The parallels between Musk and Stark seemed perfect on paper. Both are billionaire tech innovators with a flair for the dramatic and dreams of changing the world.

  • @T156
    link
    English
    18221 days ago

    The parallels between Musk and Stark seemed perfect on paper. Both are billionaire tech innovators with a flair for the dramatic and dreams of changing the world.

    They’re not, though. Stark is a rare engineering powerhouse who personally pushed past a lot of engineering boundaries, and Musk is an investor/programmer who mostly puts his name on existing things.

    I might change my mind if Musk personally invents AGI, nanobots, and a previously-unknown clean energy source capable of powering a 1/3rd of NYC with a room no larger than a foyer, like Stark did, but I’m not holding out much by way of hopes.

    • @Windex007
      link
      English
      17021 days ago

      Considering he asked twitter programmers to print out their pull requests Im not even sure he’s not cosplaying a programmer

      • @Dasus
        link
        English
        221 days ago

        Did he want them faxed to him?

      • @rottingleaf
        link
        English
        -521 days ago

        When he apparently was a programmer, this was a bit more normal.

        I’ve met a few professors requiring uni assignments’ code printed.

        • @Duamerthrax
          link
          English
          1321 days ago

          When he wrote code at PayPal, people kept having to go back and fix it. He doesn’t know what he’s doing.

          • @rottingleaf
            link
            English
            321 days ago

            OK. I just meant that one can demand that as a sign of respect or something. With a sufficient degree of narcissism.

        • @Furbag
          link
          English
          621 days ago

          I imagine that a university level coding assignment and the backend code that runs the Twitter.com website (albeit just fractions of it) are several orders of magnitude apart from each other in terms of size and complexity. I don’t know shit about programming though, I took C++ in high school and got a D+. Should’ve called the class Introduction to D++.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      121 days ago

      And yet

      Back in 2016, Iron Man director Jon Favreau revealed that Musk had been a direct inspiration for their version of Tony Stark. Downey Jr even spent time with Musk to better understand what it would be like to walk in the shoes of a real-world tech mogul.

        • paw
          link
          fedilink
          English
          121 days ago

          Out of interest, do you have any sources that what he does is not reliable? This is not some kind of I’m pissed off about your comnent, I’m actually not. Having said that, I see tgis as an opportunity to learn about Harris’ shortcomings. Thanks in advance.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    9521 days ago

    Hey vocal.media why not proofread your articles a little better? The first letter is a typo, never seen that before.

    Un an interview that’s got everyone talking, Robert Downey Jr has finally addressed the elephant in the room; those persistent comparisons between Elon Musk and the character Tony Stark.

  • @aeronmelon
    link
    English
    6421 days ago

    Elon Musk is a wannabe fanboy of Tony Stark, per Iron Man 2. It’s MCU canon.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      1621 days ago

      Yeah but Musk in the MCU got Thanos-snapped and the Avengers wisely left him out when they snapped everyone back

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      121 days ago

      From the article:

      Back in 2016, Iron Man director Jon Favreau revealed that Musk had been a direct inspiration for their version of Tony Stark. Downey Jr even spent time with Musk to better understand what it would be like to walk in the shoes of a real-world tech mogul.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    5321 days ago

    Elton never invented anything, he’s skated on other’s success. He’s more the evil partner from the first Iron Man using others’ inventions.

    • sp3ctr4l
      link
      fedilink
      English
      2521 days ago

      Now now, Elon does technically have one patent to his name personally.

      Its the shape of the charging port for Teslas.

      He patented this with the idea that if he ever did actually build out that massive EV charger network, he would basically be owed royalties if it successfully became the USB C of EV charging ports, so himself personally would be owned royalties if other car companies wanted to use that charging port shape.

      But that was like a decade ago, and last I heard he fired the entire team at Tesla dedicated to the charging network.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        1021 days ago

        Tesla’s NACS charging standard is now the charging standard for most car companies operating in the USA.

  • Echo Dot
    link
    fedilink
    English
    52
    edit-2
    21 days ago

    Stark actually was intelligent though. He really invented all the stuff he used, he earned the right to be a bit of an arse.

    • @Dasus
      link
      English
      2621 days ago

      Yeah.

      Elon bought the title of founder of Tesla. He’s not a fucking inventor, he’s a leech.

    • @thirteene
      link
      English
      119 days ago

      Spiderman far from home actually addressed this

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    3721 days ago

    When Stan Lee created Tony back in the 1960’s he probably took his inspiration from Howard Hughes.

    Hughes had been the inspiration for a famous novel of the time, “The Carpetbaggers.”

    HH was played by Leo DiCaprio in ‘The Aviator.’

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        421 days ago

        Could be.

        Off topic but fun.

        The book ‘The Carpetbaggers’ became a movie; there was a Western actor mentioned in the story, Nevada Smith. Does anyone else know a daring character named after a state with a five letter last name?

        https://youtu.be/Or-4aw41PkM

        • Jojo, Lady of the West
          link
          fedilink
          English
          15
          edit-2
          21 days ago

          I told you before, I’m not doing any more research for your crossword puzzles. If you want to keep making them that’s fine, but don’t put the work on us.

          /s just in case

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          221 days ago

          Does anyone else know a daring character named after a state with a five letter last name?

          That’s so reductive. The guy is MUCH MUCH MORE.

    • @Nuke_the_whales
      link
      English
      221 days ago

      If you watched agent Carter, Howard Stark is clearly just Hughes by a different name.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        121 days ago

        Doc Savage has entered the chat.

        Millionaire geniuses were a dime a dozen in the Pulp Era!

        [jk, of course you’re right]

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    3121 days ago

    Clicks link

    The very first word in the article is a glaringly obvious fucking typo. Why on earth would I want to read anything that website has to say?!?

  • @Okokimup
    link
    English
    2721 days ago

    Tony Stark created likeability with a box of scraps in a cave!

    • @Cocodapuf
      link
      English
      1021 days ago

      Well he’s not Tony Stark…

  • @masquenox
    link
    English
    26
    edit-2
    21 days ago

    Are people ready to admit that characters like Tony Stark and Bruce Wayne has always served to propagandize the idea of “genius millionaire/billlionaire” capitalists despite the fact that no such thing has ever existed in reality?

    And that this propaganda is partly the reason why parasitic fraudster racketeers like Musk, Gates and Bezos gets to get away with their gargantuan crimes against humanity?

    No?

    • @GreenKnight23
      link
      English
      2121 days ago

      are you ready to admit that fictional characters exist in fiction because it gives an escape to readers to fantasize about themselves as the hero?

      get over yourself bringing all that hatemongering in here.

      you think you offer a special perspective that none of us have that pertains to the widening of socioeconomic gaps between the rich and poor? yeah we get it, “rich man bad!”

      calling comic book characters propaganda, what’s wrong with you?! you think the writers of these characters have some kind of secret cabal where they purposely write great things about rich people just to make actual rich people look good?!

      your perspective is skewed and you need to re-evaluate it.

      • @Seasm0ke
        link
        English
        1321 days ago

        It isnt so much direct propaganda as conditioned propaganda. Stan Lee was a playwright for the us army a title I believe less than 10 people held at the time. He spent his late teens and early 20s being the hand on the page for the voice of the US government. Being immersed in those ideals it is no wonder he regurgitated us red scare propaganda and he expressed regret for it.

        This didnt stop though and with iron man stan lee said:

        “I think I gave myself a dare. It was the height of the Cold War. The readers, the young readers, if there was one thing they hated, it was war, it was the military. So I got a hero who represented that to the hundredth degree. He was a weapons manufacturer, he was providing weapons for the Army, he was rich, he was an industrialist. I thought it would be fun to take the kind of character that nobody would like, none of our readers would like, and shove him down their throats and make them like him … And he became very popular.”

        Prpaganda is defined as

        “deliberate, systematic attempt to shape perceptions, manipulate cognitions, and direct behavior to achieve a response that furthers the desired intent of the propagandist”.

        Iron man certainly seems to fit. Remember Stan Lee was in the military when it was antifascist. As a result he was pro military and he used his position to sway people toward his own views which… were developed when writing for the army. …

        It doesn’t have to be a secret conspiracy to act as propaganda. Social conditioning reinforces it. Americas civil religion permeates every aspect of life from the pledge of allegiance in kidnergarten to the anthem at ball games. If you do not recognize it and challenge it you will repeat it.

        I personally think in the case of Batman it was less nefarious. A plot device gone awry. After all, how could a normal man compete with Superman? In our society he would have to be rich to fund his inventions and afford superhuman tools.

        • @masquenox
          link
          English
          520 days ago

          I generally agree with your post, but I’d say one correction is in order here.

          Remember Stan Lee was in the military when it was antifascist pretending to be antifascist in order to wage war on colonialist rivals.

          The US military has never been antifascist.

          • @Seasm0ke
            link
            English
            220 days ago

            Yeah I guess I should have said ‘actively killing fascists at the time’

      • @angrystego
        link
        English
        521 days ago

        I think there’s some kind of general fascination with rich people ingrained naturally in the human mind. It’s not just in comics. It’s present in many fairy tales, mythology, religious books…

        Iagree it can help the rich to get away with things. But I also think it’s not fair to blame authors for using good old archetypes, while I also support kindhearted critique of those archetypes - it’s important to understand their role in social context and to make authors aware of the downsides.

      • @masquenox
        link
        English
        120 days ago

        gives an escape to readers to fantasize about themselves as the hero?

        Your “escapist” fantasy is to be rich, dress up in tacticool BDSM-gear and be allowed to beat up working class people?

        Yes, comic books are propaganda, and the super-creep variety has always had the smell of Objectivism to it.

        It’s certainly worked on you.

      • @Nuke_the_whales
        link
        English
        121 days ago

        Sure but sometimes the times makes certain types of escapism unattractive and not fun. The idea of a good guy billionaire is not fun in 2024

        • @masquenox
          link
          English
          220 days ago

          It’s not fun in 2024 because, thanks to the internet, we now have mountains of evidence at our fingertips to prove beyond a shadow of a doubt what they really are and always have been - ie, what the leftists have been trying to tell us since forever.

    • @Nuke_the_whales
      link
      English
      621 days ago

      Can you imagine how much good he could have done, had Bruce Wayne donated all that money to school programs, while he became a politician who helped by providing services to the city.

      I remember reading Kingdom come, and Batman is a fascist by then. Old and crippled and wearing an iron man style suit. But the actual Gotham city is now monitored by bat robots who watch everyone and keep them in line.

      • @masquenox
        link
        English
        320 days ago

        and Batman is a fascist by then.

        I’d say that Batman is fundamentally fascist. He wages war on the working class so that crime can be preserved as an activity reserved for the class Bruce Wayne represents - the capitalist one.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    2321 days ago

    You call them both innovators.

    What has Musk innovated?

    Buying other people’s ideas doesn’t count.

  • @AngryCommieKender
    link
    English
    2221 days ago

    Elon wants to be Stark. He’s actually Iron Monger. He wants to be Stark so fucking badly.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      421 days ago

      From the article:

      Back in 2016, Iron Man director Jon Favreau revealed that Musk had been a direct inspiration for their version of Tony Stark. Downey Jr even spent time with Musk to better understand what it would be like to walk in the shoes of a real-world tech mogul.

      • Chaotic Entropy
        link
        fedilink
        English
        321 days ago

        At most, Elon Musk is Tony Stark with none of the redemption ark that Stark got. That’s assuming he isn’t just the purse string holder that he is.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        321 days ago

        “This is what rich guys act like”

        “Oh, except you’ll be playing one who is actually quite intelligent”

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1821 days ago

    Musk has much in common with Tony Stark though

    Mainly being egocentric and a POS human.

    The difference is that Tony had a character development that made him more likable, while Musk became more hated.

    That and the genius bit, of course.

    • @TheRedSpade
      link
      English
      1621 days ago

      And he’s incapable of creating anything. And he has zero charisma.

  • @Subtracty
    link
    English
    1521 days ago

    His cameo in the 2nd Iron Man movie always felt so cringey to me. I don’t know how it came about, but I like to imagine Musk asked the production for the role. It is so clear to me that he desperately wants to be seen as the man who will single handedly save the world. His companies do incredibly impressive things, I cannot discredit the work of SpaceX, but the more he speaks, the more I am convinced that he is just an egomaniac cosplaying as a genius.

    • @abbotsbury
      link
      English
      1021 days ago

      I don’t know how it came about

      iirc the facility that we see housing the evil iron man ripoff suits was a SpaceX facility irl