Hi, there have been some controversy on lemmy and in particular lemmy.ml with regards to affiliation with Putin.

I was wondering what were the point of view of the owner of Lemmy.world on the topic.

  • RuudMA
    link
    English
    1022 years ago

    My political views are not important, we just have a set of rules and as long as you follow these any decent polite discussion would be possible.

    I’m also not going to ban [email protected] just because I support a different team…

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      162 years ago

      A very respectable stance that I believe will let communities flourish. Not just your community.

    • @DiligentCod
      link
      English
      72 years ago

      I think no one would blame you or complain if you ban Ajax

    • BombOmOm
      link
      English
      62 years ago

      My political views are not important, we just have a set of rules and as long as you follow these any decent polite discussion would be possible.

      Thank you! This is by far the best approach.

    • @mikehunt
      link
      English
      62 years ago

      Thank you for being awesome.

    • @ChaosAD
      link
      English
      32 years ago

      You are super awesome!!!

    • @bostondrivingisworse
      link
      English
      -1
      edit-2
      2 years ago

      …isn’t there a point at which it’s not just ‘politics’, though? Like mass killing of civilians and genocide?

      Like… C’mon. This should be an easy one.

      Edit: haha, Taiwan numbah one! Fuck Putin!

      • @brain_in_a_box
        link
        English
        -52 years ago

        What politics do you hold that has never in history been associated with atrocities by its opponents.

        • @bostondrivingisworse
          link
          English
          122 years ago

          I’m not talking about history, though. I’m talking about now. These atrocities are happening now.

          The fact that you tacitly admit this, but dismiss it with “well, everyone has some skeletons in their closet” is disturbing. You should rethink your priorities.

      • @nivenkos
        link
        English
        102 years ago

        Does it accomplish much? The same users can just create accounts on lemmy.ml or here.

        The brigading is an issue, but defederating doesn’t seem like a huge help right now.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          112 years ago

          Doesn’t defederating mean posts won’t show up? That seems like probably the main reason to defederate. You’ll never stop people from creating new accounts or a new instance, but defederating creates friction forcing people to take an alternative route if they want to troll.

          Regarding lemmygrad, has there been any trolling via alt accounts on instances that have defederated? Even if I disagree with their politics they seem generally respectful of the communities. But I’ve been away from Lemmy for a while so maybe I’ve missed something.

        • @certain_people
          link
          English
          62 years ago

          Oxygen of publicity spreads toxicity. Defederation would take away a huge part of their potential to reach people, if they’re being toxic.

        • @FantasticFox
          link
          English
          32 years ago

          It makes it harder. I doubt most people are that determined.

        • cura
          link
          English
          22 years ago

          Genuine question: What do you think will help lemmy.world for that matter?

    • @lhx
      link
      English
      -82 years ago

      Well, I’d say they’re more important than you’re letting on. Hypothetically speaking (and not lobbing accusations), if you for example supported the modern Nazi movement, that would be something your users should know.

      Might be nice to hear you’re not pro-Putin though without specifics.

  • @nivenkos
    link
    English
    152 years ago

    Do you have any evidence or sources for the supposed affiliation to Putin?

    The code is under the AGPL anyway, and it isn’t our instance, so it doesn’t matter what the developers nor the admins of lemmy.ml do.

    Keep politics in political subs.

  • @StarManta
    link
    English
    132 years ago

    What is the story with their affiliation with Putin? I haven’t heard about that

    • RuudMA
      link
      English
      282 years ago

      I think .ml was a popular cheap domain back when they started

    • @Gerryflap
      link
      English
      152 years ago

      I think the problem is moreso (as far as I’ve heard) that the owners of the lemmy.ml instance overlap with the owners of lemmygrad, which is basically the table/authoritarian commie instance. There have been some rumours about posts and comments being deleted for being critical of China/Russia. How much of that is true, I don’t know,l. What I have noticed is that there is a higher percentage of tankies on Lemmy, but they’re still usually down voted when they say dumb stuff.

      • @MercuryUprising
        link
        English
        12 years ago

        Until China wakes up and then the communist in name only posters go off the rails downvoting criticism of modern russia or China, two countries that are the antithesis of what communism espoused.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        252 years ago

        It can be interpreted as Marxism-Leninism, which I’m pretty sure both Lemmy and Lemmygrad have stated is the intention.

        Also they were dirt cheap/free when the first Lemmy instances were launched. 😁

    • @Railing5132
      link
      English
      32 years ago

      I think it’s the Maldives…

  • @Blissingg
    link
    English
    72 years ago

    Sadly the top two Lemmy instances don’t seem like great places. .ML is tankies and beehaw just have a look at how many instances they have blocked already. Seen this by a mod of theirs too which just screams insecure and proving the posters concerns right.

    • @Clbull
      link
      English
      4
      edit-2
      2 years ago

      Calling lemmy.ml a bunch of tankies because they don’t agree with a shaky far-right argument often used to attack the LGBTQ movement at large and don’t want it on their instance is quite disingenuous. Lemmygrad is the tankie community, as it is literally the pro-Socialist instance on Lemmy.

      It goes to show just how polarized online politics has become. You’re either a Nazi according to the left if you don’t fully agree with their views, or a Commie according to the right if you believe in anything like public healthcare or taxes.

      • @Blissingg
        link
        English
        2
        edit-2
        2 years ago

        Are you ok? Or just so riled up your reading comprehension has went in the bin? The photo is of beehaw, I thought that was pretty clear as they were the last instance I talked about before saying and I seen there mod respond with this before posting the image.

        Check the profile out of lemmy.ml admin it’s very obvious it’s ran by tankies that have been forced to be more accommodating after their server got popular or they’d hurt its growth.

        Edit: Also hilarious how you call it a shaky far-right argument and want to act like its never happened. I’ve seen it personally before, hell I’ve seen it from CIS people too.

        Can’t wait to get called anti-lgbtq and a far-right Nazi from you even though its as far from the truth as you could get about my political and social leanings.

        • @Clbull
          link
          English
          32 years ago

          Beehaw is more like a Tildes alternative than a Reddit alternative to me. Not gonna lie, Deimos would have probably yeeted this guy off of Tildes for a comment like that…

  • @StarManta
    link
    English
    42 years ago

    What is the story with their affiliation with Putin? I haven’t heard about that