Here’s the link to their recipe.

Now normally Serious Eats is pretty bang on with their recipes, but this one has a CRAZY amount of sugar in it. I made it as directed (but using store bought puff pastry) for Mother’s Day, and it was tasty but so sweet it could have been served for dessert.

This is the second time I made it, but with half the sugar. However sweet is still the dominant note, even after adding Worcestershire sauce, tart goat cheese, and more herbs. If you want to make this, seriously try using just a quarter of the sugar they ask for, and you might get something more savory.

[Image description: a circular tart made of layers of deeply caramelized cabbage in a sticky glaze. A bit of golden crust can be seen on the edges, and the tart is sitting on a wooden cutting board on a stove top.]

  • @JASN_DE
    link
    136 months ago

    and it was tasty but so sweet it could have been served for dessert.

    To be fair, the whole point of a Tarte Tatin is to caramelize whatever you put on there. I’d imagine it’ll be quite hard to find a good combination that’s not sweet and still caramelizes properly.

    • thrawnOP
      link
      36 months ago

      That’s true, it’s just that they use savory as a descriptor, when I found the end result to be more dessert than main.

      They’ve got a version that uses onions and much less sugar, so maybe I’ll try a mix of onions and cabbage to get that caramelization. Or just apply the sugar as a glaze on the bottom before the bake, so that it’s a layer of sweetness, and not sweet throughout.

  • BubbleMonkey
    link
    fedilink
    36 months ago

    This definitely does not look like something that would, or should, be sweet.

    All the same I’m kinda intrigued.