Right, but I’m saying that the process that a mistaken human is using here is actually not that different from what the AI is doing. People would misread the passage because they expect the number 20 to be followed by the word “pounds” based on their previous encounters with similar texts.
No, it’s not misreading anything. It isn’t reading at all. It just sees a string that is similar to other strings that it’s trained on, and knows the most likely sequence to follow is what it output. There is not comprehension. There is no reading. There is no thought. The process isn’t similar to what a human might do, only the result is.
But what we’re saying is that the process is totally different - it’s only the result that is similar. The AI isn’t “misreading” the question - it understands that it’s comparing pounds of bricks to a distinct number of feathers. The issue is that when it searches its database for answers to questions similar to the one it was asked, and sees that the answer was “they’re the same,” and incorrectly assumes that the answer is the same for this question. It’s a fundamental problem with the way AI works, that can’t be solved with a simple correction about how it’s interpreting the question the way a human misreading the question could be.
Right, but I’m saying that the process that a mistaken human is using here is actually not that different from what the AI is doing. People would misread the passage because they expect the number 20 to be followed by the word “pounds” based on their previous encounters with similar texts.
No, it’s not misreading anything. It isn’t reading at all. It just sees a string that is similar to other strings that it’s trained on, and knows the most likely sequence to follow is what it output. There is not comprehension. There is no reading. There is no thought. The process isn’t similar to what a human might do, only the result is.
But what we’re saying is that the process is totally different - it’s only the result that is similar. The AI isn’t “misreading” the question - it understands that it’s comparing pounds of bricks to a distinct number of feathers. The issue is that when it searches its database for answers to questions similar to the one it was asked, and sees that the answer was “they’re the same,” and incorrectly assumes that the answer is the same for this question. It’s a fundamental problem with the way AI works, that can’t be solved with a simple correction about how it’s interpreting the question the way a human misreading the question could be.