• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    12311 months ago

    If you ditch the orgasm bit it’s kinda like sharks? Like it’d just be edgy instead of some weird vore-fetish thing

      • @FrozenCorgi
        link
        2211 months ago

        Tried looking that up but can’t really find anything, what is the controversy there?

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          4711 months ago

          I guess you do need some background information, especially because Wizards sure doesn’t like spelling it out anymore.

          In older editions it was assumed nearly all half-orcs were the offspring of rape, and “the blessing of Luthic” was given to make orcs fertile with nearly every other race.

          The implications were clear, even more once you start diving into things like orcish society being a rigid patriarchy with a slave economy and one of Luthic’s domains being not just servitude, but specifically female servitude.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              7611 months ago

              In early DnD’s defense, monster races were objectively, comically evil, and players were pretty heavily incentivised to pick humans (and assumed to be played by extremely nerdy guys), so it wasn’t supposed to come up that much.

              The fantasy was in killing the cannibal rape monsters, freeing their slaves, and not having to ask yourself “Are we the baddies doing an imperialism?” for burning down the orc village.

              • Nerd02
                link
                fedilink
                English
                3911 months ago

                My dad used to play red box D&D (which I believe was the first edition ever released). Still has some manuals, which I got the chance to read.

                Not only it was encouraged to play humans, it was assumed! You didn’t get to pick a race, only a class. And while the classes of “elf” (think like 5e’s ranger) and “dwarf” (5e’s barbarian, sort of) were a thing, all of the other classes assumed for the player to be a human. You couldn’t play an elf wizard: you either are an elf OR a wizard. Wild stuff, compared to some of the crazy stuff we get to do in modern D&D.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  19 months ago

                  Late reply, but original D&D and Holmes-book D&D came before Red Box. Not sure about OD&D, but Holmes had race-class separation. AD&D has roughly contemporaneous with red box, and had the concept of Elf Wizard.

                  Red box D&D (both its editions) was pretty different in a lot of ways than other editions.

              • Neato
                link
                fedilink
                English
                1811 months ago

                Early DND sounds a lot like pulp comics.

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                1311 months ago

                you’re asking if horny people had the idea to give massive honkers to the small green people and make their whole schtick to bonk everyone they see?

                if that’s a question that needs to be asked you should treasure your innocence

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            411 months ago

            I can’t seem to find the reference, but I think an echo of this made it into 5e, where the offspring of orcs and other races were always half-orcs.

          • @Harbinger01173430
            link
            111 months ago

            So…can I get an orc lady for myself and make a half orc clan just for the giggles?

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        611 months ago

        Could not really find anything but that Luthic is a fertility goddess of sorts. Which seems rather normal.

  • @Sanctus
    link
    English
    5611 months ago

    Umm, what? Anything that has gestation similar to a human is probably incapable of this. Could you imagine these fucking alien beans duckin’ and dodgin’ in utero to slaughter each other with nubby hands and fingers? Lmao this is some Morrowind concept art shit

  • soli
    cake
    link
    fedilink
    54
    edit-2
    11 months ago

    My favourite bit on drow related lore is from 2E. Non-drow followers of Eilistraee would do black face and travel the world as part of an effort to show drow could be peaceful. There is something hilarious to me about how well intentioned the author seems to be but completely oblivious to what it looks like.

    • Taffer
      link
      fedilink
      English
      2311 months ago

      Oh so Señor Chang in the D&D episode of Community.

    • @Jiggle_Physics
      link
      4211 months ago

      No this was the lore.

      Hell one of 3.5 edition’s strongest monsters, from the the published books, was the undead, aborted, fetus, that was the product of the rape of another god, or celestial/hell/abyssal creature, by a god of opposing alignment, like an angel raped by an evil god.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        5411 months ago

        They were just keeping with the strong tradition established by the Greeks and Romans of gods that rape everyone and everything.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        23
        edit-2
        11 months ago

        Not really sure what the hubub is. It’s lore for a dark thing in a fantasy world. It’s like an unpopular opinion on c/unpopularopinion . You don’t like it, persay, but it’s effective content.

        • @Jiggle_Physics
          link
          011 months ago

          The issue is due to two primary factors.

          First the biology of humanoids in D&D precludes something like this, doubly so when elven gestation cycles is considered. The differences between drow and other elves is not huge. They have some minor physiological differences, and some minor magical bonuses. They would have to be completely different creatures for this aspect of pregnancy to work. They could have said something like their genetics are so competitive one ends up absorbing the others early in development, like vanishing twin syndrome, because the dominant one consumes all available nutrients killing the other embryos. However the explanation makes it clear they are physically killing each other. This, topped with the erotic element, is just bad world/lore building. Bad lore that only exists to be edgy, which is bad storytelling.

          The second big issue is that this is mainline D&D. Mainline D&D is not a grimdark setting. This isn’t Warhammer. D&D also has settings for this type of thing. To a lesser extent, places like Ravenloft, which can get pretty edgy, but this would be pushing it, even there. Others would be settings like Dark Sun, which is pretty much built for edgelord storytelling. Though the bad world building surrounding the discrepancies between drow and the rest of the elves would make for bad storytelling even in such a place. If you create a set of rules of nature, those rules can be whatever, but you need to not break those rules. Going through the basic lore of an otherwise typical high fantasy setting, people aren’t expecting to come across cartoonish edgelord shit like this.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            211 months ago

            I guess we disagree, and that’s fine.

            I believe any setting with undead has firmly entered the grim arena, even if not fully branded as such.

            Dnd is a rich world, imo a richer world but capturing wholesome, classical adventure, and grim concepts. The edge of grim can indeed be…edgy.

            It’s not for everyone, or every character to want to learn about, because it’s literally evil, and alignments.

            The world if fuller with good, and bad. (And edgy)

            • @Jiggle_Physics
              link
              011 months ago

              Which is fine, when it’s actually good world building. This particular thing, when you consider all the rules set forth for the biology of the creature, just shoots down that richer world for the sake of, murder fetus gets mom off.

      • Neato
        link
        fedilink
        English
        611 months ago

        Are you talking about Atropus? Or some other unborn God?

        • @Jiggle_Physics
          link
          711 months ago

          They are called atropals but are not kin to Atropus. Atropus is an actual god and is the size of a moon. Atropals are abominations and large size category, they also lack divine rank.

          • Neato
            link
            fedilink
            English
            711 months ago

            Oh wow. I knew about them but I guess the FR wiki excised all the gross lore.

            Atropals were a race of unfinished immortals modeled after the gods, stillborn godlings, who spontaneously rose as undead[3] abominations

            Maybe I won’t put those in my game. I was considering it because they seemed similar to Atropus, who is my ultimate big bad.