I’ve had this reoccurring thing every year or so where I remember this book I read in like 5th - 6th grade that was really fucking good every year or so. I need to find it, I try every time but no amount of Googling thin recollections of its plot has got me anywhere.

  • @SpaceNoodle
    link
    169 months ago

    You should try asking groups of people in online fora … you know, like this one.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    89 months ago

    Names? Places? Dates? Genres? Themes? You’ve got to give us more than “it was really fucking good.”

    • ComradeSharkfuckerOP
      link
      fedilink
      59 months ago

      Alright since y’all are asking for details I’ll explain the plot roughly. I only didn’t because I’ve tried this before and it didn’t work out on Reddit years ago so I don’t expect an even smaller sample size to work but I guess it’s worth a shot.

      Basically there are 3 siblings. I think they are all female but their might be a younger male. It’s from the perspective of the oldest sibling. The are being antagonize by some guy for some reason I can’t remember but I think it had something to do with their parents.

      Somehow they get their hands on a time book and go back in time to I think around the 1800s where apparently magic was a thing and so were dwarves and elves and other magical creatures. It’s explained that the reason these creatures and magic don’t exist is because humanity basically genocide them. It’s also implied that the guy antagonizing them was partly or maybe wholey responsible. Also the main character the eldest has some magic in her.

      Her and her siblings stay in an orphanage or halfway house where she meets a boy and falls in love yada yada. That boy teaches her magic and when the orphanage burns down she saves his life. Turns out that boy was a younger version of the guy that was antagonizing them in the present.

      There’s also some sort of relationship between life, death, and time or they hold a special sort of power I’m not sure. It is implied that the younger siblings will come into possession of a book of life and a book of death.

      That’s as much as I can remember I think

    • ComradeSharkfuckerOP
      link
      fedilink
      39 months ago

      Alright since y’all are asking for details I’ll explain the plot roughly. I only didn’t because I’ve tried this before and it didn’t work out on Reddit years ago so I don’t expect an even smaller sample size to work but I guess it’s worth a shot.

      Basically there are 3 siblings. I think they are all female but their might be a younger male. It’s from the perspective of the oldest sibling. The are being antagonize by some guy for some reason I can’t remember but I think it had something to do with their parents.

      Somehow they get their hands on a time book and go back in time to I think around the 1800s where apparently magic was a thing and so were dwarves and elves and other magical creatures. It’s explained that the reason these creatures and magic don’t exist is because humanity basically genocide them. It’s also implied that the guy antagonizing them was partly or maybe wholey responsible. Also the main character the eldest has some magic in her.

      Her and her siblings stay in an orphanage or halfway house where she meets a boy and falls in love yada yada. That boy teaches her magic and when the orphanage burns down she saves his life. Turns out that boy was a younger version of the guy that was antagonizing them in the present.

      There’s also some sort of relationship between life, death, and time or they hold a special sort of power I’m not sure. It is implied that the younger siblings will come into possession of a book of life and a book of death.

      That’s as much as I can remember I think

  • @ChicoSuave
    link
    39 months ago

    What else do you remember? Any details would be helpful and if we can’t figure it out, those details will help steer follow up referrals.

    • ComradeSharkfuckerOP
      link
      fedilink
      49 months ago

      Alright since y’all are asking for details I’ll explain the plot roughly. I only didn’t because I’ve tried this before and it didn’t work out on Reddit years ago so I don’t expect an even smaller sample size to work but I guess it’s worth a shot.

      Basically there are 3 siblings. I think they are all female but their might be a younger male. It’s from the perspective of the oldest sibling. The are being antagonize by some guy for some reason I can’t remember but I think it had something to do with their parents.

      Somehow they get their hands on a time book and go back in time to I think around the 1800s where apparently magic was a thing and so were dwarves and elves and other magical creatures. It’s explained that the reason these creatures and magic don’t exist is because humanity basically genocide them. It’s also implied that the guy antagonizing them was partly or maybe wholey responsible. Also the main character the eldest has some magic in her.

      Her and her siblings stay in an orphanage or halfway house where she meets a boy and falls in love yada yada. That boy teaches her magic and when the orphanage burns down she saves his life. Turns out that boy was a younger version of the guy that was antagonizing them in the present.

      There’s also some sort of relationship between life, death, and time or they hold a special sort of power I’m not sure. It is implied that the younger siblings will come into possession of a book of life and a book of death.

      That’s as much as I can remember I think

    • @essteeyou
      link
      39 months ago

      I used ChatGPT to find an old story I remember a teacher telling in assembly about 23 years ago.

  • Xariphon
    link
    fedilink
    3
    edit-2
    9 months ago

    The Girl From Everywhere has a theme of time travel via maps and includes 1800s Hawaii.

    Clockwise by Elle Strauss includes a girl time traveling to the 1800s.

    Three people time traveling via book and eventually involving three related girls could be The Time Warp Trio series. No mention of the 1800s specifically though.

    Edit: The Emerald Atlas checks more boxes than any of these and is probably your best bet.

  • @kat_angstrom
    link
    29 months ago

    I also long for a description in order to hopefully help your dream come true.

    • ComradeSharkfuckerOP
      link
      fedilink
      29 months ago

      Alright since y’all are asking for details I’ll explain the plot roughly. I only didn’t because I’ve tried this before and it didn’t work out on Reddit years ago so I don’t expect an even smaller sample size to work but I guess it’s worth a shot.

      Basically there are 3 siblings. I think they are all female but their might be a younger male. It’s from the perspective of the oldest sibling. The are being antagonize by some guy for some reason I can’t remember but I think it had something to do with their parents.

      Somehow they get their hands on a time book and go back in time to I think around the 1800s where apparently magic was a thing and so were dwarves and elves and other magical creatures. It’s explained that the reason these creatures and magic don’t exist is because humanity basically genocide them. It’s also implied that the guy antagonizing them was partly or maybe wholey responsible. Also the main character the eldest has some magic in her.

      Her and her siblings stay in an orphanage or halfway house where she meets a boy and falls in love yada yada. That boy teaches her magic and when the orphanage burns down she saves his life. Turns out that boy was a younger version of the guy that was antagonizing them in the present.

      There’s also some sort of relationship between life, death, and time or they hold a special sort of power I’m not sure. It is implied that the younger siblings will come into possession of a book of life and a book of death.

      That’s as much as I can remember I think

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    18 months ago

    You could try asking your local Youth Services Librarian. They see so many books and often have some amount of research backgrounds. They also tend to LOVE this kind of mystery.

  • @jordanlund
    link
    19 months ago

    I wish there was a way to get old Scholastic catalogs for school book drives, I bet that would be a good way to do it.

    Think of the year you saw it, then check all the catalogs from 3-5 years before and after.