• Dimi Fisher
    link
    76 hours ago

    Officially the first post I really laughed on lemmy! The future seems bright! 🤣

  • @Etterra
    link
    710 hours ago

    I say the left but double the length of the arms.

  • Dogeek
    link
    fedilink
    1612 hours ago

    Neither, a centaur has a human torso starting at the base of the neck, the left one has a long neck so clearly not a human torso. The left one has a long torso, so that doesn’t fit either.

    Solution: it’d be exactly like a regular centaur but with a different skin pattern

    • @portuga
      link
      412 hours ago

      We’d have to start evolution again because all mammals have four limbs, and four only. That’s why we can’t have pegasus (pegasi?) either. Bummer, I know.

      • udon
        link
        211 hours ago

        Isn’t a pegasus a bird? Would that mean that they lay eggs?

        • HeuristicAlgorithm9
          link
          fedilink
          19 hours ago

          Biology definitions are not based in causation, it wouldn’t lay eggs just cuz we call it a bird. It might be like the anti-platypus tho, the only bird to give birth to live young

        • @portuga
          link
          211 hours ago

          You may be on to something

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    39 hours ago

    Now do giraffe fauns. At least giraffe centaurs have those counterbalancing rear legs, giraffe fauns would need to be half as wide as they are tall to have abs strong enough to keep themselves upright. And with those tiny spindly legs they have, even if they do leg day religiously and bulk them up they’ll still be teetering about on two little hooves.

  • udon
    link
    711 hours ago

    Why not scale up the size of the human so it fits with both solutions?

    • @portuga
      link
      311 hours ago

      It’s funnier this way?

      • udon
        link
        17 hours ago

        I think a huge human torso on top of a giraffe could also look funny enough

  • @BowtiesAreCool
    link
    3422 hours ago

    Centaurs don’t have horse necks so neither is right. It would be the body of a giraffe with a human torso starting where the neck would start

      • @Cort
        link
        819 hours ago

        Nah, just like a normal centaur but with long spindly giraffe legs

  • Pirky
    link
    95
    edit-2
    1 day ago

    The left one. It’s the Giraffe’s neck that’s long. Not their torso.

    Edit: See Derpleton from Centaurworld.

    • @FilthyShrooms
      link
      3422 hours ago

      Counterargument: a centaur is a human torso on a horse’s neck, so it’s the right one

      • @bitwaba
        link
        211 hours ago

        A giraffe is a horse with a long neck.

        A giraffe centaur is a centaur with a long neck.

        QED

        • Fushuan [he/him]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          210 hours ago

          A centaur is a horse with human torso after the neck, so a giraffe centaur is a horse with a long neck and a human torso after the neck. Right is justice.

        • @portuga
          link
          211 hours ago

          What if horses are instead giraffes with short necks? Checkmate atheists

      • @BatmanAoD
        link
        518 hours ago

        But the human portion has normal human proportions (though potentially scaled up a little). Why would being on a giraffe’s body change that?

        • Fushuan [he/him]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          2
          edit-2
          6 hours ago

          Exactly, the left one warps the human proportions while the right one extends the giraffe neck that connects with the human torso. The right one is more natural.

        • @FilthyShrooms
          link
          4
          edit-2
          18 hours ago

          Because the one on the right is funnier

    • @Valmond
      link
      51 day ago

      How does he pick his nose or brush his teeth?

    • Lemminary
      link
      1622 hours ago

      What in the fresh hell is this? 💀

      • @finitebanjo
        link
        2322 hours ago

        Centaur World is a story about a war horse that accidentally falls into Centaur World full of happy cartoon centaurs that happen to speak horse or whatever.

        • FenrirIII
          link
          37 hours ago

          They speak English. Horse is magicked with the ability to speak by going to CW

      • Pirky
        link
        1222 hours ago

        That’s Derpleton from Centaurworld. Is a weird, but good show. Would recommend.

        • @captainlezbian
          link
          4
          edit-2
          10 hours ago

          I felt ridiculous watching it but it was so good. It’s the sort of show I plan to pull out to be the fun aunt alongside Avatar. I didn’t expect for it to make me cry but it did

      • @ynthrepic
        link
        1122 hours ago

        Centaur World is incredible. Best kids show I’ve seen as an adult. They need your viewership to make more crazy stuff.

  • @wjrii
    link
    English
    261 day ago

    Neither. The neck is the long part, and do horse-based centaurs have horse necks?

    Giraffe centaurs would be underwhelming.

    • work is slow
      link
      111 day ago

      Fuck, this really opened my eyes. You ruined giraffe centaurs for me. D:

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      41 day ago

      But in a centaur, the human torso is placed where the horse neck would be. If it was the torso that was replaced they would look more like satyrs.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        422 hours ago

        The torso is a tricky concept, there’s no good anatomical definition that makes sense. Is the pelvis included? The whole axial skeleton? Everyone knows the general idea of where the torso is, but it’s hard to define with precision.

      • @wjrii
        link
        English
        51 day ago

        But in a centaur, the human torso is placed where the horse neck would be.

        Yes, with a perfectly normal human torso. Put a human torso in the same spot and…

        BOOOORRRING!! 🤣

    • @tourist
      link
      361 day ago

      bro how did I get sensory overload from a black and white image

      • @Thatuserguy
        link
        41 day ago

        That’s why I read this shit with fan colorings. I think my brain would literally not be able to process what’s going on without it

  • @kemsat
    link
    419 hours ago

    The right one. A centaur is a horse with a human torso replacing the horse’s neck & head. So it’s one of those humans with the long torso, you know the type.

  • bruhduh
    link
    419 hours ago

    Like it or not, this is peak male performance

  • ✺roguetrick✺
    link
    5
    edit-2
    17 hours ago

    Giraffes are Artiodactyla like cattle so they would be closer in minotaur style than the Perissodactyla centaur style. Two hoofed legs, human upper body, long neck and giraffe head.

    Speaking of Perissodactyla, this guy essentially is a fantasy creature. He’s the centaur she told you not to worry about.