• balderdash
    link
    fedilink
    -384 months ago

    The mods won’t remove this because it agrees with “THE MESSAGE” but this is arguably not a meme.

      • balderdash
        link
        fedilink
        -134 months ago

        idk, but I just got a meme deleted by a mod because it was “a rant described as a meme”. (It was in the Pepperidge Farm format). The rules here are inconsistent but what else is new

        • mad_asshatter
          link
          124 months ago

          Thanks for the lack of details along with the faraway cage over your lead box, so we could empathize!

      • 𝔼𝕩𝕦𝕤𝕚𝕒
        link
        -14
        edit-2
        4 months ago

        Memes generally have text, or use an exploitable (think like a funny face or advice animals where you see a thousand of the same pic, but different text or “white bar” memes. They can be edited quickly or have a reactionary image allowing them to match context to several situations, like a reaction.

        Shitposts generally feature no text, and are a self contained image/joke. Shitposts tend to follow a Theme of the image itself and thus follow an in-joke rather than reactions to common conversation. They do not require context usually. Shitposts often do not require prior knowledge of something like memes do. Shitposts are often the subject of the “brainrot” criticism due to the ability to just appear as a nonsensical image to someone unaware of the in-joke.

        Memes can be shitposts, or can be OF shitposts, especially when they require knowledge of another meme or shitpost (a tier 2 or 3 meme) and there’s a bit of crossover when you come to things like this.

        This image is probably shitpost, not a meme, by these standards. However I’m just a random poster of stuff on the internet, not an authority to dictate what others post. FWIW if it’s funny and there’s not a Sublemmy for both, it’s probably fine here.

        • Flying Squid
          link
          34 months ago

          Imagine if none of that mattered and we didn’t have to categorize things that are funny!

          • 𝔼𝕩𝕦𝕤𝕚𝕒
            link
            14 months ago

            I mean I said it really doesn’t matter and is subjective. The difference is pedantic for the average person- but I would say there is one because we don’t call them all just one or the other. Especially when it comes to deciding to post an image in either memes.world or shitposting.ml.

    • @TrickDacy
      link
      24 months ago

      Lol out of all the non memes posted this is the one you choose to get upset about