• TheTechnician27
    link
    English
    5
    edit-2
    2 months ago

    How would the Death Star hit the cube in the first place though? It can travel faster than light, whereas the Death Star is meant for stationary or nearly stationary targets and has a long recharge time. Everything else – the fighters and the turrets – the cube would adapt to immediately. The Death Star 2 is shown to have a shield around it projected from Endor, but the first Death Star is never shown to have such a shield. So unless the cube gets in firing range of the main cannon, it just adapts immediately to everything and starts neutering the station’s defenses before beginning the assimilation.

    • Flying SquidM
      link
      62 months ago

      Doesn’t even need to go faster than light. It takes over 10 seconds to fire the Death Star’s laser based on this footage:

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7g77WN6obk4

      You could probably get out of the way if you were traveling at 20th century Earth probe speeds.

      • TheTechnician27
        link
        English
        32 months ago

        I’m not sure that last part’s true. The Death Star’s beam is pretty wide, and it manages to track a planet, which if we take Earth’s travel around the Sun as an example could be moving around 30 km/s. Voyager 1, by contrast, travels around 17 km/s. The main thing it would depend on is your distance from the Death Star. The laser seems to be able to travel a very long distance, and so if you’re far enough away, that only requires a very small angular correction by the station, although they’d have to lead the shot more and would give the ship more chances to make unpredictable maneuvers after they’ve already fired. Collimation means that the beam would stay at basically the same width when it reaches you as it was at the station, so I don’t think that would be a factor. If you’re really close, though, then yeah, even just lazily moving out of the way is probably enough. I don’t think it’s ever quite explained how the Death Star tracks Alderaan, but based on the fact that the laser is facing like 150 degrees away from the planet as Princess Leia is brought in for interrogation, I think it can be surmised that it can orbit itself about its own axis pretty quickly.

    • Cyborganism
      link
      fedilink
      42 months ago

      I agree with every argument except one. I don’t see how the Borg’s ships speed changes anything. The starships and starfighters in Star Wars also travel at warp speeds.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        12 months ago

        I’m not sure what the original commenter was thinking, but they have assimilated the Picard Manoeuvre and they could trivially kite the death star with it.

      • @Ziglin
        link
        12 months ago

        The Borg could dodge the beam… It is shown as being relatively slow to power up (and move, though one would assume that it moves at light speed).