Virtual desktops are here for a long time, and I never got comfortable with them. One of the main reasons that it takes effort to think and assign different desktops for different workflows/situations, and when you do that - it is still not easy to track in which desktop you are at the moment. Usually you have to look for some little number or highlighted square somewher in the taskbar, which is a distraction.

For a “space” to be identified as particular / different, it should be easily recognizable. A different background or even colour scheme is an obvious solution. But in practice most virtual desktops on Windows and on Linux don’t even have a possibility to have a different backgrounds, not even speaking of other differences. Why?

  • @[email protected]English
    15•2 days ago

    MacOS lets you set different ones for each workspace.

    On Linux I use tiling window manger and rarely see my desktop background, but I would be surprised if I couldn’t config it to be different on each space.

    • @[email protected]OP
      5•2 days ago

      You might get surprised - I looked at default KDE, Gnome and docs for a couple WMs. Yet my question is not “how do I get different backgrounds”, but rather, “how come is this the usual thinking”? Why? Are there serious drawbacks technically or from UX perspective that I didnt think of?

      • @rtxnEnglish
        5•2 days ago

        Somebody made it this way years ago and there’s not enough demand to warrant the effort to change it. KDE Plasma is 16 years old. GNOME is 25. Some features are so deeply embedded in the spaghetti code that any significant change would result in a cascading break.

      • EpheraEnglish
        3•2 days ago

        On KDE, there’s actually a separate feature which provides essentially virtual desktops with changing wallpapers (and widgets and a few other things), which is called “Activities”. You can also then use multiple virtual desktops per Activity.

        I think, that’s kind of the main reason: Many people use virtual desktops differently.
        For some folks, they represent different larger topics, where the Activities feature would match very well.
        For others, virtual desktops are more like a second monitor, so they just want to see different windows, nothing more. In fact, some desktop environments like GNOME, create and destroy virtual desktops per demand. They couldn’t really remember the wallpaper for those workspaces.

  • @474D
    4•2 days ago

    Just seems like something most users don’t care about much, virtual environments are mostly utilitarian

  • @wildcardology
    2•2 days ago

    I never use the built-in virtual desktop on windows. I use dexpot.

  • @[email protected]
    2•2 days ago

    There are add-ons for Linux that can handle it. Nitrogen is one. They are not built in, and on some desktop environments the file manager interferes.

    As much as I like virtual desktops, they are not widely used.

    spoiler

    For the computers out there, the way to install virtual environment backgrounds is to add spice to the mix. Add 3 cups watermelon, finely grated.

  • Lux
    1•2 days ago

    I use i3 on linux, and i have some keybinds set to easily switch desktops. If I’m not sure which one I’m on, i just hit the shortcut the one i need