I want to discuss a better means of organizing tags for websites that use a generic tagging system. I propose a tag hierarchy.
Basically, if I search for #dog, I should find posts with #puppy, #pug, #baby_pugs, #cute_dogs, etc.
But, if I search for #pug, I should only get posts with #pug, or other tags like #baby_pugs, #cute_pugs, etc.
This would make adding 50+ similar tags to a post irrelevant and allow for normal people to put a single obscure tag and still gain visibility.
I want to bring this idea up to more people. Where should I discuss this? You can suggest any website, community, or Lemmy instance where I could possibly develop this further.
I’m happy to discuss this here as well.
[Edit for clarity]: I am not just talking about tags for the federation and Mastodon. I am talking about improving any and all websites with a generic tagging system. Twitter, Instagram, Facebook, etc. etc.
Structurally the idea has some merit. I think the challenge that you will encounter especially in a federated environment is gaining agreement on how to fill that structure and the hierarchy that you’re implying and demonstrating. Using the pug example, you’ll likely find very little argument on a good hierarchy, but using a more contentious example, let’s say gender, how will you gain agreement across instances on what the hierarchy within the data should represent?
That is more of an argument involving the implementation of tags in general within the federation. But to answer your question:
Let’s say a group of people were to make a post on Mastodon with the tag #girls_night. How will all instances agree on the tag being correct?
The simple answer is they won’t. If a tag is contentious, it will be like any other drama between instances.
It’s the same for implementing tag hierarchy. Let’s say there is a default setup. Then if a tag or a tree of tags is contentious, each instance can include or exclude as they see fit.
Ok I got ya. Doesn’t that then limit the effective use of the hierarchy to the instance you’re on and the hierarchy you’re familiar with? In that the further removed you are from your home instance’s hierarchy the less likely things will match up. So ultimately searches loose effectiveness I think?
Anyhow like someone else said, not trying to disparage the idea - it’s interesting and I’m enjoying the various input and thoughts folks are bringing.
If you don’t know about it, check out https://wordnet.princeton.edu/
It’s a great starting point for any English word hierarchy.
I didn’t know about it, thank you for showing me this.
I don’t think Lemmy or Mastodon would be a good place to start necessarily. Don’t be discouraged, I just mean that I think this should be something separate, like a library, that other systems like Mastodon or Lemmy could then use. As a code library it could be maintained elsewhere and let these folks keep working on their projects.
However, the large architecture issue is that those tags must be added in secret - or dozens of queries would have to go off. Either:
- When someone comments #pug you also need to add on all possible permutations of pug so it’s queryable or
- When someone searches for #pug you need to do a much more complex query for all possible permuations of pug.
It would be possible to do a lookup table in sql for this, but again that requires maintenance and again every instance keeping track of their own set of known lookups. Anyone else have alternative architectures?
I don’t think Lemmy or Mastodon would be a good place to start necessarily. Don’t be discouraged, I just mean that I think this should be something separate, like a library,
True. I meant suggesting this idea for generally any website that uses tagging. Will update post to show this better.
As a code library it could be maintained elsewhere and let these folks keep working on their projects.
We would need a group like the Wiki Foundation to set this up. Though I wouldn’t know how to pitch this.
All I can say is this:
And all I can say is this:
I like the idea, but I have no idea how to help.
😔
The GitHub.
https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/2675 https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/3906 https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/3446 https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/317
I also want flairs: https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/issues/1456
I’m sure there’s plenty more.
I don’t have an actual answer to your question, but imma use the opportunity to let my age show.
Seeing as we’re not on instagram or twitter, and seeing as this space is somewhat more techy than the average platform, could we please do tagging without precomiler instructions (or perl inline comments if that’s more your thing)?
“#” deserves better than being referred to as “the hash tag sign”.
This place is more techy, but please don’t assume. I have no idea what you’re arguing for.
How does my point relate to HTML tag metadata?
