They were found in gutters, on streets, in bushes. They were boarded on trains, deserted in hospitals, dumped at temples. They were sent away for being sick or outliving paychecks or simply growing too old.

By the time they reached this home for the aged and unwanted, many were too numb to speak. Some took months to mouth the truth of how they came to spend their final days in exile.

“They said, ‘Taking care of him is not our cup of tea,’” says Amirchand Sharma, 65, a retired policeman whose sons left him to die near the river after he was badly hurt in an accident. “They said, ‘Throw him away.’”

In its traditions, in its religious tenets and in its laws, India has long cemented the belief that it is a child’s duty to care for his aging parents. But in a land known for revering its elderly, a secret shame has emerged: A burgeoning population of older people abandoned by their own families.

This is a country where grandparents routinely share a roof with children and grandchildren, and where the expectation that the young care for the old is so ingrained in the national ethos that nursing homes are a relative rarity and hiring caregivers is often seen as taboo. But expanding lifespans have brought ballooning caregiving pressure, a wave of urbanization has driven many young far from their home villages and a creeping Western influence has begun eroding the tradition of multigenerational living.

Courtrooms swell with thousands of cases of parents seeking help from their children. Footpaths and alleys are crowded with older people who now call them home. And a cottage industry of nonprofits for the abandoned has sprouted, operating a constantly growing number of shelters that continually fill.

  • SaltySalamander
    link
    fedilink
    1303 months ago

    Makes one wonder just how shitty were these elders to their children and grandchildren?

    • Beacon
      link
      fedilink
      88
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      Yeah the things that the elders say sound like typical narcissist parent quotes. "[My kids abandoned me because] they said ‘Taking care of him is not our cup of tea.” That’s sounds extremely unlikely. I would guess you didn’t want to hear the very justified exact reasons why they didn’t want you in their life anymore.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        443 months ago

        If my mother wasn’t a terrible person, a liar, and a manipulator, I wouldn’t have abandoned her when she finally broke the camels back.

      • mommykink
        link
        English
        32
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        "[My kids abandoned me because] they said ‘Taking care of him is not our cup of tea.” That’s sounds extremely unlikely

        My thoughts too. The person you’re quoting is apparently just 65, too, and a retired police officer. Obviously I’m just talking out of my ass here, but that sounds way too young to at the point of requiring full-time caregiving. I’m thinking there’s something more at play beyond what he’s letting on, but I could obviously be wrong

          • mommykink
            link
            English
            143 months ago

            Ah yeah I guess if I had the reading comprehension of an adult man and not a fucking chickadee I’d have seen that in the next sentence.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              13 months ago

              Idk that you have the right to throw stones dude, you haven’t figured out you can make a username without your birth year in it.

      • @Zachariah
        link
        English
        63 months ago

        Whose responsibility was it to help that be their cup of tea?

    • @The_v
      link
      English
      263 months ago

      I haven’t spoken to my parents in over a decade. They are really shitty people.

      I have entertained myself reviewed nursing homes looking for the one with the absolute worst reviews for them to finish their lives at.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        193 months ago

        This. If my parents hadn’t been gracious enough to die painfully from cancer, this would have been the next option.

        Not all elders deserve support, respect or compassion.

      • @Soggy
        link
        English
        13 months ago

        “Then we’ll put you in the crooked home we saw on 60 Minutes!”

    • @venusaur
      link
      English
      -18
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      Partly this and it’s the Western way. Leave your elders in a home, except [in India] they can’t afford a home so they go to the streets.

      • @takeda
        link
        English
        263 months ago

        No one would leave their parents on the streets if they had a good relationship with them. At the very least they would let them live in their homes.

        • @dtrain
          link
          English
          33 months ago

          Presuming the children have the means to support their parents and their immediate family.

          If not, a tough decision must be made.

          • @takeda
            link
            English
            63 months ago

            I didn’t say you would be able to provide the care they need, but if you love them, you would always find some space in your home so they are not on the street.

        • @braindamagebuddy
          link
          English
          23 months ago

          What about the children who can only afford a bedroom. Tough luck I guess.

          • @takeda
            link
            English
            93 months ago

            No matter how small a place is I imagine you would always figure out some space for your parents instead of sending them to the streets.

            You might not be able to provide adequate help they need, but I think if you love your parents you wouldn’t let them stay on the street.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              9
              edit-2
              3 months ago

              Literally for most of history the peasant home was one room. Grandparents, parents and their 5 surviving children were all crammed in there at night. Privacy was not a thing. What I mean is, there’s a long way to fall before true necessity comes into the picture, and as things get worse families tend to stick together more.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        10
        edit-2
        3 months ago

        Yeah, I’m going to echo the other poster. Our cultural maladaptations might be a good excuse, but you have to know what’s actually going to happen to mom on some level.

        Fun fact, it’s becoming more common to live with extended family in the West, mostly just because life is getting too expensive otherwise.

        • @venusaur
          link
          English
          6
          edit-2
          3 months ago

          In the west we emphasize the unnatural independence of our babies (e.g. cry it out) leading to adults who have unnatural detachments to their parents, leaving them in homes. That’s only part of it though. Also children who are growing up to realize that they are not obliged to keeping their abusive parents in their lives.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            3
            edit-2
            3 months ago

            Now that’s too far in the opposite direction. Cultures are kind of random; presumably lots of other cultures have attitudes towards infant care that are similar, or even less “attentive”. I forget which Native culture around here had the trick where you mess with your baby’s nose so they stop crying altogether.

            I suspect it’s less child psychology and more recent history. Traditionally, extended families often lived together in the West too. It just went away during the 20th century due to a confluence of ideological emphasis on the nuclear family and enough money sloshing around the common classes for people to actually implement that.

            • @venusaur
              link
              English
              03 months ago

              If what you’re saying is that it stems from capitalism, then yes. I agree that’s the root cause and the rest are symptoms.

        • @venusaur
          link
          English
          -13 months ago

          Edited my original comment. Does your comment still stand?

      • @SkunkWorkz
        link
        English
        53 months ago

        The biggest reason for putting parents in an elderly home here in the West is because these elders require constant medical care that their kids can’t provide.

        • @venusaur
          link
          English
          03 months ago

          “That their kids can’t provide” needs to be explained. Often it means they don’t have time or desire to.

          From the post, “They were sent away for being sick, Or outliving paychecks, or simply growing too old.”

          Same situation in US, except we have social security. Old people get sent to homes for being sick or too old all the time.

          • @SkunkWorkz
            link
            English
            23 months ago

            People suffering from dementia require around the clock specialized care. That’s something a person that isn’t educated in that field can’t give. And since dementia is on the rise it’s the number one reason why old people are put into a care home. At least in my country. In my country the stereo typical retirement home doesn’t exist anymore. Most old people stay in their own home and they get help at home by a professional and family members. They won’t be send into a home unless they require around the clock care.

          • Doom
            link
            fedilink
            English
            23 months ago

            No it doesn’t really. Their kids cannot provide it. That’s that?

            • @venusaur
              link
              English
              13 months ago

              They could provide it, but they don’t want to sacrifice their personal time.

          • YeetPics
            link
            fedilink
            English
            13 months ago

            Retirement homes ≠ being discarded on the streets though, does it?

            You can’t blame teh west for every failing of eastern culture. Apples to figs.

            • @venusaur
              link
              English
              13 months ago

              Cultural similarities do not include financial aspects. They could have adopted the cultural aspect but do not have the same financial benefits, so they’re on the streets. Why is this being debated? People offended cuz they put their parents in homes?

      • YeetPics
        link
        fedilink
        English
        13 months ago

        Ah okay, so it’s the same until you look at the details at which point it becomes extremely differentiated.

        Lmao.

        • @venusaur
          link
          English
          13 months ago

          No it is the same in many ways. If they’re sick or too old they go to a home except in India they can’t afford a home so they go to the streets. Same happens here but less so.

  • rand_alpha19
    link
    fedilink
    733 months ago

    I’m never gonna own a home, I can’t afford to care for my parents. A nursing home is absolutely out of the question if I’m the one on the hook. It’s hard to imagine it being easier in India with the work conditions and wages there.

    • @Nuke_the_whales
      link
      English
      273 months ago

      I’ve just accepted that I’m gonna rack up credit I never intend to pay and die. And I live in a country that isn’t gonna throw that debt on my kids

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        93 months ago

        I’m making sure I have great credit for as long as I can so when im 60-70 I can just get a huge line of credit and go nuts. I don’t plan on having any kids to worry about my belongings/debt/estate etc.

          • @kevindqc
            link
            English
            23 months ago

            What if you get it earlier but don’t use it?

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              23 months ago

              They don’t give it to you at 0% apr. Most credit cards have insane rates above 20%. They can and will come after just about everything you own.

              • @kevindqc
                link
                English
                13 months ago

                They charge you money if your balance is 0? Well not here

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  13 months ago

                  Oh you meant credit line, not credit? They will quickly shrink that if not used. All the credit cards I haven’t used for a while reduced their credit lines wiltin a few years. Some by as much as 10x.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              2
              edit-2
              3 months ago

              That’s the plan, currently half way to 60 and have a $20,000 line of credit so hoping I can get it up quite a bit before 60 😂

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      173 months ago

      Begin voting for caring governments, who will first consolidate and bargain for elderly care expenses, and then take on the job of elder care itself. It’s been shown that removing the mercenary aspect and keeping the service level objectives and performance an openly-discussed metric will result in improved care, longer life and reduced expenses.

      It also makes rich assholes pay more for everyone’s care, which is kinda neat for me despite maybe being in the top 20%.

        • YeetPics
          link
          fedilink
          English
          1
          edit-2
          3 months ago

          Contrarian bullshit?

          OR do you have an actual point?

          What I can parse out is “if my kid wanted to have a stable home life, they should cry less”.

    • @Passerby6497
      link
      English
      53 months ago

      That would require me to be ashamed of my choice lol.

  • BrightCandle
    link
    English
    233 months ago

    This is actually the normal around the globe. We are kind of told that we look after the frail and disabled and our family but as countless disabled people have been explaining for centuries now this just isn’t the case, its one of the biggest lies ever told about human behaviour. Its shocking that governments are still shocked by this behaviour but it goes to show how deep the propaganda has got into people.

    Human beings do not look after the chronically unwell, whether it be from age or otherwise. Almost all close family abandon them, it is abnormal for anyone from someones friends of families to even see them again after about 2 to 3 years. This is the true reality of human behaviour and the disabled have been trying to get this message across for decades and no one is listening.

    • @SeattleRain
      link
      English
      13 months ago

      We are kind of told that we look after the frail and disabled and our family but as countless disabled people have been explaining for centuries now this just isn’t the case, its one of the biggest lies ever told about human behaviour.

      Had no idea about this kind of history. Are there books about this you can recommend. I would like to know more.

  • @SirDerpy
    link
    English
    21
    edit-2
    3 months ago

    1st gen US of a north-south love marriage.

    Remember why immigrants come to the US: The same hustle yields greater success due to lessened competition for greater resources. It’s worse wherever they came from.

    Remember that good and bad family is somewhat universal across cultures. People care for their elderly because they continue to contribute to the family unit in facets such as meals, cleaning, childcare, wisdom. People cohabitate because there’s competitive strength in a larger family unit.

    Relative the US, India has roughly three times the population and one third the geographic area. They want to care for their good parents and offer the bad ones a humane somethhing, just as everyone does. Capitalism crushes them as it does us. They just have less. They can’t afford to house and feed their parents.

  • Lucy :3
    link
    fedilink
    English
    123 months ago

    Yeah no shit. That wasn’t like really obvious that that would start to happen at some point.

  • @assassin_aragorn
    link
    English
    123 months ago

    This is a pretty big deal in Indian culture. Respecting and listening to elders is actually a cornerstone, I’d say. At social events with potlucks, the young kids are always the first to eat, then the elders, then everyone else. It’s so ingrained in me that when I saw a young Indian kid mocking their grandmother I was utterly shocked.

    However, this isn’t to say the children in this article are necessarily wrong to abandon their parents. It’s just some perspective on how big of a deal this is.

    Although at the same time, I’ve noticed that second generation Indians (born to the parents who immigrated, like me) are taught a more traditional and conservative culture. The first generation Indians I’ve met seem a lot less traditional – hence why they’re probably more okay with abandoning their elders. It’s interesting sometimes how immigrants preserve their home culture and traditions better than their own home does. Granted, this isn’t the case with everything. There’s a lot of things where Indian kids who grew up in the West are far more liberal on.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      173 months ago

      … this is Indians in India, they’re not okay with it because they’re “first generation Indians” they’re like 10,000th generation Indians in their own country not America.

      • @assassin_aragorn
        link
        English
        13 months ago

        I never disagreed with that. I’m just offering my perspective as someone familiar with the cultural traditions.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      13
      edit-2
      3 months ago

      I wouldn’t abandon my grandparents if something had happened and they needed a home… But I liked my grandparents. I like my parents. If your kid won’t let you live with them even if they can’t themselves take care of you, something else is going on besides selfishness.

    • Peace
      link
      fedilink
      English
      103 months ago

      This is common across all cultures, the youth are always called “disrespectful” relative to the older generation.

      Access to global media may have caused a more drastic change in some regions

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        43 months ago

        Not just all cultures, all eras as well. From Mesopotamian stone slates over medieval hogshide, paper to the internet: boomers gonna complain

    • femtech
      link
      fedilink
      English
      93 months ago

      Finally not being forced to care for their abusers.

  • @alekwithak
    link
    English
    113 months ago

    Capitalism does it again!

  • @TechNerdWizard42
    link
    English
    83 months ago

    It may be a secret shame in India, but it’s a public shame in the US that the rest of the world doesn’t understand.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    33 months ago

    I reckon the “shame” here is on the parents’ side for failing to live on their own?

    • YeetPics
      link
      fedilink
      English
      03 months ago

      When your children are tools for building family power via arranged marriages, I can see this being a thing. Down the line.