Germany is struggling to get people on-board with a green energy movement that involves banning high footprint domestic heating systems (e.g. gas boilers)-- thus forcing people to migrate to heat pumps. A low-income family who was interviewed said it would cost €45k to install a heat pump in their terraced home in Bremen.

That price tag sounds unreal. I am baffled. What’s going on here? I guess I would assume an old terraced German home would likely have wall radiators that circulate hot water. Is the problem that a heat pump can’t generate enough heat to bring water to ~60°C, which would then force them to add a forced-air ducting infrastructure? Any guesses?

(note the link goes to a BBC program that looks unrelated, but at the end of the show they switch to this issue in Germany. I’m not sure if that show is accessible… I see no download link but that could be a browser issue)

  • MuchPineapples
    link
    36 months ago

    If you have a cavity, which a house from the 1920s probably doesn’t have.

    • @Squizzy
      link
      36 months ago

      He specifically stated he had a cavity. If you don’t you can do external cladding insulation and internal insulation.

    • Hyperreality
      link
      fedilink
      3
      edit-2
      6 months ago

      They sometimes do, but some of these older brick houses use lime mortar which is far more breathable. Allows moisture in and out. Some older houses are also not that water tight anyway or often have moisture issues.

      If you use the wrong foam, it absorbs that moisture. Bad. Think mouldy sponge. If you use the right foam, but don’t ensure ventilation and tackle moisture issues? Still bad. If you don’t mix the foam right or use too much? Possible structural damage. Or the foam’s flammable which is an issue in an old house with old electrics.

      The person you’re responding to mentions people doing it themselves with an expanding foam gun, which as someone who worked in the industry gives me the shivers tbh. I mean, maybe they’ll get lucky, but I wouldn’t buy that house. If they used the wrong foam or did it wrong, it’s not as if you’re going to be able to remove it or start over. It’s there forever now.