• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    446 months ago

    If he only said “I cleaned my shoes”, they could be dirty again. Now you know the difference between present perfect and simple past. English grammar, it’s weird (but every language’s is, to be fair).

    • @stoicmaverick
      link
      56 months ago

      Don’t even get me started on whoever decided that through, trough, and though, don’t rhyme, but pony and Bologna do. I bet he was a colonel who kept a journal… Asshole…

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        116 months ago

        To be pedantic that’s not grammar but orthography (which in English is even weirder). English is just a mutant amalgamation of Germanic, Romance and Celtic languages and man, it shows.

        • @samus12345
          link
          English
          3
          edit-2
          6 months ago

          There’s very little Celtic in modern English. Old Germanic, Latin, and French (which is derived from Latin) are the biggest contributors.

        • @puppy
          link
          26 months ago

          Don’t forget French.

          • @Soup
            link
            36 months ago

            French is technically a romance language but it is very different from the others.

          • @stoicmaverick
            link
            06 months ago

            What’s up with the +1 heart on this comment?

            • @puppy
              link
              16 months ago

              Are you on Jerboa by any chance?

              • @stoicmaverick
                link
                16 months ago

                Yeah. I’ve since figured it out. It’s just the net up verse down vote count. Actually somewhat useful for quick glancing.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1
          edit-2
          6 months ago

          Mashing together all the languages into a Frankenstein form of communication is English grammar. It has nothing to do with birds!

          • @stoicmaverick
            link
            26 months ago

            Except for the reason why we have different words for ‘chicken’ while it’s alive, and ‘poultry’ after it’s been slaughtered.

    • @stoicmaverick
      link
      26 months ago

      You’re clearly a bit of a fellow word nerd. Do you have any feelings about the fact that none of that matters anymore if we all just agree that it doesn’t, which one could have an easy time arguing that we have? Sometimes, after spending a rousing five minutes explaining the MOST correct pluralization of ‘octopus’, the only answer I can give to the inevitable question of “why does it matter?” Is “it doesn’t”.

      • @Cort
        link
        36 months ago

        If you were trying to describe a mess of cables how would you use octopus in an adjective form?

        • @stoicmaverick
          link
          46 months ago

          Thank you for your question.

          Option 1: “I’m not fixing your computer until you sort out the octopus bullshit going on behind your desk”

          Option 2: “The cable adapter you’re looking for is probably in this box, but it’s pretty octopussy in there.” Then hold firm, direct eye contact with a serious face until they respond.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        16 months ago

        I don’t know if it “matters”, and I’m not a prescriptivist who wants to tell others how to talk, but it’s interesting.

  • @stoicmaverick
    link
    106 months ago

    Not necessarily true. I just cleaned my bedroom, and it’s still fucked up.

  • @saltesc
    link
    76 months ago

    I’ve cleaned my shoes ≠ His shoes are clean now.

    The only thing linking the two statements are lines drawn from the shows, not language.

    But with arms that short and legs so long, I get his expression of great accomplishment.