Built on unearned hype.

  • Madrigal
    link
    English
    253 hours ago

    Those corporations are about to find out the fun way that these algorithms, in their current and near-future states, cannot replace human beings.

    Well, except for maybe lazy copywriters who pump out pointless listicles and executives who do - whatever it is they do - but any non-trivial task requiring creativity and understanding is beyond these tools.

    • @stoly
      link
      English
      91 hour ago

      You’re assuming that they care about running a viable service or product.

    • FaceDeer
      link
      fedilink
      82 hours ago
      • Computers might be good at numbers and typesetting, but we’ll always need human secretaries and phone operators to keep things running.
      • They might be able to beat a novice, but no computer will ever beat a human grandmaster at chess.
      • Okay, then they can’t beat humans at Go or poker.
      • Any non-trivial task requiring creativity and understanding is beyond these tools. ← you are here
      • AI-run corporations will never be able to outcompete ones with ones with human boards and CEOs.
      • An AI scriptwriter could never win an Oscar.
      • I’m voting for the human candidate for president, I don’t think the AI one is up to the task.
      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        101 hour ago

        “When I was young, they told me that one day, AI would do the menial labor so that we would have more time to do what we love - like art, music, and poetry. Today, the AI does art, music, and poetry so that I can work longer hours at my menial labor job for lower wages.”

        Also, on point one, I still see a lot of job hirings for personal secretaries and people for data entry and to take minutes at meetings, and plenty of people complaining about not being able to actually talk to somebody on the phone to get their problem solved.

        • @linearchaos
          link
          English
          254 minutes ago

          Be glad we’re not the horses. The glue factory might be coming next.

          • Madrigal
            link
            English
            333 minutes ago

            Not the best analogy. The glue factory was a thing while horses were a primary tool for transport and heavy labour. And horses were treated appallingly. Now that they’ve been made redundant, living standards for horses have improved dramatically and the glue factory is long gone (though their population has also reduced significantly).

            We can only hope for a similar outcome for ourselves.

            • @linearchaos
              link
              English
              124 minutes ago

              Before the car there were three to four people per horse

              There are currently about 140 people per horse.

              So if you want to cheer on taking the world population from 8.6 billion to about 188 million, treating us better, I can’t say I’m a big fan.

              • Madrigal
                link
                English
                122 minutes ago

                When did I say that?

                • @linearchaos
                  link
                  English
                  017 minutes ago

                  You hope for a similar outcome for ourselves.

                  The outcome for the horses is less than ideal. The population was reduced by 33x. Sure they’re treated better now as their leisure animals or sport animals. But I do not wish for their outcome on humanity.

                  • Madrigal
                    link
                    English
                    114 minutes ago

                    Go and look up the meaning of “though”, and parentheses.

                    I was referring to quality of living.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            232 minutes ago

            I’m well aware of switchboard operators. Computers were originally a profession as well.

            Secretaries are still all that, both using digital tools as well as physical. They weren’t replaced by any of those programs. They just changed how they do their job. They schedule your meetings for you now in their cell phone instead of on a desk-sized paper calendar mat.

      • @weastie
        link
        English
        1
        edit-2
        32 minutes ago

        deleted by creator

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1
          edit-2
          30 minutes ago

          Nah that’s what they’re saying. That people used to say that and they were proved wrong.

      • Madrigal
        link
        English
        72 hours ago

        Good one. Did you use an LLM to generate it?

        • FaceDeer
          link
          fedilink
          048 minutes ago

          Too good for a human to have written so it must have been AI? I guess I’ll take it as a compliment that I’m writing at that level.

      • @TropicalDingdong
        link
        English
        32 hours ago

        I’m voting for the human candidate for president, I don’t think the AI one is up to the task.

        Don’t blame me, I voted for Kodos_bot