situation. You are never in a position of danger. You are never in any way being harmed. The police should arrest the person that called them for wasting their time.

        • Flying Squid
          link
          2211 months ago

          You can always hang up the phone if you’re getting repeatedly harassed on the phone too. That doesn’t make it any less harassment. Of course it doesn’t rise to the level of physical rape. That doesn’t mean it isn’t (intentionally) psychologically damaging. And, as I said, it needs to be done before it gets a lot more immersive, not because of the way things are right now. It could very well not be so easy to instantly remove yourself in the future.

          • Cornpop
            link
            English
            -711 months ago

            I have a feeling that this isint the case of people repeatedly targeting an individual every time they are online. Seems like it was something that happened once, and that’s not harassment. That’s joking around.

            • Flying Squid
              link
              411 months ago

              I’m not talking about this case in particular. I’m talking about the need to establish a legal framework before it becomes such a problem that everyone wonders why there isn’t a law against it.

              • Cornpop
                link
                English
                -311 months ago

                We have managed fine this far. Nothing new. Police can stay out of video games.

                • Flying Squid
                  link
                  211 months ago

                  Yes, we managed this far at he immersiveness and realism level of games so far. Eventually, and this is really the goal for a lot of people, games will be so realistic and immersive that you’ll feel like you’re actually there. And that is a big problem when it comes to sexual harassment. So maybe we should make sure that we’re prepared.

              • Cornpop
                link
                English
                011 months ago

                You can’t be raped through a screen though

                • Cyborganism
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -111 months ago

                  No. But a simulation of a rape can leave you feeling the same psychological trauma. Or at the very least feel completely disgusted with yourself and can lead to serious depression and maybe worse.

                  Why is it so hard for you guys to understand that people have the right to feel safe, even online, and not feel like there are people out there with a rapist mentality?

            • Kobol
              link
              fedilink
              211 months ago

              Hate to tell you but things can be considered harassment even if “it only happened once”

              • Cornpop
                link
                English
                -2
                edit-2
                11 months ago

                Is this your first time in a video game? People seem to think that their feelings are the police’s problem. It’s weird af. You don’t have the right to never be annoyed or upset.

        • verysoft
          link
          fedilink
          3
          edit-2
          11 months ago

          Yeah but I am assuming you are an adult?
          Kids get pulled into things like this and dont just remove the headset, they are much more malleable than a grown adult.

          The question is, shouldnt their parents be supervising them? Perhaps their parents dont even know about these online worlds filled with people? Did the parents buy them VR without any research into what you can do with it? There’s a lot of education that needs doing for both children and adults concerning online safety, more and more so as the online world advances.

          • @MindSkipperBro12
            link
            611 months ago

            That’s the parent’s fault for letting them play something without adult supervision.

          • Cornpop
            link
            English
            311 months ago

            Little Kids just shouldn’t be using this stuff, or should at least be supervised. Young adults can handle trash talk and gamer bs lol. This is such a non issue that people are just grasping at straws to try and make an issue it’s insane.

            • verysoft
              link
              fedilink
              1
              edit-2
              11 months ago

              It’s an issue if kids can get a hold of this stuff and access it, yes. Parenting is the main problem, I agree, but not every parent is competent enough to look out for this kind of stuff, also this stuff is often heavily marketed towards children.

              I think adults sexually harrassing children online is an issue, if you don’t, then I don’t know what to say.

              • Cornpop
                link
                English
                411 months ago

                I mean what is sexual harassment in a game? Saying something vulgar? Getting close to their avitar? That’s not sexual harassment to me.

        • kase
          link
          111 months ago

          I don’t know if this is true, but based on what I could find on google, cyber bullying is illegal in some places, including most US states (again, not sure about that, please correct me if I’m wrong). My point is, it’s not a new idea to get the law involved in a situation regarding online harassment. A victim could probably avoid it by logging off, but the legal precedent seems to be that they shouldn’t be expected to. That seems reasonable to me, just considering I wouldn’t tell someone to ‘just leave’ an irl space because someone was harassing them.

          I agree in that I wouldn’t call what happened here ‘rape’ in a legal sense, but if you’re saying that something is inherently harmless because it’s done online, I strongly disagree. Otherwise, sorry if I misunderstood.

        • Flying Squid
          link
          2011 months ago

          “I think they shouldn’t have worn such a short skirt.”

          How about we don’t blame people for others sexually harassing or assaulting them?

          Especially when they’re trying to have some harmless fun.

          • @MindSkipperBro12
            link
            -2
            edit-2
            11 months ago

            Just block and report, it’s that easy, if you want to continue being in the situation.

            • Flying Squid
              link
              611 months ago

              And if the game doesn’t have that option? There’s no legal requirement to have that option. Maybe there should be?

                • Flying Squid
                  link
                  311 months ago

                  I have never seen a ‘block and report’ feature on any OS. And there is certainly no requirement for games to use it if there were.

  • @whaleross
    link
    10311 months ago

    It sounds ridiculous that they assaulted an avatar. I think it is the wrong take. The avatar is just the medium. The target was obviously the person behind the avatar. It’s like saying that threats over text message is assaulting her phone.

    • DreamButt
      link
      English
      1911 months ago

      Ssssh it’s okay iphone. Don’t listen to them. I know you were just protecting me from the bullies in high school

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      14
      edit-2
      11 months ago

      I didn’t know how to feel about the headline when I read it, is it possible to do that? I still don’t know. It’s not really for me to decide how SHE feels either. It just sounds… Weird? And not possible? I don’t know.

      Regardless, in my mind, it depends on what the action was. If I send a text to your phone to hack it, then I guess I’m “assaulting your phone” but if the phone is the medium used to get to you then obviously it’s towards you.

      And this can all be made moot by the software devs with an input box “keep non-friends N meters away”. Its all tech and virtual. Whatever she has a problem with can be an option to toggle for her.

      • @whaleross
        link
        2911 months ago

        Example from the article what it can look like:

        Recalling the experience, Ms Patel told the same programme that she was “surrounded by three to four male-sounding and male-representing avatars, who started sexually harassing me in a verbal sense and then sexually assaulting my avatar”.

        She said they had used misogynistic language and “continued to touch my avatar in a way that can only be described as a sexual assault of my avatar”.

        So, I guess the appropriate terminology would be sexual harassment of the person by virtual sexual assault on their avatar in the VR space, or something like that.

        I can imagine for an innocent person unprepared for it to be ganged and surrounded by deviants in VR sounds like it could be a proper traumatic experience. I don’t think there should be downplaying or normalizing this kind of experience for the sole reason that pervs are to be expected online. There is no reason to sink expectations of society to the lowest uncommon deranged denominator.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          4
          edit-2
          11 months ago

          I feel guilty for that, I really do, but this description is very funny for me in a way a South Park episode could be.

          • @whaleross
            link
            111 months ago

            It is absurd and funny, I agree, but only because it is not representative of what actually happened.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              111 months ago

              Yeah, I had and sometimes still have very strong feelings over much smaller unpleasantries in the Web, so it is bad.

        • @FluorideMind
          link
          111 months ago

          No one is down playing it, it’s being up played by being labeled sexual assault. At worst this should be considered harassment.

          • @whaleross
            link
            211 months ago

            Plenty of comments here alone dismiss everything about it.

            We, as a seasoned internet nerd community and the gamers amongst us in particular, may have been exposed to edgy and lewd behaviour online since forever, not that it is a good thing.

            It should not be considered normal that it happens everywhere online and it should not be expected that everyone should be as cynical and desensitised as we are.

            But yeah. Assault is the wrong charge. It is sexual harassment. And it should be taken seriously.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    9611 months ago

    Maybe when an article says “The daily mail jas reported” we should completely ignore it until a better paper reports on it. Everything coming from the daily mail should be considered a lie.

    • @chitak166
      link
      -111 months ago

      I guess you’d have a point if this didn’t really happen.

      • Echo Dot
        link
        fedilink
        111 months ago

        But the only evidence this did happen is from the Daily Mail so you can see the problem. It’s like trusting Fox as a reliable news source

        • @chitak166
          link
          011 months ago

          Are you saying it didn’t happen, then?

  • @Feathercrown
    link
    English
    93
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    This is sexual harrassment, not assault. It’s still disgusting, but there’s no reasonable expectation of harm. They can always take off the headset.

    • @Maggoty
      link
      2811 months ago

      And yet it’s completely possible to kill someone with cyber bullying. Trauma is trauma.

    • AnyOldName3
      link
      -1311 months ago

      It’s entirely reasonable that a panicking and scared child might forget they can escape by removing their headset, or experience enough to end up traumatised before they’ve got it off - if they don’t log out, too, they’ll know people are still there doing things to a representation of themselves. There’s still harm, even if the exact nature of the harm is different.

  • Chaos
    link
    4311 months ago

    The amount of murder I have done in gaming. I’m going away for a long time boys💀

  • @JustARaccoon
    link
    3911 months ago

    VR is immersive, but it isn’t that immersive, especially when it comes to user feedback

    • LUHG
      link
      511 months ago

      If it got that good vr would be in every household. Can’t wait to get a strangers finger up the bum.

    • @Candelestine
      link
      English
      511 months ago

      It’s not objective, it’s subjective. 100% of “immersion” is happening in your brain, where the signals received by your senses are being processed into experiences. Thus, different people will experience different levels of immersion, which is how things should be, instead of everyone being expected to try to feel the same as everyone else when faced with the same stimuli.

      Basically you’re expressing an opinion. Which is fine, people can have those, but others can have other ones too. And that is also fine.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1011 months ago

        We’re talking about safe spaces again. Some people are hyper sensitive to things other people can tolerate just fine. It’s tricky to protect those people without criminalising behaviours that are harmless in normal circumstances. Once you criminalise everything everyone can become a criminal.

      • @JustARaccoon
        link
        811 months ago

        What I mean is there’s nothing pushing or pulling at you, you can clip your hand into the other person (or mush it to a point where it’s visually disconnected from where your arm is), you can easily remove yourself from the situation by logging off, taking the headset off, or both.

        • @Candelestine
          link
          English
          111 months ago

          That’s fair. I can see a state of panic potentially being involved, but that could be addressed with technical improvements. Monitoring your eyeballs perhaps, and some sort of panic safety switch.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        211 months ago

        I think that’s fair, but I also think there’s something clinically wrong with people who’s reaction is anything but ripping off the headset when they feel violated

        And I mean that in the context that these people should be given therapy for free. That level of attachment to an avatar is not a trait of a healthy person

        To illustrate my point, there’s people who described their gta5 characters being violated was like being raped… If you’re being raped, and you could shut your eyes to make it stop, and you don’t…

        • @Candelestine
          link
          English
          111 months ago

          That’s fine. We don’t use opinions or outliers to determine what is/isn’t clinically wrong though, it all varies too much. Humans are very unpredictable, we’re a good bit more complicated than most other animals. Medicine is not supposed to be a tool for conformity, but health. So, it has to acknowledge that people just aren’t logical. We’re wet, sloppy, buggy computers.

  • Echo Dot
    link
    fedilink
    3811 months ago

    [the victim] suffered psychological trauma “similar to that of someone who has been physically raped”.

    No she didn’t. I’m sure it wasn’t a pleasant experience, but let’s not over exaggerate the situation.

    • @feedum_sneedson
      link
      611 months ago

      If it had been my avatar, I wonder if they’d be making that claim. As in, if it was literally the same avatar but I’d been wearing the headset.

    • Phoenixz
      link
      fedilink
      411 months ago

      Yeah but wild we don’t over exaggerate the situation, how will I get all the attention?

    • deaf_fish
      link
      fedilink
      211 months ago

      I’m not so sure I agree with you. If I had a choice between getting raped IRL or Virtually, I would choose Virtually any day.

      But that doesn’t mean you couldn’t get PTSD or some other trauma from being virtually assaulted. As far as I know, the brain sees all trauma equality because brains are dumb like that. So I think it is possible the victim is experiencing similar trauma to being raped IRL.

    • @Custoslibera
      link
      011 months ago

      No we don’t.

      Our world is complex and burying our heads in the sand about new frontiers of harassment does nothing good.

      • @FluorideMind
        link
        111 months ago

        What does nothing good is diminishing what sexual assault actually means.

  • @yamanii
    link
    3311 months ago

    Let’s wait for the feel suits to arrive before equating virtual “crimes” to real ones, especially in a medium where you can just block anyone, at most this should go in the same place a death threat via text goes for now.

    • @chitak166
      link
      111 months ago

      Eh, I’d say death threats should be followed up on.

      ‘Virtual sexual harassment’ should be followed up on if it involves threats of real crimes.

      Saying, “I’m gonna come to your house and rape you” is definitely cause for criminal investigation, if there’s enough evidence to make it viable.

      Saying, “you like that, don’t you?” while “fondling” an avatar in VR is not cause for criminal investigation.

  • I Cast Fist
    link
    fedilink
    English
    2911 months ago

    The victim was in an online ‘room’ with a large number of fellow users when the virtual assault by several adult men took place.

    Taken from the DailyMail. Neither article has details on which VR game/app she was, nor what kind of “assault” it was. The dailymail says it was “on the metaverse”, but “metaverse” could be VRChat, Fortnite or fucking Second Life for all we know. Could’ve even been on fuckzuck’s metaverse, Horizon Worlds, but isn’t it the place where you don’t have a bottom half and other avatars are forced to stay the equivalent of 1.5m away from you at all times?

  • kingthrillgore
    link
    fedilink
    28
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    the Daily Mail

    Ah yes so file this under shit that never happened.

    Assaulting someone in a VR game is still assault especially if they never consented.

    • @Zeon
      link
      711 months ago

      ‘Assaulting someone in a VR game is still assault especially if they never consented.’

      Sarcasm?

  • Dr. Coomer
    link
    English
    2711 months ago

    The fact that this is even compared to real SA is so fucked up. At least on the internet or game you can leave, it’s not like your forced to endure the actions or behavior of other people.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    24
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    Are you fucking kidding me?

    They took cops off of real cases to work a VIRTUAL ASSAULT in a video game. (just harassment, not assault btw)

    JFC I hope we fucking get nuked soon. We don’t deserve to live.

    • Cyborganism
      link
      fedilink
      211 months ago

      Can you at least agree that this is a case of harassment and cyber bullying?

      Ah have you tried putting yourself in that person’s shoes at all and try to imagine how their experience might have felt like?

      I don’t know about you, but if I was 16 and went into a VR environment, where you practically feel like you’re really there, with the intention to have some fun with friends, and a bunch of grown ass men started getting together and simulated a rape with explicit violent language, I would probably not feel very happy or secure. I’d probably log out feeling pretty dirty and uncomfortable. Basically the same kind of feeling you’d get from any form of sexual assault in real life.

      What happened in that VR environment was done by real people who thought it was okay to sexually assault a teenage girl, even if it was virtual. They’re basically rape apologists and are enabling rape culture. Realizing the fact there are men like this is scary enough to be traumatized and never trust men again.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        7
        edit-2
        11 months ago

        Did you read my comment or just go on a text block spree without finishing it?

        For reference:

        “… They took cops off of real cases to work a VIRTUAL ASSAULT in a video game. (just harassment, not assault btw)”

        Pretending like this is a problem that requires police intervention is easily one of the most immature and incompetent things I’ve ever seen.

        You know video games have moderators right?

        • Cyborganism
          link
          fedilink
          111 months ago

          For one, it doesn’t say that at all in the article.

          Second, harassment and cyberbullying is a real case. Especially when it involves sexually explicit material or simulating sexual activity and the victim is a minor.

          So yes, this is very much a real case.

      • @chitak166
        link
        -111 months ago

        You don’t have to socialize with those people.

        You have the tools at your disposal to control who you interact with online.

        • Cyborganism
          link
          fedilink
          -111 months ago

          I don’t know what platform they were using. And maybe in a VR setting, and with multiple characters, it’s a little difficult to find out who the perpetrators are.

          When I play an online FPS game for example, I don’t always see our notice the names of the players I interact with.

          And that’s beside the point anyway. That girl has the right to feel safe even in a VR setting where the aim of the platform is to simply interact with others as you would in real life. I don’t know why nobody here understands this.

          • @chitak166
            link
            3
            edit-2
            11 months ago

            I don’t think people have the right to ‘feel safe’ around every single person they interact with on the internet. If she doesn’t like how those people behave, she’s free to leave and interact with others.

            At some point, we have to take responsibility for our own actions and the people we choose to associate with.

            • Cyborganism
              link
              fedilink
              -311 months ago

              Oh really?

              So she gets harassed online and she’s the one that has to leave? She’s the one that has to sacrifice her enjoyment of the game due to other people’s bad behaviour?

              That seems fair to you?

              • @chitak166
                link
                211 months ago

                She can still enjoy the game. Nobody is forcing her to interact with those people.

                Even if the game was built around enabling them, then she could always go play a different game or just about anything else. Nobody is forcing her to play a game that makes her feel uncomfortable.

                The same goes for, say, going to forums where people say things you don’t like. You have the power to leave. Taxpayer resources shouldn’t be wasted in making sure every single microcosm on the internet makes everyone ‘feel safe.’

                I don’t understand why this is such a difficult concept for you.

                • Cyborganism
                  link
                  fedilink
                  -4
                  edit-2
                  11 months ago

                  Because that concept that YOU are defining here enables the aggressors and, in this case, perpetuates rape culture.

                  If I were to be harassed, sexually or otherwise, in a forum like this one right here, the mods would ban the harasser. It’s their duty to allow the users to be in a safe, respectful and civil environment.

                  And if I were to be harassed continually on any Lemmy instance, there are cyber bullying laws in most countries to address this and you can be sure the police would be involved. Online harassment is a real world issue with real world consequences.

                  Edit: And no, she can’t enjoy the game anymore knowing that this shit happened to her and can happen again and again. It completely ruined the experience for her.