I.
Hate.
Country.
Music.
Or at least that’s something I’d’ve said, say, maybe 5 or 6 years ago. And it was true! I hadn’t heard a single song I could identify as “country” that I could stand, let alone “like”.
But it all started with Lil’ Nas X and “Old Town Road”. I think the first time I heard it, I dismissed it without really “getting” it. But when I started hearing and liking other things by Lil’ Nas X, and when one of my favorite YouTube content creators said good things about “Old Town Road” on a stream, I listened again. More out of curiosity than anything. But with more context, I understood “Old Town Road” better. And, dare I say, liked it.
“It’s ironic country music”, I told myself. “It’s ok for me to like that. It’s got the affectations of country music, but it’s not country music in its bones. It’s actually pop if you really think about it.”
I.
Hate.
Country.
Music.
(Except “Old Town Road” because it’s only “ironically” country.)
See? It’s so simple. The world still made sense. And I could listen to it and like it, and admit to myself that I liked it.
And then came Jelly Roll.
It was New Year’s Eve (I don’t remember what year it was), and I was watching New Year’s Rockin’ Eve as I do every year (and plan to this year). And on comes a country artist. I groaned and reached for the mute button. But my friend wanted to hear it. So…
He sang “Need A Favor.” And, it was… good. I liked it.
Try as I might, I couldn’t think of an excuse why I was allowed to like it. And I didn’t listen to anything else by him for a good while, gut when I did, I liked it too.
I.
Hate.
Country.
Music.
(Except that one song by Nas X. And I guess I like that one song by Jelly Roll. But that’s it.)
And I did listen to a little more Jelly Roll and it was surprisingly enjoyable as well. And I still hadn’t resolved the cognitive dissonance when…
Bam! The most recent episode of SNL came on. And the musical guest was Shaboozey.
And since then I have not been able to stop listening to “A Bar Song (Tipsy)” practically on repeat.
And it was a few days before I let the intrusive thoughtsYouTube algorithm win and play me another Shaboozey song. It was “Highway.” And holy shit, it was… if anything better than “Tipsy”.
And I’ve listened to a bunch of Shaboozey since, and his stuff ranges from “actually really good” to “I can’t stop playing it.”
I…
guess I…
kinda… maybe…
like…
country music…
actually?
It’s really surreal. But it’s clearly impossible to continue to believe that “I don’t like country music”.
The jury’s still out on Post Malone’s “I Had Some Help” featuring Morgan Wallen. But honestly, I’m listening to it as I write this to try to form a more solid opinion on it and I can feel it growing on me a bit.
I’m not sure whether I’m changing or country music is. This is all still very new to me.
Maybe I’ve just been racist against country music until I started seeing some less “traditional” country musicians. A part of me is worried the country music I’ve been enjoying lately is going to end up being a gateway drug to the harder stuff like Kenny Chesney’s “She Thinks My Tractor’s Sexy” and Toby Keith’s “As Good As I Once Was”. But doing research for this Lemmy post, I just listened to a (small) part of each of those two, and I can report I’m at no risk of developing a habit of either of those.
…for now.
I’m no expert but you might like hick-hop and not country music. Again, no expert here but I grew up being forced to listen to country and it wasn’t these guys. I’ll understand if my opinion isn’t accepted, do what you will.
Maybe check out Orville Peck. A good country artist for non country lovers like me.
I like country music when I’m doing home canning because it feels like it fits the project. Otherwise I’m ambivalent towards it. Mother use to play it quite a bit, so it’s whatever she’d listen to in the 90s/00s.
It seems you’re liking a lot of songs that are fusions of modern pop and country music. I don’t have anything else to recommend in this vein, but this year I’ve gotten into some country fusion groups that blend genres you wouldn’t expect. You might check these out:
Charley Crockett - Country underpinned by blues, jazz, and funk. I highly recommend the album In The Night.
Rattlesnake Milk - country music meets surf rock.
Paul Cauthen - country music meets gospel, funk, and at times electronic. I’ve really enjoyed his recent album Black on Black and I’d recommend the title track or “Hot Damn” but don’t miss out on older songs like “Cocaine Country Dancing” and “Holy Ghost Fire”
My son really likes Charlie Crockett. Also Colter Wall.
How do you feel about Orville Peck?
I haven’t really listened to Orville Peck much. I heard about him a few years ago, but I recall getting too much Roy Orbison vibes for my taste. I really respect his commitment to the style though. I’m going to put him on today and give it another go.
We saw him in concert couple of months ago and he does a really fun show!! There’s a lot of alt country out there that’s pretty good, but you have to turn off the radio and look for it.
People shit on country, but there’s good stuff there. A lot of good stuff, and if you avoid the usual country radio side of things, it gets even better.
Jelly Roll is for sure a damn fine gateway into it. He’s hip-hop informed country, with some soul and r&b in there. Which, there’s a lot of interaction between those genres that isn’t obvious, but that’s tangential. But, yeah, Jelly is the current forefront of a new take on country that leans more towards “outlaw” country than Nashville formula.
Willie, Johnny Cash, Kris Kristofferson, that’s what I think of as the holy trinity of outlaw country. Yeah, Waylon is there, but he isn’t quite as accessible to non country fans.
Orville Peck. He’s doing fairly traditional country style, but with a modern outlook. Right now, he’s as good a gateway to country as Jelly is, imo. And you’ve got direct hip-hop-county fusion out there called hick-hop, as well as stuff like gangstagrass that leans more hip-hop than country.
But even within the standard Nashville cookie cutter stuff, there’s gold to find, once you know what you really like.
You can also edge out into bluegrass and folk-country and find some incredible music that defies genres in terms of the songwriting.
You said you aren’t sure if it’s country changing, or you. It’s both. Country has opened up huge the last decade, with a lot of non traditional stuff being successful (check out The Dead South as a great example). When someone realizes that a genre contains things they do like, when their previous exposure was not enjoyable, it opens up the mind to explore more, so they’ll find the stuff that isn’t on the radio and discover that the genre (any genre) is more than what is easy to find.
And we all change over time. Twenty years ago, I wasn’t in the same place as I am now, so songs I didn’t like then hit different now.
Fwiw, the last two songs you mentioned are dead perfect examples of Nashville cookie cutter radio trash. Ngl though, as good as I once was hits a lot better for me as I age, and it is catchy as hell. Toby Keith low key sucks though.
But don’t worry about it. Maybe you’ll hear more that you like, maybe you don’t. But it’s always a fun ride to explore something you didn’t like before. I recently found some jazz that works for me, and I had spent decades actively disliking most of what I heard. Turns out I just don’t like horns in my jazz. So, now I’m exploring stuff that isn’t horn heavy, or lacks it entirely, and it turns out I like jazz.
I am also a hater of country music but I cant hate on the Highwaymen. Also I like Lucas Nelson, Jesse Welles, and Chris Night but thats about as country as I’ll get
Old Town Road by Lil Nas X is not country music. There’s not a single acoustic guitar in there at all.
There’s banjo though
Give Dixon Dallas a listen.