• Toes♀
    link
    fedilink
    English
    214 months ago

    I always thought her character was the weakest aspect of the show. Being able to sense their emotions from another starship was harder to accept than the introduction of Q.

    If her scope was limited to the room I wouldn’t have minded.

    • @ummthatguyOP
      link
      English
      374 months ago

      When she actually uses her powers beyond the trivial, it’s usually an episode where she gets mind raped. The writers are to blame here.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        184 months ago

        This might be my biggest TNG complaint. The character and the actor are good (or at least decent if we’re being picky), but almost every time the focus is on her, the writing is absolutely awful.

        • @Telodzrum
          link
          94 months ago

          Even the episode where she is forced to take command when the Enterprise was disabled managed to be more about how showing Laren is a callous asshole than that Deanna was capable of command decisions.

          • HobbitFoot
            link
            fedilink
            English
            64 months ago

            You needed Miles and Laren to play off each other and give Deanna options to consider.

            The episode also led to an interesting B plot in a future episode about Deanna becoming a commander.

      • HobbitFoot
        link
        fedilink
        English
        114 months ago

        I feel like she would have been better if she was a diplomat instead of a councilor. There are tons of episodes where having a diplomat on the bridge would have been very useful, even if she was just an attaché advising Picard.

        It would also give the show an excuse to keep her out of a uniform since she would likely be a civilian.

        • @ummthatguyOP
          link
          English
          64 months ago

          Which is primarily what the third seat is for. Often enough, Starfleet is entangled in a situation which calls for a foreign dignitary, mediator, or third party of some sort. The Enterprise simply “lucked out” on an empathic half-Betazoid. They really should be more thankful.

          • HobbitFoot
            link
            fedilink
            English
            54 months ago

            The Enterprise simply “lucked out” on an empathic half-Betazoid

            who is also the daughter of a fairly high ranking ambassador.

    • @essell
      link
      104 months ago

      I can sense someone else’s feelings over a zoom call, makes sense to me!

        • @essell
          link
          14 months ago

          I can do that too.

          As a therapist its not unusual to start picking up a client’s feelings a few hours before the session when you’re closely attuned to them.

    • @ummthatguyOP
      link
      English
      174 months ago

      They nailed the criticism with that bit.

  • @JimVanDeventer
    link
    134 months ago

    *Enterprise shakes violently

    *Booming disembodied voice yells “who dares enter my domain!”

    “Captain, I sense… a presence.”

  • @stupidcasey
    link
    114 months ago

    She always came across as a bit of a con man that got in over her head and can’t get out.

  • @VelvetStorm
    link
    44 months ago

    I would love to know the range of her powers. Imo she was the worst of the main character in tng.

  • @Hobbes_Dent
    link
    44 months ago

    TO INFINITY AND BEY…

    Oh ok, back out again.

    TO INFINITY AND…

    Oh, out again.

    TO INF…

    I see how this is.