Do you know a long song that doesn’t repeat itself and sort of tells a story through music (maybe without words)?

  • @TheOneAndOnly
    cake
    link
    103 days ago

    Dating myself a bit here, but Meatloaf’s Paradise By The Dashboard Light, and Billy Joel’s Scenes from an Italian Restaurant are 2 that need to be on this list.

  • @Jarix
    link
    43 days ago

    City Hall by Tenacious D

  • @Leavingoldhabits
    link
    1
    edit-2
    2 days ago

    If you like jazz piano, Keith Jarret’s köln concert is a masterpiece.

    There were a bunch of issues with the venue and he ended up playing the whole thing on a broken piano.

    This video sums up how the peice happened.

    And this is recording

    Edit: I like to think it’s a story of stacked disasters and a master artist somehow making the whole mess gorgeous.

  • @sga
    link
    33 days ago

    there is a hindi song which is sorta long (5 mins without music, 6 with) - Breathless (not really breathless, but full song done in just 16 breaths(that is roughly 3 per minute), but almost none are easily audible) - it is a romance story - meetup - love blossom - heart break - life ruined - reunion - together forever. The lyricist is one of the best hindi/urdu lyricist, maybe among the best in the world

    also there are many old classical concerts (for example - beethoven) which are music only and at times were in conjunction with plays or dramas going through stories

  • @BassTurd
    link
    124 days ago

    Most of Coheed and Cambria’s albums follow along with a graphic novel written by Claudio, the lead singer. I’ve never read them and don’t know the story, but if you listen to an album start to finish, you can tell that it’s more than just lyrics.

      • @BassTurd
        link
        12 days ago

        Ten Speed of God’s Blood and Burial. Perfectly clear.

    • @Shelbyeileen
      link
      23 days ago

      The Coheed and Cambria comics are awesome. They’re hard to get your hands on, after Umbrella Academy got popular, but worth it.

    • @LordCrom
      link
      33 days ago

      Cats in the cradle, has no one said this one 😭 😭 😭

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    33 days ago

    I figured there’d be plenty of mentions of Rush’s 2112, but they have a lot of other songs that fit the bill too. The Necromancer, Fountain of Lamneth, Xanadu, Natural Science (well I guess that’s more of a rant than a story), Cygnes X-1 books 1 and 2. Since you say maybe without words, La Villa Strangiato.

    If you want to stick to classic prog then Yes has some songs that fit the bill too like America and Harold Land. I confess to not really understanding the lyrics of most of the rest of Yes’s discography, they can be really poetic, but I think the whole Closer to the Edge album fits on it’s musicality alone. The title track’s a freaking journey.

    Led Zeppelin has a few of these too, though musically they are a little repetitive. Achilles Last Stand, Battle of Evermore, Gallows Pole.