Ridley Scott explained how studios didn’t realize ‘The Martian’ was a comedy.

  • Rob Bos
    link
    fedilink
    English
    511 month ago

    The book was a comedy as well. Tons of great dry jokes. The two are not mutually exclusive.

    • Jerkface (any/all)
      link
      fedilink
      English
      12
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      There’s a chasm between being funny and being a comedy. Comedy is a genre, and I’d argue doesn’t strictly even need to be very funny, if at all.

      • Bobby Turkalino
        link
        fedilink
        English
        61 month ago

        Yeah the old timey definition of a comedy is a story that starts sad but gets better, while a drama is the opposite

        • @BeMoreCareful
          link
          English
          21 month ago

          I thought one ended in a marriage and the other a death.

        • @jordanlund
          link
          English
          130 days ago

          Or the Shakespearian definition:

          Comedies end in a wedding.
          Tragedies end in a funeral.

  • MrScottyTay
    link
    fedilink
    English
    39
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    How did no one realise this? Like half the movie at least is black humour

    • @dustyData
      link
      English
      13
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      [Insert standard explanation about the worldwide decline in media literacy here]

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      31 month ago

      100% of the movie is about being stranded a la castaway. Does turning your volleyball into a friend make that a comedy or is it sad?

          • @jordanlund
            link
            English
            230 days ago

            Bruce Campbell too! There used to be film festivals here called “Bruce Abuse!”

  • @jordanlund
    link
    English
    351 month ago

    “Mark Watney: Space Pirate”

    • @ilinamorato
      link
      English
      51 month ago

      The reasoning he went through on that was hilarious. It’s definitely something that a person stuck on Mars would think about.

  • Sumocat
    link
    English
    251 month ago

    It’s a farce: “a light dramatic composition marked by broadly satirical comedy and improbable plot”. It’s played straight. The stakes are serious. It should be a tragedy. But then there’s a literal turning point when they turn around to rescue Watney, and it’s ridiculous.

    • @cynar
      link
      English
      330 days ago

      The book makes it make a lot more sense. He actually reasons through what he is doing, and why. The line “I’m going g to science the shit out of it” is practically the mantra, and demonstrated again and again.

      The film basically takes this and strips out all the ‘boring science’ stuff. What’s left, while still a good film, is a shadow of the source material.

      • TheRealKuni
        link
        English
        330 days ago

        I’m hopeful they’ll do Project Hail Mary justice.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    13
    edit-2
    1 month ago

    Maybe it was behind-the-scenes commentary? I recall that one of the goals from the author was that they keep the “positive” outlook. Like, there are plenty of stories of people losing their minds after being stranded.

    This would be different.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    101 month ago

    This is my favorite book and favorite movie. So I really must wonder, did they read the script? Mark literally makes dirty ASCII art that is broadcast across the earth.

    • @Fredselfish
      link
      English
      101 month ago

      Screw watching the movie. Read the book or better listen to the audiobook its freaking awesome! I own both but end up listening to the audio version rather then reread the book.

      • @Lemming421
        link
        English
        51 month ago

        The film is great as its own thing, but the book is excellent and Wil Wheaton’s narration is perfection.

        • @nieminen
          link
          English
          31 month ago

          He does a great job with ready player one as well

        • Drusas
          link
          fedilink
          21 month ago

          Huh, it had a different narrator when I listened to it. Some guy I had never heard of. He was good, though.

  • Jo Miran
    link
    fedilink
    English
    -71 month ago

    The book is hard sci-fi and excellent.

    The movie is dumb shit and screwy. The only way this change of tone and content is justified is by realizing that they switched genres and turned it into a movie.

      • Jo Miran
        link
        fedilink
        English
        01 month ago

        Yes but it never breaks the science in the name of comedy. Using the other astronauts’ poop to fertilize went against the book just so he could make an extra joke. The Ironman scene was also ridiculous and unnecessary.

        The movie didn’t need to dumb down for a few extra gags.

        • @I_Has_A_Hat
          link
          English
          171 month ago

          In the book he uses his own poop. Not a huge change really.

          • Jo Miran
            link
            fedilink
            English
            41 month ago

            It is a very big change because of the reason he only uses his own poop and not the poop of the other astronauts. They broke away from the hard science in order to insert a joke.

            • @nieminen
              link
              English
              21 month ago

              I have to agree with both of your points. The poop thing and the iron man thing were my only two real issues with the movie though.

              Obviously a ton of the book’s content is removed to make it fit in a single movie, but I think they did a great job, especially when compared to other adaptations.

              • Jo Miran
                link
                fedilink
                English
                31 month ago

                I like the movie, and I am agreeing with Ridley Scott. It was clearly a comedy. The book had humor in it, but it was science first. I saw it as a thought experiment on what it would take for someone to survive in Mars. The movie’s tone was more of adventure comedy, and there is nothing wrong with that.

                Donald Glover was fantastic.