• @insaneinthemembrane
    link
    608 hours ago

    Can someone explain this to a non US person please? You sign your votes?

    • @AlpacaChariot
      link
      English
      94 hours ago

      Yep, we have the same system in the UK. In fact, the envelope looks almost exactly the same so they might even be printed by the same company.

      You get two envelopes (one big, one small), a postal voting statement, and a ballot paper.

      The actual ballot paper just has a list of options for you to put your X against; there’s no personally identifiable information on it. Once you’ve filled it out you seal it in the small envelope.

      You then fill in the voting statement (it has your name and address on it so they can cross your name off as voted, and you sign it so they can check your signature matches the one on file) and both that and the sealed ballot go in the big envelope. That way your vote is still private because they check the vote is valid in one step and then add your ballot to a pile to be counted with the others in a second step, at which point it’s anonymous.

      https://www.electoralcommission.org.uk/voting-and-elections/ways-vote/how-vote-post

      • @Dkarma
        link
        -102 hours ago

        Wrong. We don’t sign our ballots.

        Stop talking.

    • @FlexibleToast
      link
      2
      edit-2
      3 hours ago

      I could be mistaken, but most places check your signature against the voter roll. If your signature doesn’t match, then they’ll ask for an ID. At least that’s how it was where I volunteered in 2020. This is done before you get your ballot. You don’t actually sign the ballot itself.

    • Match!!
      link
      fedilink
      English
      196 hours ago

      something you have to remember about the US is that while it’s a democracy, all the democratic practices were started in the 1800s, often with explicit intention to negate the votes of some discriminated group

      • modifier
        link
        fedilink
        176 hours ago

        And one party is doing their best to keep that heritage of disenfranchisement alive.

    • @Khanzarate
      link
      678 hours ago

      For mail-ins, yeah, you sign it to do the final “I authorize this document to be my vote”.

      If you don’t authorize it, it’s not legally your vote.

        • @lectricleopard
          link
          126 hours ago

          There’s a difference, signing the book is done before you vote in person in ny, and is not associated with your ballot or who you voted for. So in person there’s no way to know who you voted for.

          • @atomicorange
            link
            11 hour ago

            For mail-in, you don’t sign the ballot itself. You sign the envelope, which is used to validate / track who voted, but is then separated from the actual ballot before counting so there’s no way to track who you voted for.

    • @FlowVoid
      link
      English
      18
      edit-2
      6 hours ago

      You sign the envelope that contains the ballot. That way, an election worker can compare the signature on the envelope to your signature on file.

      This is how they make sure that someone didn’t steal the ballot from your mailbox and fill it out for you.

      Once the signature is verified, the envelope is opened and the anonymous ballot inside is removed and stored with all the others. When they are counted, there will be no way to tell who filled out each ballot.

      • @mkwt
        link
        65 hours ago

        When I did absentee voting, the voter signature and voter id information were on a perforated slip attached to the outside of the envelope.

        That way, the process is something like:

        1. Look at the slip. Verify voter signature, eligibility to vote, and mark as having voted in the voter rolls.
        2. Detach perforated slip from sealed envelope. Sealed envelope now contains no identifying information. (This envelope was mailed inside an outer mailing envelope.)
        3. Entire sealed envelope and contents thereof goes into big bin of accepted ballots.
        4. Later, election workers open the sealed envelopes from the bin and run the actual ballot papers through the scantron machine.
      • Tarquinn2049
        link
        35 hours ago

        And yet the “scary machines” are too easy to tamper with… they are scared of them because of how hard it would be to get away with tampering with them. And they know their supporters and others in government don’t know any better and will jump on the bandwagon of the machines being vaguely scary.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          14 hours ago

          As I understand it, a fairly bulletproof method is to vote using a machine that prints out a human readable card with a punch through the candidates you voted for. So you can confirm the machine understood the options you tapped and then drop the paper ballot into a secure box, which can be used as a backup for manual recounts.

          Anybody know if this is what the experts [still] want?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      65 hours ago

      The key point is that if it’s not signed, it gives them an excuse to throw it away.

      Do that to enough people and you end up with a big problem. The uncounted votes could swing the election, or you get a messy court case where some judges step in and basically decide the election on their own, or who knows what else.

      At a minimum, it’s sets the stage for chaos. And from the chaos can emerge a chaotic outcome.

    • @krelvar
      link
      218 hours ago

      For mail in balloting at least in my state you sign the return envelope NOT the ballot itself.

      • femtech
        link
        fedilink
        137 hours ago

        In Illinois they give you two, well 3 technically. The one everything comes in, the one you put the ballot in, and the one you put the ballot envelope in. So the signature is not on the outside or on the ballot itself.

    • @seaQueue
      link
      208 hours ago

      I’ve always had to sign my vote by mail ballot envelope in CA. They keep a signature on file from when you last registered to absentee (not vote at your polling place) vote and compare the two to see if someone else is trying to vote in your name.

    • @UnpopularCrowOP
      link
      168 hours ago

      In order for a mail in ballot to be valid, the person must sign the envelope.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      36 hours ago

      just imagine gremlins running around in your election system at every level. thats pretty much whats happening